Community Announcements

US Judge Rules Bernards Can't Require More Parking for Mosque Than a Church

47d45c52a859dfaedeb3_ISBRTreesbyHouse.jpg
The Islamic Society of Basking Ridge proposed building a 4,250-square foot mosque for 150 worshippers on more than four acres in Liberty Corner. Credits: By Linda Sadlouskos
a5ea6b275a0ad4f31378_ISBRhearing12.2.jpg
About three years of public Planning Board hearings regarding a proposal for a mosque in Liberty Corner were usually attended by crowds that filled the room. Credits: By Linda Sadlouskos
47d45c52a859dfaedeb3_ISBRTreesbyHouse.jpg

BERNARDS TWP., NJ - A federal judge reportedly ruled on New Year's Eve that the Bernards Township Planning Board acted improperly when it demanded a higher number of parking spaces for a proposed mosque in Liberty Corner than the number of parking spaces that would have been required for a church. 

“The court has held that Bernards Township discriminated against ISBR [Islamic Society of Basking Ridge] based on its Islamic faith and that the township’s actions were unconstitutional," said Adeel Mangi, lead counsel for organization that has proposed construction of a 4,250-square-foot on slightly more than four acres off Church Street in Liberty Corner Village. "This ruling resolves the key disputed land use issues in the case because many of the township’s bases for denial depended on its requirement of a 'supersized' parking lot," Mangi said in an email sent to TAP Into Basking Ridge on Dec. 31. 

Last March, the ISBR had filed a federal lawsuit alleging that the Bernards Township Planning Board's denial of the mosque application on Dec. 8, 2015 was based on religious discrimination. The lawsuit was also filed on behalf of Mohammad Ali Chaudry, president of the ISBR and, as a resident of Basking Ridge, a former member of the Bernards Township Committee. 

Sign Up for E-News

The planned mosque, which would have replaced a mid-20th century house at 124 Church St., would have been built to accommodate 150 or fewer worshippers, the applicants said during about three dozen public hearings prior to the Planning Board's denial of the application.

Bernards Township officials have denied the allegations, and have maintained that the Planning Board's rejection of the application was based on land use laws. During hearings, residents and other township officials also expressed concerns that the project would negatively impact the historic residential neighborhood, and possibly also create traffic backups that would make it difficult for the nearby Liberty Corner Fire Co. to respond to emergency calls. 

The ruling by U.S. District Court Judge Michael A. Shipp, sitting in New Jersey, was in response to a request from the ISBR for a partial ruling on the discrimination case.

Township officials say they 'vehemently disagree' with New Year's Eve ruling

On Jan. 1, Bernards Township Mayor Carol Bianchi issued a release that the township had just received word of Shipp's partial ruling on the case on New Year's Day.

Bianchi said that the township "vehemently disagrees" with Shipp's ruling and will consider how to be move forward with the case, "including appealing the decision when ripe for appeal."

However, Bianchi added that given the holiday, officials are awaiting a full analysis of Shipp's 57-page decision by attorneys representing Bernards in the case.

However, Mangi called the judge's written decision, "a landmark ruling interpreting the [federal] Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act that will have national impact in reaffirming that townships cannot treat applicants differently based on their religion."

In a copy of the the judge's written decision submitted to TAP Into, Shipp pointed to what he said are the "defendants’  [Bernards Township's] disparate application of an off-street parking requirement between Christian churches and Muslim mosques, pursuant to the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (“RLUIPA”)...and the purported unconstitutional vagueness of a parking ordinance."

Shipp said that "after careful consideration," the court determined that the ISBR was entitled to judgment regarding both issues.

Shipp pointed to a Bemards Township parking ordinance that sets forth a general ratio of 3 to 1 between seats for worshippers and parking spaces, and noted that the township has set that ratio of 3:1 as an acceptable standard for “churches.”

"The parking ordinance, by reference, provides a definition of 'churches' that includes mosques, yet [the township's officials] applied their own unsubstantiated interpretation that the term 'churches' exclusively refers to Christian churches and not Muslim mosques," the written ruling states. "Based on their review of the application and relevant evidence, [the township Planning Board and its professionals] required ISBR to construct parking spaces far exceeding the 3:1 ratio afforded to Christian churches," Shipp's ruling said.

During the public hearings before the Planning Board regarding the application, board members and their professionals heard testimony that because mosque worshippers sometimes attended services by driving directly from work, they sometimes arrived with fewer than standard of an average three persons in each vehicle who would be attending services. After initial testimony, township planners raised the required number of parking spaces to 107.

Bianchi noted that Shipp had "opined that the township had to apply the same standard for every house of worship to determine the number of parking spaces, regardless of actual parking demands."

She said that the ruling would prevent the Planning Board from being able to consider a 2010 International Traffic Engineering report or other evidence "to determine the actual parking needs of the institution."

Bianchi said that decision would have major implications for municipal land use boards, including Planning Boards, and their ability to determine the actual off-street parking needs of proposed projects without fear of being accused of religious discrimination, as an alleged violation of RLUIPA.

Second lawsuit filed by U.S. Justice Department in November

Right before Thanksgiving, the U.S. Justice Department also filed a lawsuit against Bernards Township, alleging that the township violated the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000 when it denied zoning approval to allow the ISBR to build the mosque.

The new complaint, which is said to have followed an eight-month investigation, was also filed in U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey. 

A township statement issued in response to the November filing said that the municipality "strongly believes that the DOJ [Department of Justice] action is designed to coerce the township to settle in a manner which does not address proper land use planning."

The township statement said that Bernards had voluntarily cooperated with the Department of Justice investigation with 350 hours of staff time spent on providing 215,000 pages of documentation.

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Warren

Somerset Regional Animal Shelter Offering July Adoption Promotion for Cats/Kittens

July 10, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - The Somerset Regional Animal Shelter, in Bridgewater, is urgently looking for homes for its cats and kittens.

According to a release from the shelter, the population surges throughout the summer during kitten breeding season, and so the shelter is launching a special promotion to help increase cat and kitten adoptions. During the month of July, all cats and kittens that over ...

Do You Recognize These Dogs?

PLAINFIELD, NJ - Two dogs were found in Plainfield near the fire station on Central Avenue on Saturday. 

The dogs are currently with a family in South Plainfield.  If you recognize the dogs, please email TAPinto Plainfield at jpopper@tapinto.net.

A Hidden Gem in the Suburbs – Spring Academy Montessori Pre-School helps children reach their full potential by fostering an innate love of learning!

July 16, 2018

Located on a quiet residential street in Warren, NJ, Spring Academy Montessori Preschool opened its doors to the public in late November 2016.  Spring Academy wanted to fill a niche that was missing in the community -- a pre-school with a Montessori philosophy combined with an emphasis on language immersion.  Since then, parents have been coming from all over to enroll their children in ...

Upcoming Events

Wed, July 25, 7:30 PM

Chatham United Methodist Church, Chatham

Masterwork’s Summer Sings Conclude with Verdi ...

Arts & Entertainment

Wed, October 3, 7:00 PM

SCLSNJ's Warren Township Library branch, Warren

A History of the Old Presbyterian Graveyard in ...

Government Other

Obituaries

Jul 28, 1955 - Feb 8, 2018
Owner/Chef of Jaret’s Stuffed Cupcakes  Beloved Husband, Father, Brother and ...
Read more

Get Ready Warren: Fireworks, Food and Family Fun At Mt. Carmel Feast

July 13, 2018

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, N.J. – It’s time again for the annual Mt. Carmel Feast, a four-day festival full of food, music, games, rides, fireworks, and other family fun, located at Mt. Carmel Field in Berkeley Heights.

The fairgrounds will be open from 6 p.m. to 11 p.m. on Friday, July 13 through Monday, July 16. Those four nights will include concerts, games, and ...

Somerset Regional Animal Shelter Offering July Adoption Promotion for Cats/Kittens

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - The Somerset Regional Animal Shelter, in Bridgewater, is urgently looking for homes for its cats and kittens.

According to a release from the shelter, the population surges throughout the summer during kitten breeding season, and so the shelter is launching a special promotion to help increase cat and kitten adoptions. During the month of July, all cats and kittens that over ...

To Our Current and Future Representatives

July 17, 2018

To Our Current and Future Representatives - Wherever They May Be:

We can never forget we are a nation of immigrants. 

We cannot fall prey to fear, ignorance and anger when we  have been historically driven by freedom and justice. 

We must have the courage and will to fight hate, bigotry and prejudice. 

We must not wake up to what we hoped was a bad dream and ...

Viewing and Funeral Mass Set for 1-Year-Old Boy Killed in July 7 Crash, Fundraiser Established

July 16, 2018

RARITAN, NJ - A viewing for the 1-year-old Raritan boy killed on Anderson Street July 7 will be held this week at St. Ann Church in Raritan, according to an obituary released by the Bongiovi Funeral Home.

Matias Ortega-Rosales was killed on the evening of his first birthday when a vehicle hit two cars and then his family as he was being pushed in a stroller by his mother, Domitila Rosales.

Bedminster Woman Dies From Injuries After Being Struck by Car in Mall Parking Lot

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - A Bedminster woman has died from her injuries after being struck by a car in the parking lot of the Bridgewater Commons Mall Monday.

Marion Kelley, 62, was struck by a vehicle while walking in lot four near the Macy's merchandise pick up area at around 3:20 p.m. Monday.

The 2017 Mazda was driven by Chinmayi Parikh, 33, of Piscataway.

The crash is still being ...

County Kicks Off Summer Concert Series with Bob Miranda and the Happenings

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - The Somerset County Park Commission kicked off its Summer Concert Series at Duke Island Park Sunday with a performance by Bob Miranda and the Happenings.

A very large crowd turned out for the performance by the band made famous in part by the song "See You in September."

The next concert will be held July 15 at 7 p.m. at Duke Island Park, with Billy ...

Somerset County Flags at Half-Staff to Honor Grace Gurisic, First Woman Freeholder

SOMERVILLE, NJ – Somerset County will fly its flags at half-staff July 12 in memory of Grace A. Gurisic, who served as the county’s first woman freeholder more than half a century ago.

Gurisic passed away June 9; she was 84. Funeral services will be held 8:30 a.m. Thursday, July 12, from the Vander May Wayne Colonial Funeral Home in Wayne. A funeral mass will follow at St.

3rd Annual Meadowlands BBQ Battle a Smokin’ Success

July 18, 2018

EAST RUTHERFORD, NJ - Seven competitors battled it out at Meadowlands Racing and Entertainment's 3rd Annual BBQ Battle on Saturday, July 14, all vying for $2,000 in prizes and most importantly, bragging rights. 

The BBQ categories of best Ribs, Brisket, Chicken, and Pulled Pork, came with a $500 prize to the winner of each category. A panel of five judges conducted a blind ...

3-Day ‘AddamsFest’ set to Celebrate Charles Addams and His Creations This Fall

WESTFIELD, NJ — It’s creepy. It’s kooky. And it’s taking over Westfield from Oct 26 to 28. AddamsFest, a town-wide celebration honoring Westfield native Charles Addams and his most famous creations, The Addams Family, will be a destination event this fall with family-friendly activities, lectures, exhibits and film screenings, the town announced Thursday.

Watch the ...

Make the Call, Save a Life

July 10, 2018

EAST BRUNSWICK, NJ - There is much focus on preventative opioid abuse education. Rightfully so. However, the goal in addressing the opioid epidemic is saving lives. Even if that means just saving one life. While people are becoming increasingly aware of resources relating to rehabilitative services, support groups for friends and family of addicts, and training parents for signs of opioid and ...