Girls Lacrosse: Verona Remains Undefeated, Beating Caldwell 13-11

Brittany Costigan shakes off a defender heading to the cage Credits: Nick Teodoro
Caitlyn Buermann brings the Lady Chiefs in transition Credits: Nick Teodoro
Brittany Costigan scored a pair of first half goals for Caldwell against undefeated Verona Credits: Nick Teodoro
Sam Gargiulo had a game high seven goals for Caldwell against Verona Credits: Nick Teodoro

WEST CALDWELL, NJ — A strong second-half surge from Verona resulted in a 13-11 loss for the Caldwell girls lacrosse team despite a solid effort.

“I think they played a great game we just had a couple things not go our way,” said Caldwell head coach Angela Giampino-Vasi.

The game’s decisive run was made in the middle of the second half as Verona took charge. Seven goals were scored in a span of 10 minutes for the Lady Hillbillies who took a commanding 13-8 lead with just more than five minutes to play in the game.

Sign Up for E-News

“We got two yellow cards and were down by two [players],” said Giampino-Vasi. "I kind of feel like we started to lose our momentum a little bit and when we started to regroup it was just too late."

The two main scorers in Ava Anderson and Dana Pena prompted Verona’s strong scoring run as the Hillbillies continued their winning streak. Anderson was able to notch her 100th career goal in the process of completing a six goal contest while Pena added four of her own on the day.

“Dana and Ava are just amazing, they give 100 percent all the time and they demand their teammates to do the same,” said Verona head coach Suzanne Giarrusso.

Caldwell fought back down by five to make the game uncomfortable for Verona in the final five minutes. Sam Gargiulo, who tallied a game-high seven goals, helped trim the Verona lead to just two with less than two minutes remaining, but ultimately the Lady Hillbillies to win the next draw and wind down most of the remaining time in regulation.

“We were in it, Verona is a great team, though,” said Giampino-Visi.

For the Lady Chiefs, it was a tough loss after a strong first half performance which spotted them a 6-5 lead. Caldwell impressed early on taking a lead of 2-1 in the game's first five minutes. After a lull, the offense came alive late in the first half, sparked by Sam Gargiulo and Brittany Costigan giving Caldwell the momentum heading into the midway point.

“I felt like we were able to control the ball on attack better. We weren’t rushing and that was really going in our favor,” said Giampino-Visi.

Ultimately, a slightly more polished Verona team continued to show why they are second half team. The Lady Hillbillies improved to 5-0 on the season as they will head into a matchup at 7-0 Bernards High School on Monday April 17.

“It’s good to have another win under our belt. We had to work for this one and I don’t feel we played our best lacrosse today,” said Giarrusso. Caldwell always gives us a great game and we’re very evenly matched teams."

For Caldwell, the loss drops the team to 3-2 on the year as its head for a quicker turnaround against 1-3 Cedar Grove on Tuesday. They will use the game with Verona as a learning experience and look to rebound.

“If we beat Cedar Grove we will see Verona again in the County Tournament so that’s a goal we’re looking forward to,” said Giampino-Visi.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Verona/Cedar Grove

Essex County Undersheriff Kevin Ryan dies

June 21, 2018

Kevin Ryan, a former Assemblyman from Nutley who served as an Essex County Undersheriff, has died.

Ryan, 49, served for nearly two decades in the Essex County Sheriff's Office, rising to the rank of undersheriff. He also served a year beginning in January 2011 as State Assemblyman before redistricting changes.  

Ryan was a close confidante of Essex County Sheriff ...

Cedar Grove Police Blotter

June 18, 2018

On June 14, 2018 at 12:13 a.m., Ptl. Nicole Witel stopped a vehicle after a random license plate check revealed that the registration was suspended. A subsequent investigation led to the arrest of a 23 year old male driver from Montclair for driving while suspended. He was processed and released with a summons to appear in municipal court.

On June 16, 2018 at 7:00 a.m., Ptl. Raymond Cassella ...

NJ Teen Steers His Mustang Into Tractor Supply Store

June 20, 2018

MONROE TWP., N.J. — James Duffey, 18 of Garwood, drove his 2014 mustang through the doors of the Tractor Supply in Monroe Township, N.J. on Tuesday, June 12, about 12:30 p.m.

But it isn't what you think. Duffey is a lot like other high school Seniors. He likes to go out with his friends for a soda. In Duffey's case, his friend is a 4-year-old American Mustang he named "Star ...

Upcoming Events


Fri, June 22, 6:00 PM

Montclair Public Library Auditorium, Montclair

Let's Listen to Jazz

Arts & Entertainment

Fri, June 22, 8:00 PM

Education Center, West Orange

Night Moves: Evening Guided Zoo Tours

Education Other


Sun, June 24, 11:00 AM


MakerFest 2018


Cedar Grove Seeks Zoning Board Members

June 19, 2018

CEDAR GROVE, NJ - The Township Council requests any residents who wish to be considered for membership on the Zoning Board of Adjustment to submit a letter of interest by Wednesday, July 11, 2018, to the Clerk’s Office, 525 Pompton Avenue, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009 or . Kindly include address and telephone number on correspondence. Contact the Clerk’s Office at ...