Education

'Nobody Will Hear Our Voices if We Are Silenced Behind Walls': Students, Parents Critical of District's Handling of Summit Middle School Walkout

8d2dc9cd0592e91ef240_df3942c0c34556b0cfbe_Screen_Shot_2018-03-16_at_10.34.55_AM.jpg
From left, Ravi Naidu, Joanna Geci, and Zachary Siegel were among a series of students who addressed the Board. Credits: Melanie Wilson
8d2dc9cd0592e91ef240_df3942c0c34556b0cfbe_Screen_Shot_2018-03-16_at_10.34.55_AM.jpg

SUMMIT, NJ - Students and parents alike, with one exception, voiced their disagreement -- during the public comment section of last night's Board of Education Meeting -- with how the Summit Public School District handled the March 14 school walkout at Summit's Lawton C. Johnson Summit Middle School (LCJSMS).

District administrators and officials responded by saying the plan and its implementation were prompted solely by student-centric safety concerns and came as a result of the school's athletic field currently being covered by snow.

A series of poised, articulate middle schoolers took to the podium in the Summit High School Media Center to express their disappointment in not being able to leave the building during the March 14 National School Walkout to protest gun violence, which was held exactly one-month after a mass shooting that claimed 17 lives at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, FL.

Sign Up for E-News

The plan to walkout of the middle school to the rear field was changed last minute, with students who had submitted the required permission slips allowed to walk out of their classrooms at 10 a.m. but not permitted to exit the building, with Summit Police officers and teachers stationed at each of the doors. Instead, the students who left their classrooms were directed to the school's Auditorium.

Student Ravi Naidu, son of current Summit Common Council President David Naidu, said, “The point of the walkout was not simply to ‘walk out’ — it was designed to allow students to express their opinions and have them heard by others, such as government representatives. Staying in the Auditorium defeated the main point of the walkout.”

Another student, Zachary Siegel, said, “Limiting us to the Auditorium defeated the whole purpose of the walkout because we could not publicly take a stand and add our voices to the thousands of others who were joining together to demand better gun laws and safer schools. The communities where these shootings have happened, towns like Parkland and Newtown, are wealthy, quiet communities that remind me a lot of Summit. If these acts of violence can happen there, then they can happen anywhere, so we must be able to take a stand for our own safety.”

Siegel added, “Going to school isn’t only about learning, but also about developing children’s character. If people want to protest, let them protest. Nobody will hear our voices if we are silenced behind walls.".

In a letter addressed to parents Thursday, LCJSMS Principal Damen Cooper apologized for the last-minute location change, and said that the large amount of snow on the field prevented the students from using it. “Despite the change in venue, students were still able to express themselves peacefully. Please know that safety was our main concern through the entire process,” he wrote.

Many of the students who spoke acknowledged Cooper’s letter, but were not satisfied. Gabby Ma said, “To use snow as an excuse is just wrong. How is three inches of snow going to get in the way of us walking? We could have just walked on the sidewalk. The worst part was they were going to make us sit in silence which was not what we were originally told. I heard that Washington Elementary school had a fire drill. Snow wasn’t keeping them from walking outside. Also, the high school got to do an actual walkout but why weren’t we? Why couldn’t we do a peaceful protest for just 17 minutes outside? All I wanted to do was get my voice heard about gun control and my thoughts on the Parkland school shooting heard.”

About 10 students in total spoke, including Lilian Betz, Madison DeGennaro, Joanna Geci, Edward Vela on behalf of another student, and Cammy Barrett.

The students that addressed the school body were praised by Board President Rick Hanley. “I am impressed and proud of the students for speaking in a respectful way.” He also commended Superintendent of Schools June Chang and the building supervisors for ensuring the safety needs of the students.  

Middle School Parent Julie Latzer questioned the District policy on the walkout and how the decision was made that the middle schoolers would stay inside.  

Chang said that there was “no decision to be made.”  “If they walkout, they walkout."

He reiterated his statements made at Monday night’s Board of Education meeting, that the walkout was not a school-sanctioned event, but stated that the District did try to provide safe areas for the students to walkout. This was possible behind the high school where there was turf, he said, but because of the snow in the back of LCJSMS it was not feasible. The front of the school is on Morris Avenue, and he said that area was too open. “The whole world would know where they would be,” he said.

Latzer said that with teachers and police officers stationed at the doors the students felt that they couldn’t walk out.  

Middle School Parent Hazel Siegel said that having the teachers and police blocking the doors created “an intimidating and scary environment, exactly the opposite of what the walkout is supposed to do," and added that, perhaps, the school and the administration did not realize how much “standing up and saying enough is enough” meant to the students.

Chang said that it was a safety decision.  

Kristen Pierotti, LCJSMS parent and co-president of the school's PTO, said, “The children’s ability to protest was squelched.”

The opposite view was expressed by parent Vickie Freeman, whose husband James is a former Board of Education member, who said that she was impressed and pleased with the way the District handled the event. Freeman noted that there are two sides to every issue, and that different families have different views.

Reading letters she sent to Chang, Cooper, Summit High School Principal Stacy Grimaldi, and Lincoln-Hubbard Principal Matt Carlin, which thank them collectively for their "calm and sensible leadership," Freeman said, "You all perfectly balanced preparation for an event you knew would occur, with respect and understanding, while maintaining objectivity -- not endorsing or supporting it -- knowing there are two sides to every issue.

You made sure all the walkout kids were safe at all times, and showed respect for families with differing views (or who simply felt it was not for them) in that learning continued for those who did not choose to participate in the walkout.

You communicated clearly and early with parents about expectations and requirements for participation. (And when some offered flawed interpretations, you immediately responded to the school community to calmly clarify the guidelines.)

You also rightly understood that the subject matter inspiring the event today was mature in nature and might be scary for young kids. So you addressed that at the elementary schools with age appropriate guidance & protocol."

She said that she hoped that the District would not “spend another minute of time on this, and that the people would take their concerns to the legislators. “Let everyone get back to work."

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

Summit

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_7be61d8c0218a63463d0_4f185ba72d5296e67c72_adobestock_74413077_mother_goose

Tue, April 24, 10:00 AM

Summit Free Public Library, Summit

Ages 6 mo.-2 yrs.: Mother Goose Mornings

Arts & Entertainment Education

Carousel_image_c59277305d03a4dae3a5_4164c2471f3c198c0cc5_storytime_0317

Tue, April 24, 10:00 AM

Summit Free Public Library, Summit

Mother Goose Mornings

Arts & Entertainment Education

Carousel_image_ff35ab71e957e9734489_jump_in_swim

Tue, April 24, 11:00 AM

The Connection, Summit

Jump In & Swim

Arts & Entertainment

Summit Fire Department Blotter

02/01/2018, 7:26 am - FD dispatched to Route 78 East Bound mile marker 47.2 for a reported motor vehicle accident with entrapment and injuries. On arrival both the Springfield and Summit Fire Departments set up for extrication. The vehicle was chocked to stabilize the vehicle. EMS performed patient care. A hose line was stretched for possible fire suppression by the Berkeley Heights FD.

Summit Police Blotter

April 11, 2018

3/13 - Jayhee Cho, 32, of Summit was arrested and charged with criminal mischief. Mr. Cho was processed and released with a pending court date.

3/13 - Aseyefigh K. Papanye, 30, of Brooklyn, New York was arrested and charged with theft of credit cards, fraudulent use of credit cards, theft by deception, theft by unlawful taking, obstruction of the administration of the law, and possession of ...

Video: Point View's Petrides Says Oil Price Hysteria Unwarranted, Talks Tech

April 23, 2018

Point View Wealth Management's Managing Director and Portfolio Manager, John Petrides, live on BNN Bloomberg discussing stocks with oil near $70 per barrel and major Tech earnings this week:

ptview.com/medias/tv-radio

​​​​​​For nearly 25 years, Point View Wealth Management, Inc. has been working with families in Summit and beyond, providing customized portfolio management ...

Video: Point View's Petrides Talks AMEX, GE and Amazon Earnings, Stock Outlook

Point View Wealth Management's Managing Director and Portfolio Manager, John Petrides, live on FOX Business AM discussing several upcoming pivotal earnings and possible market reactions:

ptview.com/medias/tv-radio

​​​​For nearly 25 years, Point View Wealth Management, Inc. has been working with families in Summit and beyond, providing customized portfolio management ...

Fear of Rising Rates? Remember The Reason You Own Bonds

If the current interest environment has you concerned about your bond portfolio, remember why you are investing in bonds.  The role bonds, or fixed income, play in a portfolio is not solely based on performance.  Bonds are used to offer stability, particularly when stock market volatility is rising. Rate hikes can dampen bond performance, but keep perspective on how rising rates impact ...

Cluelessly Clueless

I teenaged my way through high school under the assumption that my parents had no idea what I was doing.  I like to think I was pretty good at withholding information and presenting situations in ways that were other than they really were.

 

Still, sometimes they found things out.  Like the time my friends plopped me on our front door step at one o'clock in the morning ...