Law & Justice

6 Students File Lawsuits Related to Alleged Sexual Misconduct By Former Columbia Teacher

502e510c6fe04fe72a47_chs_teacher.jpg
Nicole Dufault, former Columbia High School teacher.
502e510c6fe04fe72a47_chs_teacher.jpg

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - Three lawsuits have been filed against the South Orange Maplewood School District -- the most recent just two month ago -- by students of a former Columbia High School teacher accused of sexual misconduct with up to six under-aged boys.

Nicole Dufault, who was arrested in September 2014, and is still awaiting trial on related criminal charges, is named in the civil suits along with the school district. Dufault was born and raised in Bloomfield. 

The legal complaints, all filed in just the past 15 months, seek damages for Dufault’s alleged actions, and claims that she coerced the students into performing oral sex, pressured them due to her authority as a teacher, and caused emotional distress and psychological injury.

Sign Up for E-News

The lawsuits also claim the school district is at fault for allowing unsupervised areas of Columbia High School (CHS) to be accessible during a 2013 summer program in which many of the incidents allegedly occurred. It contends the sexual acts were able to take place in those areas of the school that lacked supervision.

In addition, the complaints contend the school and the district are liable for the alleged criminal acts because they are required to provide a safe atmosphere for the students.

TAPinto SOMA obtained the lawsuits through a public information request of the school district. All identities of the plaintiffs have been redacted along with the names of their parents who filed on their behalf. 

The first lawsuit, filed Sept. 30, 2016, was brought forth by parents of two minor students whose names were not released. It seeks $1 million in compensatory and punitive damages, as well as court and legal costs.

The lawsuit contends both students were victims of sexual assault, abuse and harassment beginning in early August 2014 and lasting for two months. It also claims both were “intellectually disabled” and had “social communication difficulties” and were “vulnerable to sexual harassment.”

The suit contends Dufault engaged in oral sex and sexual intercourse with both students and that complaints were made against Dufault to the district soon after that the district allegedly ignored.

The second lawsuit, also filed in September 2016, was brought on behalf of a third former student who was a freshman in the spring of 2014 when he alleges the abuse began. It claims that the student and other youngsters were invited to cut class and “hangout” in Dufault’s classroom during off periods and that she even used the school computer to change their records so they would not be caught skipping class.

The suit alleges that Dufault “spoke with them about lewd and sexual actions, brushed up again their bodies and touched intimate and personal parts of their bodies in front of other students in the social group.” It also contends she engaged in sexual acts with the students that were video recorded.

As with the previous lawsuit, his complaint also claims the school district is liable because it failed to properly supervise Dufault’s classroom at those times.

The third lawsuit, filed just this past October, was brought on behalf of a fourth former student. It seeks no specific damages, but also contends Dufault abused the male teen.

This alleged victim claims his abuse occurred during the summer of 2013 when Dufault was involved in the summer “Bridge Program,” and included several alleged sexual acts in various CHS locations, as well as Dufault’s car in the CHS parking lot.

The complaint also seeks damages against the school district for failing to properly supervise the high school to prevent such alleged crimes.

Attorneys for the two previous lawsuits could not be reached for comment, but John McDonnell, who represents the fourth plaintiff, said he did not name a damage amount because more information is needed.

“It’s premature to say what we’re seeking,” McDonnell said. “There are two sides to every story, until I hear the other side it is hard for me to evaluate the case.”

Dufault’s attorney, Tim Smith, disagreed with the claims against Dufault and again repeated his ongoing defense that Dufault was the victim. He has in the past cited her suffering from “frontal lobe syndrome,” which he blamed on brain surgery Dufault underwent following complications from her first pregnancy.

“You had a particularly overly aggressive group of students who came into contact with a teacher who suffered from brain damage,” Smith said in an interview.

But he did agree that the unsupervised areas of the high school where the incidents allegedly occurred were part of the problem.

“You had a program that took place in an isolated part of the school where there was nobody there to control the situation, then you couple that with the fact that the school never screened her post-brain surgery,” Smith said. “She also had a home front situation that was troubled with her husband having been arrested and she was taking care of the kids herself. You had a whirlwind of events that led to this victimization of her.”

Asked to comment on the lawsuits, School District Spokeswoman Suzanne Turner issued the following statement via email:

The allegations are deeply disturbing. The nature of the charges are the most difficult that schools, parents and children would ever have to discuss together. 

By law, administrators and Board of Education members are not permitted to publicly discuss personnel or individual student matters, ongoing litigation, or other issues requiring confidentiality. However, we can affirm we believe deeply in our mission to provide our students with a safe and healthy learning environment. We are hopeful that the process will bring closure to this painful chapter in our community’s history.

The school district like most other districts has liability insurance that would likely cover any damages.

Related article
 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

Warren

Bee Day at Hanson Park!!

May 20, 2018

Please join the Hanson Park Conservancy on Saturday, June 23rd for Bee Day at Hanson Park!  At 2:00 PM Grant Stiles from Stiles Honey will be sharing his knowledge of bees with his presentation, “Fundamentals of Beekeeping and the Importance of Honey Bees in Our Society.”  Bring your blankets and chairs and enjoy the beautiful surroundings as Mr. Stiles answers all of your ...

Golf Outing On May 26 Benefits Retired Racehorses

MILLSTONE TOWNSHIP, N.J. —May 29, will mark Standardbred Retirement Foundation's (SRF) 26th Annual Charity Golf Outing being held at the beautiful Battleground Country Club in Manalapan, N.J.

This much anticipated event is held in conjunction with SRF's online auction which will open for bidding beginning Friday, May 25 and end at 7 p.m. on  Thursday, June 7. The outing ...

Obituaries

Jul 28, 1955 - Feb 8, 2018
Owner/Chef of Jaret’s Stuffed Cupcakes  Beloved Husband, Father, Brother and ...
Read more

Belmar Mayor Grants ‘Larry the Lobster’ His Freedom to Kick Off New Jersey Seafood Festival

May 19, 2018

BELMAR, NJ — Belmar Mayor Brian Magovern wasn’t going to let the rough ocean surf and high winds get in his way yesterday of pardoning “Larry the Lobster” to begin the New Jersey Seafood Festival.

Instead, Magovern moved the May 18 event from the Fifth Avenue beach to the quieter waters of the Shark River Inlet. Accompanied by a small group of borough officials and ...

Food to Travel For - Two Jersey Shore Dining Hot Spots in National Limelight for Specialty Eats

BELMAR, NJ — Two Belmar specialty eateries have made the national food-hopping map. Coney Waffle Ice Cream and Sweet Shop on Ocean Avenue and Hoagitos in Belmar Plaza are featured this month on television shows touting what makes them stand out from the rest.

The over-the-top ice cream creations of Coney Waffle are in the spotlight in Viceland’s “The Ice Cream Show” in ...

WHRHS Baseball: Roxbury Baseball Powers Past Watchung Hills

May 19, 2018

ROXBURY, NJ – The Roxbury High School baseball team won its 14th game on Friday, rolling over Watchung Hills 9-1 at home.

Offensively, Roxbury did its damage early, scoring twice in the second inning and then five more times in the third to take an early 7-0 lead.

Roxbury’s Will Findlay had two hits and Donovan Brady, Andy Axelson and Brian Dachowski all had base hits. In ...

WHRHS Boys Lacrosse: Bridgewater Upsets Watchung Hills in OT for SCT Title

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - So close. The Watchung Hills boys lacrosse team fell to Bridgewater-Raritan, in overtime, as the Panthers won a fourth-straight Somerset County Tournament title on Saturday, 5-4, at the Torpey Athletic Complex.

Watchung Hills took an early 3-0 lead in the first quarter with goals from Gavin DeFuria, Connor James, and Joe Rica. 

The last game the ...

Hillsborough Man Sentenced for Bribing Doctors in $100M Test Referral Scheme

May 18, 2018

NEWARK, NJ – Five individuals including a Hillsborough resident  were sentenced Friday for bribing doctors in exchange for test referrals as part of a long-running and elaborate scheme operated by Biodiagnostic Laboratory Services LLC (BLS), of Parsippany, its president and numerous associates, U.S. Attorney Craig Carpenito announced.

Doug Hurley, 38, of Hillsborough and Kevin ...

North Plainfield Middle School Hosts Holocaust and Genocide Open House

NORTH  PLAINFIELD, NJ - All are invited to the 2018 North Plainfield Middle School Holocaust/Genocide Open House on Thursday, May 17 at 6 p.m. Students and staff will be on hand to serve as docents for a unique exhibit.

It is a museum in a school, created by the school, constructed by the school and for everyone in the community. featuring  over 400 posters, memorabilia and artifacts ...

WHRHS Boys Lacrosse: Bridgewater Upsets Watchung Hills in OT for SCT Title

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - So close. The Watchung Hills boys lacrosse team fell to Bridgewater-Raritan, in overtime, as the Panthers won a fourth-straight Somerset County Tournament title on Saturday, 5-4, at the Torpey Athletic Complex.

Watchung Hills took an early 3-0 lead in the first quarter with goals from Gavin DeFuria, Connor James, and Joe Rica. 

The last game the ...

Phone App Leads to Arrest of Arizona Fugitive

                                                                              

BOUND BROOK, NJ – A local resident wanted on a fugitive warrant from Arizona and Washington was tracked down ...

Podcast: The Royal Wedding Through the Eyes of a Brit

May 19, 2018

In our May 18 podcast, Giles Bootheway, a British citizen who teaches at St. Bonaventure University, shares his thoughts on the Royal Wedding with TAPinto Greater Olean Co-editor Richard Lee.

PLAY

Sign Up for E-News to get top stories delivered daily to your inbox. 

Download the FREE TAPinto App!  Click here for Android - Click here for iOS to get ...

Charity Golf Tournament to Benefit Parkland Cares and the Jason Taylor Reading Room, May 17 -Travels Charity Spotlight -

PARKLAND, FL - Parkland Cares will hold a Charity Golf Tournament on Thursday, May 17 at Parkland Golf & Country Club, with 100% of the proceeds going to the Jason Taylor Reading Room and Parkland Cares.  The event is presented by Steven Douglas and former NFL player and Hall of Famer Jason Taylor will be in attendance.

Howard Dvorkin, CPA, is chairman of Debt.com and a 30-year ...

Food to Travel For - Two Jersey Shore Dining Hot Spots in National Limelight for Specialty Eats

BELMAR, NJ — Two Belmar specialty eateries have made the national food-hopping map. Coney Waffle Ice Cream and Sweet Shop on Ocean Avenue and Hoagitos in Belmar Plaza are featured this month on television shows touting what makes them stand out from the rest.

The over-the-top ice cream creations of Coney Waffle are in the spotlight in Viceland’s “The Ice Cream Show” in ...

'To Kill a Mockingbird' Sustains Timeless Appeal

SUMMIT, NJ – The Summit Playhouse provides a stellar production of a much loved classic, “To Kill a Mockingbird.”

The Harper Lee novel, later a Gregory Peck film and now a stage production, retains all the warmth, intensity and integrity that made it such an appealing hit in the 1960s. And there will be a new production on Broadway in December with a script by Aaron Sorkin ...

'The Sting' with Harry Connick Jr. Slithers and Shakes at Paper Mill

MILLBURN, NJ – In a premiere production of “The Sting,” Harry Connick Jr. commands the Paper Mill Playhouse stage.

Based on the sensational Paul Newman/Robert Redford film in 1973, the 1930s plot centers on a con game and gambling, sometimes on a train between New York and Chicago.  Scott Joplin’s music is intertwined with the show, especially “The ...