West Orange School District Retains Third-Party Law Firm for Special Investigations

Credits: Cynthia Cumming
Millburn Township Council adopts resolution to return funds to West Orange Board of Education on April 19, 2016
Portion of the Corrective Action Plan adopted by the West Orange Board of Education in December 2016
The Gregory Elementary financial transaction in question was specifically documented by the board of education's Independent Auditor in the November 2016 Auditor’s Management Report

WEST ORANGE, NJ  — The West Orange Board of Education (WOBOE) adopted a resolution on Monday to hire a third-party law firm in order to ensure a “complete, thorough and impartial review” of certain matters, including accusations made by members of the public about a school employee’s improper use of student funds to pay her personal property taxes in 2016.

At a recent WOBOE meeting, West Orange resident Micaela Bennett brought up the incident she and others uncovered during an open-records request and she accused a Gregory Elementary School employee of embezzlement. Bennett also alleges that Superintendent of Schools Jeffrey Rutzky covered up the incident by not informing the board, stating that she and others uncovered records showing that Rutzky penned a request to Millburn requesting the money be returned because of the “tax payment made in error.”

The chief financial officer for Millburn Township confirmed earlier this week that he did receive an electronic payment (ACH) of $2,764.40 from the employee in question in 2016 as well as a letter from the superintendent requesting a refund in the same amount. He also confirmed that the Millburn Tax Collector refunded this amount to the WOBOE at the time, and reiterated that the payment did not come from a checkbook owned by Gregory Elementary School.

Sign Up for E-News

In response to inquiries on Thursday regarding the school’s financial transactions and the improper use of funds, the board declined to say whether the employee had been disciplined, stating that it would be unlawful to comment on any personnel matters. However, her name remains listed on the school’s website. It should be noted that TAPinto West Orange is not disclosing the name of the employee because she has not been charged with any criminal wrongdoing.

On behalf of the WOBOE, Vice-President Mark Robertson shed light on the situation in question in a written statement.

“The public should be aware that the Gregory Elementary financial transaction in question was specifically documented by the board’s independent auditor in the 2016 Auditor’s Management Report, which was completed on Nov. 21, 2016 and presented in public session at the board meeting on Dec. 12, 2016,” said Robertson.

Robertson provided the auditor’s management report as well as the agenda for the December 2016 meeting, during which the board adopted a “Corrective Action Plan” that the independent auditor presented. This is public information and can also be seen on the district website.

He did not address whether the board had knowledge about the incident prior to the audit, which occurred and was published several months after the event. It remains unclear at what point the WOBOE was made aware of these actions.

The WOBOE has retained Chiesa, Shahinian & Giantomasi (CSG), which is headed by former New Jersey Attorney General Jeffrey Chiesa, whose firm has extensive expertise in conducting special investigations, according to Robertson.

“The board’s purpose of engaging an independent third-party law firm is to ensure that the special investigations are impartial and devoid of the possibility and/or appearance of any possible conflicts,” Robertson said. “The board looks forward to receiving the special counsel’s investigations and recommendations in order to resolve fully these matters. The board of education takes all allegations and/or concerns by the public very seriously.”

Robertson added that the members of the WOBOE have investigated and will continue to investigate all such concerns brought before them.

Concerned citizens bring issue to light

Bennett, who alerted the public about the incident via a private Facebook group for West Orange residents, said she is part of a small group of concerned citizens who have been looking into Rutzky’s past and keeping tabs on school board actions.

“Shouldn't we all be passionate about our children?” said Bennett, who has lived in West Orange since 2005 and whose son is a graduating fifth-grader at St. Cloud Elementary. “Our children being well-educated and supported through their school years should be a common denominator.”

Her concerns about the superintendent go beyond what she categorized as a “cover up” regarding the Gregory school funds.

“I hope the board recognizes that they have a responsibility to supervise the superintendent,” Bennett said.

She noted that Thomas Volscho, another member of the group, made several public records requests to find information about the incident involving the misuse of funds.

Bianca Prieto contributed to this article.

Don’t miss important news in your town. Click HERE to subscribe for free, or follow us on Facebook and on Twitter at @WestOrangeTAP.

To download the FREE TAPinto App, Click here for Android or Click here for iOS.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

West Orange

Free Class at CylcleBar Livingston to Support Sustainability

June 22, 2018

LIVINGSTON, NJ — Join us at CycleBar Livingston for Uplift Humanity's first charity event! In addition to getting your sweat on for FREE, you can learn about about how we are using a sustainability-first approach to solve poverty in developing countries around the world. Meet our Board and Founder and get information on volunteer opportunities.

We've partnered with ...

Deegan Dental Implant Special!


Deegan Dental is happy to announce our New Dental Implant Special Offer that will give you a reason to smile! Our New Special Offer, that expires 11/30/2018, covers a single Complete Tooth Replacement (including the Implant, Stock Abutment and E-max Crown) for only $2,200 per Implant; a Great Value ...

Former Jefferson School (Maplewood) Staffer Facing Criminal Charges For Alleged Lewd Photos of Students

June 22, 2018

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - A former Jefferson Elementary School paraprofessional has been charged with criminal behavior believed to be related to lewd photos of students at the school that were found on his cell phone after he was arrested in Morris County on an unrelated sexual charge.

It also appears that South Orange Maplewood School District officials knew about the arrests as early as ...

Upcoming Events


Sun, June 24, 11:00 AM


MakerFest 2018


Sun, June 24, 12:00 PM

Cyclebar Livingston, Livingston

Free Cycling at CycleBar Livingston to Support ...

Giving Back Health & Wellness

Tue, June 26, 8:15 AM

Whole Foods market, West Orange

JBN Presents: Women's Networking in West Orange

Business & Finance

Michael T. McCormick, Jr. Memorial Foundation Donates New Scoreboard to the West Orange PAL Baseball Field

On Sunday, April 15, the West Orange PAL baseball teams began their opening ceremonies of the spring season with a heartfelt dedication of a new scoreboard, donated by the Michael T. McCormick, Jr. Memorial Foundation.  The foundation was created to honor the life of Michael, a lifelong West Orange resident, who tragically died in a car accident on the day after his 19th birthday, Aug.

Mt. Olive Memorial Weekend Tournament: Bringing Baseball Back to West Orange!

“I’ve got to find the right spot”

“Two out rally!”

“Protect the ball”

“You fired up? I’m fired up! I can’t hear you!”

“Breathe!” “Deep breath, reset”

“Whoa..where are you going?? You can’t move”

Just a few of the statements you may have heard this past weekend at the ...

Essex County Turtle Back Zoo Schedules Family Nights and Zoo-vies This Summer

June 21, 2018

WEST ORANGE, NJ - Essex County Turtle Back Zoo will have Family Nights with extended evening hours to 8:30 p.m. on Wednesdays and Thursdays during the months of July and August, with the last admission to the zoo at 8 p.m.

In addition, on Wednesday evenings during July and August, Zoo-vies, featuring animal-related movies, will be shown on the top floor of the Turtle Back Zoo Parking ...

My So-Called Graduation

The last of my children graduated from high school.  


My son and daughter threw their caps high into the air and cheered their liberation from one symbolic institution before contemplating their matriculation into other, much larger institutions significantly further away.  


Or at least far enough away that they won’t be needing rides home from ...

'Half Time' delivers with sterling cast

MILLBURN, NJ – The Paper Mill Playhouse is putting on a smashing new production of “Half Time” to round out its current season.

With actress Georgia Engel in an engaging performance, the cast also features Donna McKehnie, Andre De Shieilds and Lilias White, among a host of other talents.

The musical centers on an effort to have seniors perform a dance number during ...

'Half Time' lights up Paper Mill stage

‘Half Time’ turns the tables on aging in gleeful production

By Liz Keill

MILLBURN, NJ – The Paper Mill Playhouse is putting on a smashing new production of “Half Time” to round out its current season.

With actress Georgia Engel in an engaging performance, the cast also features Donna McKehnie, Andre De Shieilds and Lilias White, among a host of other ...