Summit Parents Debate Role of Planned Parenthood in Schools' Human Growth and Development Program

James Freeman protests to the Summit Board of Education about Planned Parenthood's involvement in the Human Growth and Development Program.
Winners of the Site Invention Contest are introduced at Thursday's Summit Board of Education meeting.

SUMMIT, NJ - Several Summit parents speaking at Thursday's Board of Education meeting said "political advocacy" practiced by Planned Parenthood should not have a role in courses teaching Summit elementary school children about human reproduction, while other parents said school officials should provide "objective" and "scientific" information on sexuality in addition to the values they instill in their homes.

The Human Growth and Development Program, according to Superintendent of Schools Dr. Nathan N. Parker, was developed by the district nurses with the input of elementary school principals. It was then reviewed by district physician Dr. Amy Gruber and approved by the Board of Education on September 17, 2009.

Dr. Parker added, however, due to concerns expressed by some parents, Summit Board of Health member, Dr. Robert Rubino, and Dr. Elizabeth Fagan, who also are parents, would review the program, which is being taught by school nurses.

"Planned Parenthood," according to James Freeman, who has children in the Lincoln-Hubbard School, "is involved on one side of a very bitter debate on reproductive issues" and the schools, which are supposed to foster a diversity of opinions, should not allow the involvement of a political advocacy group that is on one side of a particularly divisive issue."

A member of the board of Planned Parenthood, Nora Wong, who has been a Summit resident for 22 years, with two children who graduated from Summit High School, replied that residents should have faith that the schools would choose the best resources for the education of their children and that the nurses would choose the best programs.

Financing of some materials for the program she said, would not have been possible with out help from private sources arranged through Planned Parenthood.  There was no cost to the school district for any curriculum materials.

She added that only school staff members, Board of Education members and Planned Parenthood educators attended an April 14 meeting in Dr. Parker's office, which was not attended by parents concerned about the program.

No one in the community knew about the April 14 meeting or about Planned Parenthood's involvement in the program, replied parent Angali McCormick.

She said the involvement of Planned Parenthood violated the Summit schools' mission statement that says the schools should be free of any political influence.

There would be an equal objection, she said, if the Archdiocese of Newark or Focus on Families were brought in to conduct programs in the city's public schools.

However, Annette Dwyer, a parent who described herself as a parent who embraced her Catholic ideals and the respect for all life, said while she embraced her role as the first line of education for her children on sexual matters, she did not feel qualified to teach the objective and scientifically-based material which the school nurses were able to teach.

The name of the organization alone, she said, was being used to allege a political agenda.

Parent Sarah Ragan, felt, however, that the involvement of Planned Parenthood, with its specific agenda on reproduction, was infringing on her rights as a parent.

Many options besides Planned Parenthood are available to the schools, Dr. Rubino said, and the involvement of the advocacy group was a "shot across the bow" to parents who wanted to educate their own children in sexual development.

He added children should be allowed to get their education in elementary schools and high school in sexual matters and decide on their own political views on these matters when they get into college.

"We don't want to invite controversy where none exists," he said.

Dr. Parker, replying to statements made by residents, said there was no grant or partnership with Planned Parenthood.

He also said the school nursing staff should not feel intimidated or pressured regarding teaching the curriculum.

On another matter, Board President Thomas O'Rourke said the board was "mindful of its fiduciary responsibility" in preparing the budget and commended "our relatively young administration" for doing a good job of reining in expenses during the difficult 2010 budget year.

He added, however, that the board's General Counsel had advised the Summit Common Council that the school body felt it was improper for the Council to cite a state regulation allowing it to cut the school budget because the Board of Education budget exceeded 1.5% of the city's total assessed property value while the Council refuses to have the city re-evaluated for the past 15 years.

The board, he said, would not pursue legal action, and he promised to issue a statement next week in response to the $350,000 reduction made by the Council in school expenditures after the budget was approved by the Board of School Estimate, which is composed of council members.

On another financial matter, the board approved a memorandum of agreement with the Summit Education Association wherein the association members agreed to cover the Math and English Help Centers as completely voluntary duty periods which would not include teaching, or asking teachers to do "prep, grade or take home work," and would be limited to issues which can be addressed during the duty periods.

The terms of the agreement will not impact the collective bargaining agreement between the board and the association and Mr. O'Rourke said, the changes brought about by the agreement will enable the school district to forego replacing two staff members who are retiring, resulting in approximately $712,000 in budgetary savings.   

Jefferson School fifth graders and their teacher also presented a program at Thursday's meeting on the RJTV or "Roaring Jaguars" television, which involves students in gathering, reporting and videotaping programs about school and national events.

In addition, the board announced and congratulated the first-and-second-place winners in the Site Invention Contest for third, fourth and fifth graders in the Summit schools.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Wed, February 21, 10:00 AM

Summit Free Public Library, Summit

Family Storytime

Arts & Entertainment Community Calendar Education


Wed, February 21, 4:00 PM

Summit Free Public Library, Summit

Bilingual Math and Science Story Time

Arts & Entertainment Community Calendar Education


Wed, February 21, 4:00 PM

Summit Free Public Library, Summit

Bilingual Math and Science Storytime: Ages 3-K

Arts & Entertainment Community Calendar Education

Summit Fire Department Blotter

12/16/17 7:42 am     FD dispatched to DE FOREST AVENUE and MAPLE STREET for a strong odor of natural gas in area. On arrival found an outside odor of natural gas. PSEG was requested and responded to the scene. Readings of 7% natural gas were found in the manholes in the center of the intersection. CVS was checked and zero readings for natural gas were found. Summit FD was released ...

Summit Police Blotter

February 12, 2018

2/1 - At 0955 hours a report was taken for a theft of a street sign. The unlawful incident occurred between an unknown time frame on Pine Grove Avenue. Value of the street sign was not immediately available at the time of the report.

2/5 - Roberto C. Noel-Berman, 23, of Summit was arrested and charged with possession of CDS. Mr. Noel-Berman was released with a pending court date.

2/5 - ...

Summit's Beacon UU Supports Newark Residents on Pollution Problem        

February 21, 2018

For four decades, Ronson cigarette lighters were produced in a factory on Manufacturers Place in the Ironbound section of Newark, resulting in contamination of soil and water by the industrial solvent Trichloroethylene (TCE).

In 1989, the factory closed, and a decade later houses were built on a site that environmental officials had restricted to nonresidential uses. Today, toxic TCE ...

Point View's Dietze, Petrides Tell LA Times How to Make Sense of Market's Volatility

Point View Wealth Management's Founder, President and Chief Investment Strategist, David Dietze, along with the firm's Managing Director and Portfolio Manager, John Petrides, comment in the Los Angeles Times on mistakes investors should avoid when the market heads south:

The duo's advice is part of a piece ...

Is FAANG Long in the Tooth?

Investors love to rally around a stock story. Today it’s all about the FAANG stocks. Facebook (FB), Amazon (AMZN), Apple (AAPL), Netflix (NFLX) and Google (GOOG) are a major reason why the S&P 500 rallied so much in 2017. Mr. Market is convinced the FAANGs are impervious to a sell-off. “Its different this time” is ringing loud and clear, but will the outcome really be that ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 12

On this week’s episode of AtlantiCast, decade of excellence makes headlines, as Atlantic Health’s place on Fortune Magazine’s 100 Best Companies to Work For List leads off the newest episode of AtlantiCast. Also on this week’s show, check out the newest “hybrid” operating room at Morristown Medical Center and find out how Atlantic Health is helping local ...

Let the Games Begin

I am truly awed by the Olympics.  Watching these superb young athletes on TV inspires me to renew my membership to the gym and pursue my lifelong dream of taking home the gold.  


The problem is that in my deluded head, I can see actually see myself standing atop the podium.  I am wrapped in a puffy designer ski coat with a huge piece of bling slung around my neck ...

Movies! Movies! Movies! - Three Ways to Enjoy Movies

Most people who use the Summit Free Public Library are familiar with our video collection: thousands of DVDs and nearly 800 BluRays -- and growing!

In addition to recent box-office hits and Hollywood classics, we have foreign films, anime, and musical performances from Aida to ZZ Top. Binge-watch a must-see TV series, discover a new one, or introduce your kids to your childhood ...