Real Estate

Roseland Council Adopts Ordinances to Redevelop Sites for Apartment and Affordable Housing Use


ROSELAND, NJ—The Roseland Borough Council, facing a standing-room-only audience in borough hall, voted 5-1 on Tuesday to pass two ordinances that adopt redevelopment plans to replace two “functionally obsolete” Roseland office buildings with residential complexes totaling 440 units of which 88 would contain affordable housing.

The complexes in question are at 6 Becker Farm Road and 85 Livingston Avenue, inside an office park owned by the Mack-Cali Corporation.

Under the redevelopment plans, according to the council, the Becker Farm Road property would house 300 total units, of which 60 would be used for affordable housing, and the Livingston Avenue property would encompass 140 units, of which 28 would fall into the “affordable” category.

Sign Up for E-News

The plan for the Livingston Avenue site also envisions a “high-end” hotel and “high-end” restaurant.

Both redevelopment plans are seen by Roseland officials as aiding efforts by the borough to meet its state-mandated obligation to provide affordable housing within the borough’s borders. The borough currently is involved in litigation designed to establish its “Fair Share Obligation” under New Jersey housing laws and the means to address this obligation.

“It is not a matter of whether more affordable housing will be built in Roseland, because it will be,” said Roseland Mayor John Duthie. “We can, however, determine for ourselves where we want that housing to be built.”

Duthie added that, in addition to the developers of the two office-complex sites, in the complicated affordable housing litigation, there are two “intervenors” who also would like to develop affordable housing in Roseland.

The mayor noted that the areas proposed for affordable housing by the intervenors would involve sites in the center of the borough—one on Harrison Avenue in the area of many existing single-family homes and the other on Passaic Avenue, near the borough’s Lester C. Noecker School.

He said the sites would encompass 15 and 26 acres in area. He added that housing built on either site would add to traffic congestion and existing infrastructure in the areas might not be sufficient to handle the increased volume.

Duthie also said the Becker Farm Road building, which is currently vacant, recently sold for $16.7 million, a price considerably below its original assessed value of $23 million. He said the Livingston Avenue site faced a similar decrease in value, due to the fact that suburban office parks are increasingly falling out of favor with potential business occupants. This includes another office property at 65 Livingston Avenue, which is in foreclosure.

The mayor added that the decreases in value of the two buildings have resulted in considerable settlements in tax appeals recently—shifting more of the borough’s property-tax burden onto residential property taxpayers.

He also said that although Roseland complied with all its past affordable-housing obligations and was given credit for supporting an eight-unit apartment for the Essex County ARC, the recent revision of statewide housing obligations by the courts has failed to recognize this.

“My concern is with the five times the amount of affordable housing we must built to get to the affordable housing number,” said Duthie.

He also said that the two office complexes are much better situated, in terms of existing infrastructure and the location of the office park, directly off Route 280.

Borough Council President Mark Vidovich added that it is possible that, if Roseland does not come to a fair-share housing agreement before a mid-September deadline imposed by the courts, it could face an obligation to build at least 466 additional affordable housing units in addition to the 66 such units that currently exist in the borough.

He pointed out, however, that, at this juncture, the borough does not have a solid figure as to what its affordable housing quota actually is.

If developers are allowed to produce 20 percent of each development in affordable units, he said this could result in 2300 additional homes in Roseland.

“I don’t want to see the town I grew up in, where I raised my family and where I plan to retire drastically altered,” said Vidovich.

Additionally, he said the “immediate need”—housing units that the borough must have built as soon as possible to meet its obligation—has fluctuated from 70 to 90 affordable units to 500 units to be built with 100 of them being affordable.

Vidovich also noted that the intervenor on the Passaic Avenue site wants to construct 150 units—something that would make an already congested and difficult turn on Passaic Avenue more difficult, he said.

The intervenor on the Harrison Avenue, he added, wants to construct 400 units in that area.

The council president also added that commercial real estate values in the borough have dropped more than $500 million in the last six years. He said he would be interested in the hotel proposal because it offers a chance to “rescue” the “dying breed” of an office park and make Roseland a more attractive destination.

William Northgrave, the attorney hired to oversee the borough’s development efforts, said the ordinances adopted on Tuesday would only provide the “boxes,” or outlines, for redevelopment of the two sites. He noted that formal redevelopment and financial plans would need to be implemented and agreed upon by all parties and any formal proposals would have to come before the borough planning board with site plans.

If the borough does not produce redevelopment plans, he said, state courts and the developers would be able to decide where affordable housing is to be located within the borough.

Roseland currently has a “stay” of court actions, he said, while it works out redevelopment plans. If it comes to an agreement with the courts and the Fair Share Housing Corporation, which is the advocate for those seeking affordable housing, before the mid-September deadline, it will stave off “Builders’ Remedy” litigation.

Northgrave explained that under Builders’ Remedy developers, it would be virtually able to dictate where and how affordable housing would be built.

Borough attorney Ethan Sheffet added that Builder’s Remedy litigation would enable developers to ignore Roseland zoning restrictions and build where they want to meet affordable housing quotas.

However, Claudia Reese of 4 Cooper Avenue, a member of the Roseland Affordable Housing Committee, said many communities around the state have satisfied their obligations without filing declaratory actions such as those filed by the borough.

She added that only 11 municipalities in Essex County have sought declaratory relief.

Reese also said that affordable housing standards dictate that the units be located near existing housing stock.

Several Roseland residents at the meeting questioned whether the payments in lieu of taxes (PILOTs) to be paid by developers such as Mack-Cali would sufficiently compensate the borough for increased infrastructure it would need to support the new housing developments.

They also noted that, since 95 percent of the PILOTs would be going to the municipality, the borough’s elementary schools and the regional school district to which it belongs would be shortchanged.

Northgrave said that, in his many years of experience, PILOTs, or annual service charges, as they more properly are called, more than made up for any added expenses brought into communities whose developers paid them in lieu of taxes.

He added that market studies have shown that developments such as those contemplated did not significantly add students to the school populations in host communities, and the additional students by and large came from the affordable housing portions of the developments.

The development expert added that although the schools would not be getting additional tax revenue, they would not be getting less revenue than they already had.

He also said that if the schools did incur more-than-anticipated expenses due to the expanded student populations coming from the developments they could negotiate with the borough to provide some of the PILOT revenues as an offset to them.

During the council discussion on the redevelopment proposals, Councilman Richard Leonard questioned whether the borough could receive information on whether the proposed residential units were to be purchased or rented and, if so, whether this made a difference in financial calculations.

He was told that although the developers had not specified whether the units were to be for purchase or rental, the assumption was that they were to be rental units and that it made little difference in the initial calculations.

Leonard also objected to the density of the two projects—at 28 units per acre.

When the vote came, he was the only governing body member to vote against the redevelopment ordinances.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

West Essex

West Orange Restaurant Week Heads Into Weekend; Don't Miss These Offers

March 16, 2018

WEST ORANGE, NJ — Restaurants and eateries from throughout West Orange are currently participating in the Downtown West Orange Alliance’s (DWOA) second annual Restaurant Week, which wraps up on Saturday.

There will also be an opportunity to win $250 in restaurant gift certificates for purchases made during Restaurant Week.

For every purchase made at ...

Upcoming Events


Sun, March 18, 12:00 PM

West Essex Middle School Gym, North Caldwell

West Essex Class of 2020 Tricky Tray



Sun, March 18, 2:00 PM

West Caldwell Public Library, West Caldwell

Irish Folk Music Concert

Arts & Entertainment

Mon, March 19, 2:00 PM

Fairfield Free Public Library, Fairfield

Pre-K Storytime

Arts & Entertainment Education

Valyrian Steel: Where is it All? Should We Still Care?

There is a glaring hole in recent Game of Thrones seasons that needs to be addressed: the ability of Valyrian steel to destroy White Walkers has not been acknowledged since before Jon Snow’s death.

In fact, it hasn’t been mentioned since the Season Five finale when Jon Snow reveals this discovery to Sam Tarly. Jon has cared about little more than the war between the living and ...

Health Alert: Child with Measles Traveled to Newark Airport on March 12

March 15, 2018

TRENTON, NJ — Anyone at Newark Liberty International Airport on Monday, March 12 between 12:45 and 9 p.m. might have been exposed to measles and should contact their health care provider, according to the New Jersey Department of Health (NJDH).

The NJDH has issued a public health alert after a child with a confirmed case of measles—a highly contagious ...


- Mar 14, 2018
Obituary for Anne M. Gaeta (Corona) Anne M. Gaeta, nee Corona, 86, of Roseland, NJ, beloved ...
Read more
- Mar 11, 2018
Walter E. Hanley, Jr., 82, of Fairfield, New Jersey, passed away on Sunday, March 11, 2018. Beloved ...
Read more
Dec 11, 1941 - Mar 13, 2018
Roslyn Elaine Prosperi (nee Flexer),76, of Fairfield, NJ, passed away on Tuesday March 13, 2018.
Read more
WEST CALDWELL, NJ - The Honorable Robert L. Reiher, 83, of Bonita Springs, FL and Ocean Beach, NJ, ...
Read more
  WEST CALDWELL, NJ - After a long illness, 6 years old Juliana Rose Donnelly died ...
Read more
WEST ESSEX, NJ - Thomas (Tom) A. Callahan Sr. passed away at the age of 73 at his home in ...
Read more
William Francis Verhaegen, Jr., of Aliso Viejo, California, died suddenly at Saddleback Memorial ...
Read more

Komen North Jersey Pink Tie Party Set For March 16

March 12, 2018

SUMMIT, NJ - The annual Susan G. Komen North Jersey Pink Tie Party fundraiser affair is coming up.

The event, which will be held Friday, March 16 at The Grove in Cedar Grove, is focused on raising funds to support Komen’s BOLD GOAL:  to reduce the number of breast cancer deaths in the U.S. by 50% by the year 2026, by improving access to quality and ...

Coffee, Tea or Fleas?

Two ducks are on a flight to Miami.  The first duck says to the second, “you flying south for the winter?”  The second duck replies, “Oh wow, a talking emotional support duck!”


Pa rum pum.


There have been a lot of news stories lately about animals traveling on airplanes.  Some are humorous, like the woman who recently tried to bring ...