Government

Civic Story Panel: New Jersey Pension Fund Crisis Discussed

b07eb35d8ec103b829be_CivicStory2.jpg
Civic Story Panel (l-r): Andrew Sidamon-Eristoff, Nancy Munoz and Tom Byrne Credits: Chip Dickson
8f61ec0be34b2984138a_CivicStory1.jpg
Moderator Lisa Allen and Civic Story Founder Susan Haig Credits: Chip Dickson
8a5e3c22b97f531f90fb_CivicStory3.jpg
Tom Byrne and Nancy Munoz Credits: Chip Dickson
0828ceca54a09eb1b3b3_CivicStory4.jpg
Andrew Sidamon-Eristoff Credits: Chip Dickson
b07eb35d8ec103b829be_CivicStory2.jpg

SUMMIT, NJ – New Jersey’s Public Employee Pension Fund is severely underfunded based on projected demands of future pension payments and retiree health care costs and could run out of money in twelve years if actions are not taken to address the problem.  That is the conclusion of a report issued February 11, 2016 by a bi-partisan group called the New Jersey Pension and Health Benefit Study Commission

The report’s conclusions and some of its contents were discussed by a panel hosted by the nonprofit organization Civic Story last Monday night at Central Presbyterian Church in Summit.  The evening’s event was “NJ Pension & Health Benefits - Sowing Solutions”.  The purpose of the event was to increase awareness of the issue, highlight some of the suggested solutions and stimulate further dialogue because silence and lack of attention will only make the situation worse.  Here are some of the major points:

1)      If no actions are taken, the rising level of benefit costs could cause the fund to run out of money in a period as short as twelve years as “…the painful reality is that the benefits currently provided to employees are beyond the State’s means”.

Sign Up for E-News

2)      This problem exists because “…elected officials overpromised and underfunded for two decades.”

3)      Underfunding is often the path of least resistance and according to estimates; the pension fund is underfunded by at least $50 billion and possibly as much as $135 billion.

4)      There will not be a bailout from the federal government.

5)      Rising benefit costs will force cuts in other essential services such as education, infrastructure and public policy.

PANEL DISCUSSION

The panel participants included Tom Byrne, Chair of the NJ Investment Council; Andrew Sidamon-Eristoff, former State Treasurer; and Assemblywoman Nancy Munoz.  The panel moderator was Lisa Allen, a resident of Summit. 

The consensus of the panel was the public employee pension fund financial condition is a crisis and that corrective steps need to be taken as soon as possible to avoid more punitive and costly steps.  They echoed the first of ‘five hard truths’ from the 2016 study, “The State’s current public employee pension system is broken and needs to be fixed now to protect current retirees.”  Underlying this view are concerns about the already large and increasing burden of public employee benefits, which the Commission felt must be kept below 15% of the State budget.

Above the 15% level, the Study concludes, “…the State will be in financial jeopardy and New Jersey’s credit ratings will continue to decline.”  In fact, the State received another downgrade in March.  This time from Moody’s taking the rating on general obligation bonds from A2 to A3.

The New Jersey Pension Fund has $72 billion of assets.  Those assets are meant to help fund the annual retirement and post retirement health care benefits for 800,000 New Jersey public employees that are still working or retired.  According to an analysis of future needs, the pension fund is underfunded by at least $50 billion and possibly, $135 billion.  At its current level, “The State cannot afford to continue to provide employees with pension and health benefits far greater than those enjoyed in the private sector”, which is the second of five points in the Study.

The pre-reform State benefits spend was $4.6 billion in 2016, or 13.5% of the 2016 Budget.  In 2017, it is expected to increase to $5.6 billion or 16.1% of the Budget and already above the Commission’s 15% threshold.  According to the Study, State benefits will reach 27.3% of the 2023 Budget without reform.  Health care costs are projected to rise from $3.3 billion in 2016 to $5.8 billion in 2023, while pension costs are expected to rise from $1.3 billion to $5.6 billion.   In the 2016 Budget, active health benefits and post-retirement medical benefits represented 9.7% compared to 6.4% in 2008 and 4.5% in 2001.  They are 10.7% of the 2017 Budget.

The demands on the pension fund are expected to continue to grow, while the level of assets in the pension fund grew only 1.4% a year between 2008 and 2016, and just 0.1% annually since 2010.  Trying to fully fund the existing benefits “…will inevitably force cuts in essential services such as education, infrastructure and public safety” according to the Study. 

PROPOSED SOLUTIONS

The panel felt there were two likely scenarios.  The first would be finally arriving at a ‘New Jersey’ solution and the second would involve the federal government.  That remedy would likely involve draconian cuts to other parts of the budget to supply the funds necessary to meet the funding needs of the pension plan.  According to Sidamon-Eristoff, federal help means, “…the feds are likely to impose restrictions, or conditions, on the states. So at the end of the day, public employees in New Jersey and elsewhere, if this happens, will end up with much less rich benefits than they have now.”  All agreed federal help would not be in the form of a bailout.

The proposed New Jersey solution involves honoring pension promises to date and reforming pension plans going forward so that retirements benefits are not based on income from the last three years of service.  It also involves shifting to a hybrid pension structure called a cash balance plan that targets a meaningfully lower rate of return than the current return target of 7.65%.  Additional cost savings are expected to come from reforming public employee health care benefits by capping the type of coverage provided to the ‘Gold Plan’ level.  From the Study, “Active employees… are almost invariably enrolled in plans with the highest actuarial values in the nation.”  According to the Study, the average pre-subscriber costs in State-run programs pre-reform is $16,642 for an active employee, $29,748 for an early retiree and $9,970 for a Medicare retiree.  The estimated save from reforming health benefits was $2.23 billion. 

Increasing taxes was not considered to be a major part of the remedy because the potential contribution was not estimated to be of sufficient magnitude and the risk of error the revenues would be lower than expected was felt to be high.  Also, income tax revenues are over 40% of State revenues and too dependent on a small group of tax payers.  No more than 570 individuals represent about $1.1 billion of state income tax revenues, which are about $13 billion.  Losing just a few of these individuals to other states could negate much, if not all, of any proposed tax rate hike on the highest income earners. 

Another constraint from taxes is the recent slower growth but relatively higher burden of benefit expenses.  New Jersey State revenues are almost flat with the level reached in 2008.  When property taxes are included, total receipts exceeded the 2008 level in 2013 as shown in the following chart, New Jersey Taxes and Other Revenues. According to IRS data, total income in New Jersey was lower in 2011 than 2007 and responsible for part of the drop in revenues during that period,

HOW DID THIS HAPPEN?

The summary statement from the Study, “Because elected officials overpromised and underfunded for two decades, the painful reality is that the benefits currently provided to employees are beyond the State’s means.”

According to Byrne, who is also the son of the former Democratic Governor Brendan Byrne of New Jersey and former Head of the New Jersey Democratic Party, the last six administrations failed to contribute a sufficient amount of funding to the pension plan as suggested by the actuaries because of other budgetary priorities.  Governor Christie appointed Byrne to Chair the Commission.

The period starts during the Whitman Administration through the Christie Administration, which provided the highest level of funding.   Combined there was just under $10 billion contributed to the pension fund, which is a level that would be sufficient for a fwe years at most and certainly not 23 years.  Since 2000, a much higher level of funding demands coincided often with periods of anemic revenue growth and the lowest levels of contributions tended to occur during the period of strongest revenue growth.

From Fiscal Year 1995 to Fiscal Year 2010 (000)

Governor                                                       Contribution

Whitman                                                         $     963,934

DiFrancesco                                                    $            563

McGreevey                                                     $     101,424

Codey                                                             $     165,026

Corzine                                                            $  2,175,596

Total                                                                $  3,406,543

Christie                                                            $  6,274,505 through FY 2017

OTHER

Unfunded liabilities of defined benefit plans are a much bigger issue in the government sector than in the private sector.

State & local government defined benefit obligations totaled $5.763 trillion at the end of 2016 and $1.9 trillion was unfunded or 33.0%.  State & local defined contribution plans totaled $490.6 billion. 

Federal government defined benefit obligations totaled $3.43 trillion and $1.83 trillion was unfunded, or $53.5%.  Federal defined contribution plans totaled $466.6 billion.

Private sector defined benefit obligations totaled $3.38 trillion and $496.0 billion was unfunded, or 14.7%.  Private sector defined contribution plan assets totaled $5.74 trillion.  Private sector employees represent over 80% of the workforce and 47.3% of combined retirement obligations.  Source of this data is the December 31. 2016 Flow of Funds

Civic Story is a nonprofit news site and producer of short videos highlighting civics, sustainability, and creative growth in New Jersey's cities and beyond. Our mission is to broaden the news through videos and dialogue about civic growth and constructive change.  From website www.civicstory.org

Sources - Commission Report:   http://www.state.nj.us/treasury/pdf/NJPensionCommission-Supplemental-Report-on-Health-Benefits.pdf

State of New Jersey Department of Treasury:  http://www.nj.gov/treasury/omb/publications/archives.shtml

State of New Jersey Department of Community Affairs: http://www.state.nj.us/dca/divisions/dlgs/resources/property_tax.html

 

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Warren

Missing in North Plainfield: Have You Seen Angel?

June 21, 2018

NORTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - Have you seen Angel?

Angel is a seven year old black and white Husky last seen near Westervelt Ave. and Manning Ave. on June 16 wearing a black collar. Her family says she is very friendly. 

If found, call Andrea at  888-466-3242.

 

Warren Financial Planner Fined $500K, Barred from Selling Securities for Defrauding Seniors of $6.1 Million, NJ Attorney General Says

June 16, 2018

NEWARK, NJ –  A Warren resident and his company, a Morris County investment advisory firm, were fined $500,000 in civil penalties and barred from selling securities for fraudulently selling at least $6.1 million in unregistered securities to elderly and retired New Jersey investors, Attorney General Gurbir S. Grewal announced on Friday. 

The Bureau of ...

Warren Temple’s Knead to Feed Honored with Community Service Recognition Award

June 24, 2018

The Jewish Family Service (JFS) recently celebrated the charitable work of Knead to Feed, a challah bread baking organization based out of Temple Har Shalom in Warren. The Community Service Recognition Award was presented to Knead to Feed founders at the JFS’ 38th annual meeting on June 6, 2018.

Kneed to Feed at Temple Har Shalom was born out of a sermon delivered by Rabbi Randi ...

PAL Runners Take Titles and Record At USATF Jr. Olympics T&F State Championship

PLAINFIELD, NJ – The highly anticipated USATF Jr. Olympics T&F State Championship meet brought the best of the best of New Jersey to Hub Stine Stadium in Plainfield for a two day event, Saturday June 9 and Sunday June 10, 2018. Top-three earn medals and top-six competitors in each event advance to the USATF Region 2 Junior Olympic Championships on July 12-15 at the College of New ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_c0dcc5b06e5dfbe83904_vbs2018-banner

Mon, June 25, 8:45 AM

Stonecrest Community Church, Warren

Summer Spectacular 2018 VBS

Religions And Spirituality

Carousel_image_c0dcc5b06e5dfbe83904_vbs2018-banner

Tue, June 26, 8:45 AM

Stonecrest Community Church, Warren

Summer Spectacular 2018 VBS

Religions And Spirituality

Carousel_image_c0dcc5b06e5dfbe83904_vbs2018-banner

Wed, June 27, 8:45 AM

Stonecrest Community Church, Warren

Summer Spectacular 2018 VBS

Religions And Spirituality

Obituaries

Jul 28, 1955 - Feb 8, 2018
Owner/Chef of Jaret’s Stuffed Cupcakes  Beloved Husband, Father, Brother and ...
Read more

Manutti Marina in Belmar: Top Choice for Boating, Fishing and All-Around Family Fun

June 12, 2018

BELMAR, NJ — It’s no secret that Belmar Manutti Marina ranks among the best boating destinations along the Atlantic coast.

Tucked along the eastern shoreline of the idyllic Shark River — just a five-minute trip by boat to the ocean — the state-of-the-art marina is a top choice among boaters looking to stay for the season, enjoy a vacation or spend the weekend.

In ...

Missing in North Plainfield: Have You Seen Angel?

June 21, 2018

NORTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - Have you seen Angel?

Angel is a seven year old black and white Husky last seen near Westervelt Ave. and Manning Ave. on June 16 wearing a black collar. Her family says she is very friendly. 

If found, call Andrea at  888-466-3242.

 

Summer Camp Programs for Children and Teens Announced By Environmental Education Center

BERNARDS TWP., NJ – Each summer, the Environmental Education Center (EEC) in Basking Ridge holds programs that let children and teens explore nature for summer activities that both entertaining and an opportunity to learn about the environment.

The programs are organized and led by the EEC's staff of naturalists.

The EEC is a Somerset County facility located at 190 Lord ...

To Our Republican Supporters in Warren Township,

June 12, 2018

 

I want to thank the voters of Warren Township for the overwhelming support Gary and I received on the June 5th primary election.  This would not have been achievable without the hard work of our families, many friends and supporters as well as the loyal Republicans that cast a vote for us and our shared goals.  

 

The campaign is not over until the ...

Thousands Expected for Sourland Music Festival

June 20, 2018

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ – The Sourland Music Festival will be held Saturday, June 23 from 3-10 p.m. at the Hillsborough Golf & Country Club at 146 Wertsville Road, rain or shine, to benefit the Sourland Conservancy.

Discounted advance-sale tickets are available online only, Children under 12 are admitted free.

“We’ve got a really powerful lineup of the region’s most ...

SCBP Biz Fest 2018 Draws Record Crowd

SOMERSET, NJ - More than 500 people attended Biz Fest 2018, Somerset County's ‘hyper-local’ trade show and networking event, on Thursday at the Imperia.

The Somerset County Business Partnership (SCBP) organized the event.  SCBP Vice President of Business Services Chris Edwards said that this year's Biz Fest was a huge success. 

"This has been ...

Update: Police Break Up Fight Involving 40-50 People at Bridgewater Commons Mall

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — No injuries have been reported in an incident that shut down Bridgewater Commons Mall Thursday evening after a fight involving a crowd of 40-50 people.

Police are still investigating unconfirmed reports of shots being fired, according to the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office.

The mall is closed for the evening as the investigation continues.

Somerset County ...

March for Watchung Library and Rally Set for Saturday

WATCHUNG, NJ - Supporters of keeping a Watchung Library in Watchung have organized a March For Watchung Library to be held on Saturday, June 16. 

The Coalition to Save the Watchung Library is rallying support and have asked all who want to participate to “paint a sign, put on some purple, and come out and join your friends and neighbors for a Rally on the Green and ...

Thousands Expected for Sourland Music Festival

June 20, 2018

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ – The Sourland Music Festival will be held Saturday, June 23 from 3-10 p.m. at the Hillsborough Golf & Country Club at 146 Wertsville Road, rain or shine, to benefit the Sourland Conservancy.

Discounted advance-sale tickets are available online only, Children under 12 are admitted free.

“We’ve got a really powerful lineup of the region’s most ...

Third-annual Juneteenth Parade and Heritage Festival in New Brunswick this Weekend

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - The Vulcan Pioneers of New Brunswick, comprising the city's Black Fire Fighters Association, will host the Juneteenth Parade on Saturday, June 16 to commemorate the Emancipation Proclamation.

Juneteenth celebrations are held across the country to mark the announcement of the abolition of slavery in Texas in June 1865. That state was one of the last locations to learn of ...

Manutti Marina in Belmar: Top Choice for Boating, Fishing and All-Around Family Fun

BELMAR, NJ — It’s no secret that Belmar Manutti Marina ranks among the best boating destinations along the Atlantic coast.

Tucked along the eastern shoreline of the idyllic Shark River — just a five-minute trip by boat to the ocean — the state-of-the-art marina is a top choice among boaters looking to stay for the season, enjoy a vacation or spend the weekend.

In ...

'Half Time' delivers with sterling cast

MILLBURN, NJ – The Paper Mill Playhouse is putting on a smashing new production of “Half Time” to round out its current season.

With actress Georgia Engel in an engaging performance, the cast also features Donna McKehnie, Andre De Shieilds and Lilias White, among a host of other talents.

The musical centers on an effort to have seniors perform a dance number during ...

'Half Time' lights up Paper Mill stage

‘Half Time’ turns the tables on aging in gleeful production

By Liz Keill

MILLBURN, NJ – The Paper Mill Playhouse is putting on a smashing new production of “Half Time” to round out its current season.

With actress Georgia Engel in an engaging performance, the cast also features Donna McKehnie, Andre De Shieilds and Lilias White, among a host of other ...