Resident Wants Summit Common Council to Admit Wrongdoing in Sunshine Law Violation Debate


SUMMIT, NJ – The resident who has been taking the Summit Common Council to task for a series of e-mail that the city solicitor has said were a violation of the Sunshine Law said he will continue to bring more of the e-mail before the council until the members involved admit they made a mistake.

Guy Haselmann first approached the council on Oct. 19 with 440 pages of documentation he received after filing a request under the Open Public Records Act. Haselmann said the documents are largely e-mail correspondence between four members of the council in June, in the two weeks leading up to the June 21 council meeting in which the ongoing parking issue was introduced as an ordinance. The item had been on the agenda as a discussion item, but Council President Dave Bomgaars introduced it as an ordinance and called for a vote, despite the fact that Council members Stephen Murphy, Mike Vernotico and Mayor Jordan Glatt said they had not gotten information on the ordinance. About 30 residents also at the meeting voiced their concerns and asked the council to wait on the vote until after the summer. The measure did not get enough votes to pass.

The issue revolves around a series of e-mail sent between several members of the council in the days just prior to the June 21 meeting. Portuondo and Madden discussed with Rity McNany, manager of the city’s parking agency, the details of the proposed parking ordinance that Portuondo intended to introduce at the meeting. The e-mail exchange had previously included Council members Tom Getzendanner, Ellen Dickson and Bomgaars. Dickson has publicly said she did not respond to the e-mail and can’t control who sends her messages.

Sign Up for E-News

The crux of all the messages was the introduction of the ordinance. Glatt, Vernotico and Murphy were ostensibly left out of the exchange as the other council members knew they would not support the paid-parking ordinance. When it became apparent in the exchange that there were five council members who would support the measure, it was introduced at the meeting as an ordinance. However, Dickson voted against it, so the measure failed.

When Haselmann brought the matter forward during the Oct. 19 meeting and accused the council of conducting business outside of a scheduled council meeting, Bomgaars said the strictures of OPRA and how the council acts are not easy things to comprehend, “especially for an outsider who files an OPRA request and goes through 400 pages.” He said there is nothing wrong with one, two or three council people talking among themselves.

“That’s how you do business,” he said. “We try to operate as best we can in full disclosure. Yes, we do send e-mail among one, two or three of us. We do have coffee together. We have committee meetings. You keep talking about five council members. There is nothing wrong with having five. There’s nothing wrong with having a majority of five. That’s how you do business.”

After a review of the documentation, however, City Solicitor Barry Osmun said that in his opinion, the e-mail exchange did constitute a violation of the Sunshine Act, formally called the Open Public Meetings Act. The law was enacted in 1976 to ensure that the business of government takes place at a public meeting before the eyes and ears of the citizens.

"E-mails did not exist in 1976 when OPMA was enacted," Osmun said in the memo, sent to the council on Oct. 26. "However, based on language referring to meetings by 'means of telecommunications equipment,' the statute would apply to e-mail."

Just after the memo was released, Dickson told The Alternative Press that she did not respond to the e-mail she received from Getzendanner, therefore it should not be construed as an e-mail discussion.

“I want to make it clear that I was a recipient of this email to which I did NOT respond,” Dickson said. “I had no control over it. I also voted with (Council Member Mike) Vernotico and (Council Member Stephen) Murphy against the ordinance, which was defeated.”

Murphy said the memo validates everything they had already suspected about council business being discussed via e-mail.

“We were under the belief that a violation had occurred because of a lack of transparency,” he said. “We believed they were basically cutting this deal behind the scenes. And it was validated by Barry’s memo.”

Haselmann said he only brought one e-mail to light at the Oct. 19 council meeting for the sake of simplicity, but he intends to continue to attend the meetings and bring forward more e-mail until the council members involved admit they were wrong to do business away from the public eye.

During the Summit Candidates’ Forum on Saturday, the question was raised as to whether the candidates feel the Sunshine Law was violated, and Vernotico and Dickson, both running for mayor, addressed the matter.

“If you have to discuss the nuances of the law, you’re not following the law,” Vernotico said. “I can find no reason to conduct business outside the public venue.”

Dickson again stressed that she was included in the e-mail exchange that’s been at the center of the controversy, but didn’t respond to it.

“There was no deliberation involved,” she said. “To have any kind of violation, you have to have deliberation. What about things you post on Facebook? What about texting? There hasn’t been any legal writing on any of these issues. I do think we need a refresher course on this from a lawyer who understands this part of the law. I don’t think there was any major violation, but I think we have to get clear on what’s going on.”

The council will hold its regular meeting tonight at 7:30 p.m. at city hall.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Sun, February 25, 9:30 AM

Calvary Church, Summit

Tricia Walker-Three Chords and the Truth: A ...

Arts & Entertainment


Sun, February 25, 10:00 AM

Camp Riverbend, Warren

Camp Riverbend Open House


Sun, February 25, 11:00 AM

The Connection, Summit

Rockette Style Workshop Series

Arts & Entertainment

Summit Fire Department Blotter

01/01/2018 9:26 am     FD dispatched to a motor vehicle accident, car vs. pole in front of 196 GLENSIDE AVENUE.  On arrival occupant was out of the vehicle.  Summit EMS assumed patient contact. FD made notification to the power company to make repairs.  Summit PD remained on scene for traffic control and road closure until repairs were made.

01/02/2018 7:36 pm ...

Summit Police Blotter

February 12, 2018

2/1 - At 0955 hours a report was taken for a theft of a street sign. The unlawful incident occurred between an unknown time frame on Pine Grove Avenue. Value of the street sign was not immediately available at the time of the report.

2/5 - Roberto C. Noel-Berman, 23, of Summit was arrested and charged with possession of CDS. Mr. Noel-Berman was released with a pending court date.

2/5 - ...

Lightbridge Academy in Millburn Hiring Assistant and Lead Teachers

February 23, 2018

If you are passionate about educating and nurturing young minds, you may fit right in with our family! Lightbridge Academy is currently hiring Assistant and Lead Teachers to join our team and grow with us!

If you would like to learn more about the positions offered, you can reach us at 973-218-1800.

Video: Point View's Petrides Says Market Healthy, Strong Despite Sell-Offs

Point View Wealth Management's Managing Director and Portfolio Manager, John Petrides, live on FOX Business News discussing the market sell-off post the release of the Fed Minutes:

For nearly 25 years, Point View Wealth Management, Inc. has been working with families in Summit and beyond, providing customized portfolio management services and ...

Is FAANG Long in the Tooth?

Investors love to rally around a stock story. Today it’s all about the FAANG stocks. Facebook (FB), Amazon (AMZN), Apple (AAPL), Netflix (NFLX) and Google (GOOG) are a major reason why the S&P 500 rallied so much in 2017. Mr. Market is convinced the FAANGs are impervious to a sell-off. “Its different this time” is ringing loud and clear, but will the outcome really be that ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 12

On this week’s episode of AtlantiCast, decade of excellence makes headlines, as Atlantic Health’s place on Fortune Magazine’s 100 Best Companies to Work For List leads off the newest episode of AtlantiCast. Also on this week’s show, check out the newest “hybrid” operating room at Morristown Medical Center and find out how Atlantic Health is helping local ...

Let the Games Begin

I am truly awed by the Olympics.  Watching these superb young athletes on TV inspires me to renew my membership to the gym and pursue my lifelong dream of taking home the gold.  


The problem is that in my deluded head, I can see actually see myself standing atop the podium.  I am wrapped in a puffy designer ski coat with a huge piece of bling slung around my neck ...

Movies! Movies! Movies! - Three Ways to Enjoy Movies

Most people who use the Summit Free Public Library are familiar with our video collection: thousands of DVDs and nearly 800 BluRays -- and growing!

In addition to recent box-office hits and Hollywood classics, we have foreign films, anime, and musical performances from Aida to ZZ Top. Binge-watch a must-see TV series, discover a new one, or introduce your kids to your childhood ...