Religions and Spirituality

ISBR Mosque Plan Approved at Special Planning Board Meeting on Tuesday

Revised plans for a 4,250-square-foot mosque in Liberty Corner was approved at a special Planning Board meeting on Tues., Aug. 8, at Ridge High School. Credits: By Linda Sadlouskos

BERNARDS TWP., NJ - Planning Board members and Mayor Carolyn Gaziano voted for site plan approval for a proposed 4,250-square-foot mosque on Church Street in Liberty Corner Village on Tuesday at a court-mandated special hearing that was held in the aftermath of Bernards Township's legal settlement agreement with the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge,

The Planning Board's approval of the revised plan - reversing an earlier denial of the ISBR's mosque application by the Planning Board in December 2015 - is subject to further approvals from the Somerset County Planning Board and from Bernards Township Sewerage Authority for a sewer line extension.

ISBR Attorney Robert Raymar said that the project is still a few months away from final approvals and the drawing up of actual construction plans. But, he said of Tuesday's approval by the Bernards Planning Board, "This obviously is a step forward."

Sign Up for E-News

The 6-0 vote to approve the plan followed a brief public hearing at which former members of the Planning Board and other members of the public - including Jeffrey Plaza, who presided over the Planning Board during most of more than three years of hearings on the mosque proposal - offered critiques of the ISBR's revised site plan and the procedure, and even integrity, of Tuesday night's hearing.

A key change in the site plan for the proposed mosque was the reduction of required parking spaces from 107 to 50 on the four-plus acre lot at 124 Church St.

The settlement, approved in late May by a majority of the Bernards Township Committee and the Planning Board, required that change and also a payment of $3.25 million from Bernards Township to pay the ISBR for a combination of damages and legal costs. The settlement with the ISBR is published on the township website, Tuesday's "Whispering Woods" hearing was another outcome of the settlement.

The number of parking spaces had been set early in hearings on the mosque that began in 2012, when experts testified that attendees at worship services at the mosque were more likely to arrive alone or in pairs directly from their jobs. The rule of thumb for church parking is that an average of three attendees will arrive in each vehicle for religious services.

A federal judge ruled that some of the land use issues that were the Planning Board's basis for denial were as a result of the additional parking requirement. Lawsuits were filed by both the ISBR and US Department of Justice in federal court in 2016 alleging that the Planning Board's rejection was based on religious discrimination rather than land use laws.

At Tuesday's hearing, the revised plans submitted by the ISBR's experts showed 50 parking spaces, with 14 additional parking spots, if needed, on unpaved ground.

Gaziano, as a voting member of the Planning Board, said she believed that the Planning Board's original decision to reject the ISBR application was based on legitimate land use issues regarding a plan with 107 parking spaces. A plan with only 50 parking spaces addressed many of those issues, she said.

The three professionals that reviewed the revised site plans and documents submitted by the ISBR prior to Tuesday's hearing said they were in compliance with the settlement requirements.

But some of the speakers on Tuesday spoke against the process of the board's interpretaton of the Whispering Woods hearing.

"A Whispering Woods hearing gives residents an opportunity to comment on a settlement [proposal]," said resident Cody Smith. "You already approved a settlement," Smith told the Planning Board.

Kevin Orr, another speaker who is an attorney as well as a former Planning Board member, said he agreed with Smith.

"I believe the integrity of the process remains flawed," Orr said.

'Done Deal'

"It was a done deal before it even started," Orr said of Tuesday's hearing.

Plaza argued that the way the settlement agreement was stated, granting the lifting of personal liability for the Planning Board members as well Township Committee members who approved the settlement agreemeent, presented an inherent conflict of interest for four voting members of the Planning Board.

Raymar countered that the lawsuit only named members of the Planning Board in their professional, not personal, capacities. The township officials were not sued as individuals, he added.

Raymar also noted that the board's vote to approve the plan is subject to appeal.

[Information added] Other township residents said that some of the concerns raised during the original hearings, including a fire safety plan, a traffic flow plan for drop off of people entering the building, and stormwater management, have still not been resolved in the revised application.

Some speakers criticized the use of a fence to shield the proposed facility from a neighboring property, and said the neighbors will need to look at a 6-foot high fence.

Raymar said that the issues had been addressed in the new application documents, which had been subject to review by the township professionals. For example, he said the township fire official had reviewed the fire safety plan, and had recommended one small change, which he said was followed.

Thomas Quinn, the professional engineer for the Planning Board, noted that the township professionals had been "given a tight framework through which to review" the revised documents for the mosque projet.

Loretta Quick, the immediate neighbor of the mosque property, told the Planning Board she was afraid to say what she wanted for fear of violating the federal court order. She said the ISBR had "previously harassed and intimidated me" during the legal proceedings, and had pursued a court subpoena even seeking her personal email.

Another neighbor of project, Joseph Abbate of Somerville Road, had been a vocal critic of the project during the original hearings, but at Tuesday's hearing then asked only if street parking could be restricted near the intersection with Somerville Road. Afterward, he addressed the mosque representatives at the meeting by offering a "Welcome to the neighborhood."





TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


UPDATE: Four’Easter May Bring Another Foot of Snow, Be Prepared for School Closures and Power Outages in Warren Township and Surrounding Area

March 20, 2018

WARREN, NJ - Happy Spring. Get the milk, bread and eggs. Get the generator, gas and chainsaw and be prepared to lose another day of spring break if Wednesday is called a snow day. Heavy mixed precipitation is expected with snow accumulations of 8 to 14 inches in our area by Wednesday evening when the fourth Nor’easter of the year hits. #foureaster is trending, and Winter does ...

Warren Township to Collect Winter Storm Quinn Tree Debris

WARREN, NJ - The Department of Public Works of Warren Township will be collecting tree and brush debris from all Warren Township residents in the aftermath of Winter Storm Quinn.

Due to the intense effects of Storm Quinn that impacted Warren Township on March 7, the Township Committee has authorized and directed the DPW to. begin the collection process ...

Somerset County Opens Emergency Shelter for Storm Victims at RVCC

BRANCHBURG, NJ – Due to the extended power outages in Somerset County as a result of Winter Storm Quinn and the expected cold temperatures over the next few days, the Somerset County Office of Emergency Management has partnered with the American Red Cross to open a shelter for county residents at Raritan Valley Community College.

The shelter opened as of 5:30 p.m. Saturday, ...

Update from Warren Office of Emergency Management on Saturday, Mar. 10

WARREN, NJ - The Warren Township Office of Emergency Management has provided a timeline and Jane Asch at Warren’s Office of Emergency Management has updated storm recovery information as of 1 p.m. Saturday, March 10 with the following:



The most pressing issue is restoration of power. It may be helpful to understand the triage system both JCP&L and ...

JCP&L Update: Preparing for the Storm

March 21, 2018


With predictions of more than a foot of heavy, wet snow and wind gusts up to 45 mph, JCP&L is prepared for the storm. We have implemented storm and staffing plans and are ready to respond appropriately should this next wave of severe weather cause power outages. 

What we’ve done to prepare: 

Secured mutual assistance ...

Wellness of Warren Holds Open House

WARREN, NJ: - Wellness of Warren is hosting an Open House on Tuesday, March 27 from 6 to 8 pm.  This unique group of offices is located 112 Town Center Drive in Warren, New Jersey.

Come and enjoy the evening with like-minded wellness professionals. Visit the Wellness of Warren office space (fractional offices space available) that provides an array of holistic and natural wellness ...


South Plainfield – Joanne Gallo, 68, of Palm Beach Gardens, FL and Warren, NJ, passed away ...
Read more

AAA Cautions: Daylight Saving Could Affect Daily Commute

March 10, 2018

WARREN, NJ - AAA is reminding drivers that the change to Daylight Saving Time may create distractions on the roadway and challenges for drivers who lost an hour of sleep. Daylight Saving Time begins on Sunday at 2 a.m.

“As we spring forward, drivers should be aware that the time change will also mean changes to driving habits,” said Robert Sinclair, Manager of Media ...

School Bus Driver Charged with Sex Assaults Against Students

March 20, 2018

MONTGOMERY, NJ – An 84-year-old township resident has been arrested and charged with sexual assault against an 8-and 12-year-old and as many as seven other children while a bus driver going back to the 1960s, according to Somerset County Prosecutor Michael H. Robertson.

Edward Atoeff of Cherry Valley Road was the owner and operator of Jastyke Transportation at the time of the alleged ...

Whole Foods Delays Opening Due to Predicted Storm

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — Whole Foods, in the new Chimney Rock Plaza in Bridgewater, is officially opening its doors on Friday, March 23.

It was originally scheduled to open March 21, but the opening was delayed because of the predicted nor'easter.

The Bridgewater location is the first Whole Foods in Somerset County. 

The 49,000-square-foot store is featuring ...

UPDATE: Four’Easter May Bring Another Foot of Snow, Be Prepared for School Closures and Power Outages in Warren Township and Surrounding Area

WARREN, NJ - Happy Spring. Get the milk, bread and eggs. Get the generator, gas and chainsaw and be prepared to lose another day of spring break if Wednesday is called a snow day. Heavy mixed precipitation is expected with snow accumulations of 8 to 14 inches in our area by Wednesday evening when the fourth Nor’easter of the year hits. #foureaster is trending, and Winter does ...

Suspended HS Athletic Director Charged with Theft

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ - Suspended Hillsborough High School Athletic Director Michael Fanizzi has been arrested and charged with the theft of $10,704 in athletic event receipts over a four-year period from 2013-2017, according to Somerset County Prosecutor Michael H. Robertson.

Fanizzi, 53, a resident of Conover Way in Hillsborough who had been athletics director for 14 years, had been ...

The Perfect Travel Pack - The Airport Repack Because of a Delayed Flight - What You Really Need

March 21, 2018

If you have traveled a lot, you have had a canceled flight.  Do you know how to do an airport in such cases?

Well, on a recent canceled flight on Norwegian Air from Berlin to New York, we had to do it.  Our experience is now your gain.

The slide show above shows you step by step, how it was accomplished.  Here we will explain it.

For starters, think about your ...

Air Travel Alert - 1,810 Area Flights Canceled for Wednesday - Check Here For Survival Tips in this Fourth Nor’easter

Whenever there is inclement weather, it pays to keep informed. Wednesday, March 21, 780 flights from Newark and 440 from JFK are already canceled.  LaGuardia canceled 590.  In other words, you are probably snowed in today.

Most Airlines now offer APP, text, or email updates to flight delays.  Make sure to sign up for them.  That will ...

Will Your Air Travels Be Impacted by Our Fourth Nor’easter (Fourth? Is it the End?)

After three Nor’easters, you would think we could catch a break. They do say the fourth one is always the best.  This time, we should be very well practiced.

By now, you know the drill. This article has advice on local and airline support services. You may want to bookmark the page for future reference. 

Most Airlines now offer APP, text, or email updates to flight ...

St. Patrick’s Day Sobriety Check in Belmar/Neptune Area on Tap by State Police

March 17, 2018

BELMAR, NJ — Giving no details on location and time, New Jersey State Police plans to conduct a sobriety checkpoint on Saturday, March 17 in the area of Belmar and Neptune Township,

The state police made the announcement on its Facebook page, alerting motorists that state troopers will be pulling over vehicles at this undisclosed location and time  “looking for signs of ...

'Trying' explores age, youth and points of history in poignant production

‘Trying’ explores youth, age and points of history in poignant production

By Liz Keill

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – The George Street Playhouse presents an engrossing, two-character play based on the real life of Francis Biddle, former Attorney General.

Biddle, a Harvard educated lawyer, served under Franklin Roosevelt and later Harry Truman during the Nuremberg Tribunal. His ...