Roseland Councilmen Rescind Resignations and Apologize for Racist, Anti-Semitic Text Message Conversation    

Councilmen Jacobs and Tsilionis speak with Roseland residents attending the tense meeting. Credits: Alan Grossman
The council chambers were packed with residents who wanted to express their views on the issues surrounding the councilmen who reneged on their resignations Credits: Alan Grossman
Roseland Republican chairperson Mary Comito speaks about the party’s disappointment that the councilmen rescinded their decision to resign from the council. Credits: Alan Grossman

ROSELAND, NJ – Roseland councilmen Thomas Tsilionis and David Jacobs, who resigned on Feb. 19 after being widely criticized for a racist, anti-Semitic text message conversation, told the crowd at the Roseland Borough Council meeting on Tuesday that they are rescinding their resignations.

Both men announced that they would remain in their positions while resigning from the Republican Party. 

This reversal of their decision did not sit well with Roseland Mayor John Duthie, who asked both men to resign from the council.

Sign Up for E-News

“Racism and anti-Semitism in every form and fashion must be condemned in the strongest way possible,” said Duthie. “There is no place for these prejudices in our society. There is certainly no place for them in government.”

Duthie added that elected officials must hold themselves to the highest standards.

“Any racist or anti-Semite who occupies a public office should immediately resign,” he said. “I would condemn any such elected official in the strongest of terms.”

Both Tsilionis and Jacobs were given the opportunity to defend themselves. Tsilionis began by apologizing for the text message, which he admitted was offensive if “taken out of context.”

“I do not have a racist or anti-Semitic bone in my body,” he said. “These texts originated between friends. There was no borough business discussed.”

In his attempt to “put things in perspective,” Tsilionis said that Councilman Richard Leonard only decided to release this “private conversation” that took place eight months ago to the press early this year because Leonard lost the vote to be the next council president to new council president Mark Vidovich.

“Political bullying has no place in Roseland,” said Tsilionis in explaining why he changed his mind not to resign.

Jacobs, who is Jewish, apologized for answering Tsilionis’ anti-Semitic text with a “jest that was negative toward Jews, inappropriate, insensitive and offensive.”

“I must meet a higher standard,” he said. “I am truly remorseful for what I did, and have been asked to resign. I will resign from the Republic Party, but I will not resign as a councilman.”  

Both men indicated that they received an outpouring of support over the past week from friends and neighbors telling them not to resign.

 “They told me if I resign, I would be letting them down, and they know I am not anti-Semitic,” said Jacobs. “Members of the Jewish community have told me I must not resign. A resignation will not fight anti-Semitism.”

Jacobs also agreed with Tsilionis that Councilman Leonard’s decision to release the text message to the press “was an act of bullying” because he did not support him as council president.

“I will not be bullied,” said Jacobs. “I will stand my ground. I apologize to the citizens of Roseland. My comment was not made with any malice towards any one. I am sensitive to racism and discrimination.”

He added that he was called anti-Semitic names when he was in school as a young man.

During public comment, where more than 30 people gave their opinions about this situation, Roseland Republican chairperson Mary Comito spoke about the party’s disappointment that the councilmen rescinded their decision to resign from the council.

“They both committed to us in private and in public statements that for the good of Roseland they would step aside,” she said. “We accept their resignation from our party, yet remain steadfast in calling for their resignation from the governing body of Roseland. Their actions were indefensible and inexcusable.”

As a reflection of the tension this issue has brought to the fore in Roseland, there was a large police presence at the meeting that took place at the Municipal Building on Harrison Avenue. Roseland police cars stretched out across the front of the building, and a police barricade was put up to ensure that the nearly 200 residents in attendance—both in the council chambers and in the halls—could not enter until a half an hour before the start of the meeting.

Residents who spoke about this issue during public comment expressed many diverse opinions.

Resident Emily Levine was among those who felt torn about whether the councilmen were making the right decision. She said that both councilmen seemed genuinely remorseful about what they said, but they should have known better than using hurtful, disparaging remarks against Jewish people.

On the other hand, Levine joined many others who questioned why Councilman Leonard waited so long to give these text comments to the press.

“The sharing of these texts doesn’t pass the sniff test,” she said.

Among the many residents critical of the councilmen was Roger Freda, who said, “The councilmen’s comments were disgraceful, and a slap in the face to every resident.”

“How do I explain to my daughter, who is six years old, that it’s not just okay to apologize and go to another table?” he said, accusing Tsilionis of only wanting to stay for his health benefits. “Do what needs to be done for Roseland, not just for your benefit.”

Councilman Leonard claimed that he was not pleased with how this whole issue has played out.

“I’m hoping we can use this incident to make sure we are an inclusive community,” said Leonard.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

West Essex

Free Class at CylcleBar Livingston to Support Sustainability

June 22, 2018

LIVINGSTON, NJ — Join us at CycleBar Livingston for Uplift Humanity's first charity event! In addition to getting your sweat on for FREE, you can learn about about how we are using a sustainability-first approach to solve poverty in developing countries around the world. Meet our Board and Founder and get information on volunteer opportunities.

We've partnered with ...

Deegan Dental Implant Special!


Deegan Dental is happy to announce our New Dental Implant Special Offer that covers a single Complete Tooth Replacement (including the Implant, Stock Abutment and E-max Crown) for only $2,200 per Implant; a Great Value compared with our usual $4,000 fee!

Dental Implants look and feel like your own ...

Upcoming Events


Sat, June 23, 1:00 PM

Fairfield Free Public Library, Fairfield

Special Summer Reading Kick Off Show: Green Golly ...



Sun, June 24, 11:00 AM


MakerFest 2018


Mon, June 25, 9:00 AM

Anthony Santomauro, North Caldwell

Legends Baseball “School’s Out Baseball Camp”

Education Health & Wellness Other Sports

Winners of 19th Annual Gaelen Juried Art Show & Sale Announced

June 21, 2018

WHIPPANY, NJ - Winners of the 19th annual Gaelen Juried Art Show & Sale were announced at the Opening Reception on Sunday, June 10.   The show will run through Sunday, July 29 at the Gaelen Gallery West, Aidekman Family Campus, 901 Route 10 East, Whippany.

Awards were presented at the Opening Reception for Best in Show and Best /Honorable Mention in the following categories: ...


Mar 23, 1932 - Jun 2, 2018
Obituary - Donald J. Cooney, March 23, 1932 to June 2, 2018 Donald J. Cooney, 86, of North ...
Read more

A Special Thank You For Helping Us Weather The Storm

June 18, 2018

About a month ago, on May 15, 2018, something happened to me and my family that changed our lives. An act of God, apparently a “microburst,” tore through our front yard, and uprooted an approximately 19,000 pound tree. The tree fell into my 8 month old’s bedroom destroying the entire structure of our home.

My husband, with what I call divine intervention, told us to go ...

Sobel & Co. Valuation Practice and EAC Valuations LLC Merge

“We are pleased to announce that EAC Valuations PA has joined the Sobel & Co. Valuation Practice to create Sobel Valuations LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Sobel & Co.,” said Alan Sobel, managing member of the firm.

“From the first time Frank Merenda, president and CEO of EAC Valuations, met with the Sobel & Co. valuation team, we quickly recognized the power of ...

My So-Called Graduation

The last of my children graduated from high school.  


My son and daughter threw their caps high into the air and cheered their liberation from one symbolic institution before contemplating their matriculation into other, much larger institutions significantly further away.  


Or at least far enough away that they won’t be needing rides home from ...