Education

Complaint Filed Against West Orange School District Determined to Be Without Merit by NJ Office of Special Education Programs

WEST ORANGE, NJ - On November 1,  the New Jersey Office of Special Education Programs rendered their decision on the complaint filed on August 23 against the West Orange School district by Susan Freivald and Alexandra DeRonde, who are also co-presidents of PASSE (Parents Advocating for Special Services in Education) along with Renay Zamloot, a Non-Attorney Education Advocate. The decision determined that  the district was "accordingly determined to have been generally compliant with the special education regulations" as they pertained to the complaint, which revolved around the implementation of block scheduling and curriculum changes at  Liberty and Roosevelt Middle Schools. Freivald/DeRonde argued that the schedule changes and integration of Special Needs students into World Languages courses had not been properly addressed to parents and caregivers of special needs students. The Board of Education approved the LMS and RMS Schedules on June 26, 2013.

The West Orange Department of Special Services spent the summer meeting compliance requirements for special needs students (students with IEPs, or Individualized Education Programs) as they pertained to the schedule changes at LMS and RMS.  In the opening remarks in the decision received by the West Orange School district by the NJ Office of Special Education Programs, the requirements were laid out:

Students' special education programs and placements may be changed only with a formal change to their lEPs pursuant to N.JAC6A:14-3J. Changes to the IEP without a meeting may be made with written parental consent pursuant to NJA.C.6A:14-3.7(d); otherwise, an IEP meeting must be convened. Written notice of the proposed changes to students' IEPs must be provided to parents in accordance with the requirements of NJ.AC. 6A:14-23. In developing students' lEPs, districts must take into account the academic, developmental and functional needs of students, and develop a program, including appropriate modifications, supports and accommodations, for the student to progress in the general curriculum, N.JA.C. 6A:14-3J.
 
 
Interim Superintendent James O'Neill, in a statement to the Alternative Press, noted:
 
On Friday November 1, 2013 the district received the official report from the state Office of Special Education Programs.  The investigation was the result of a complaint filed by two West Orange residents who purport to have expertise about special education issues and who profess to be knowledgeable advocates for parents of classified students.  I indicated to the Board and the public at the time that I felt the charges were without merit.   I am delighted to report the state has confirmed the West Orange School district not only appropriately exercised our right to modify the program but because it was within the “districts authority to organize it delivery of curriculum and instruction , it was not necessary to amend the student’s IEP’s to implement the district-wide change…. The district followed the required procedural steps to amend and implement student IEP’s.”
 

The official report from the state Office of Special Education Programs went on to say that:
 
In this matter, the West Orange Board of Education exercised its authority to modify the program of study delivered to all students at the middle school level and to ensure equal access to the curriculum, including world languages, for students with disabilities. Because it was within the district's authority to organize its delivery of curriculum and instruction, it was not necessary to amend students' IEPs to implement the district-wide change; however, in order to address the master schedule change, the district acted expeditiously to amend students' IEPs to reflect the changed curriculum. Amendments were made without meetings with written parental consent as permitted by N.J.A.C. 6A:14-3.7(d); otherwise JEP meetings were scheduled to make the changes as required by N.J.A.C. 6A:14-3.7 and 2.3. Written notice that met the requirements of
N.J.A.C. 6A:14-2.3 was provided to the parents in the course of making the IEP changes. In those instances where lEPs have not been amended, IEP meetings have been scheduled, and the students' IEPs have been implemented in the context of the new schedule. The district followed the required procedural steps
to amend and implement students' IEPs, and is accordingly determined to have been generally compliant with the special education regulations.1 However, for those two students whose lEPs have not been amended to date, the district is directed to convene JEP meetings and consider the special education services to be delivered to them. Copies of those students' revised IEP should be provided
to OSEP within 30 days of the date of this report.
 
Sue Freivald and Alexandra DeRonde were contacted by the West Orange Alternative Press for their comments regarding the New Jersey Office of Special Education Programs' determination regarding their complaint:
 
"We appreciate the investigator's time and efforts. We filed the complaint on behalf of parents who had approached us with concerns about negative effects on their children, and because of our own concerns about compliance with the law. 
 
While we respect the state's decision, we regret the judgment that the district-wide changes were acceptable, since this seems to ignore the foundational premise of individualized education plans (IEPs): that the individual needs of each special education student must be considered whenever the district takes action.

Also, the state's ruling does not mean that all the changes made were appropriate for all students affected by them. For instance, we appreciate that fact that Sandra Mordecai has asked the superintendent to look into whether severely impaired 8th grade students from self-contained classes have been placed in freshman-level general ed World Language without consideration of their needs and level of functioning. Instead of taking them out of World Language or providing other instruction they need, such as reading, district staff are simply making the World Language classes pass/fail, even telling parents that as long as the child attends class, they will pass. This is not appropriate for either the struggling students with special needs, whose time is being wasted, nor all the other students in the class who must work hard to get good grades in World Language. We look forward to working with the district on solving these remaining problems."

Interim Superintendent O'Neill, however, was pleased with the decision of the State Office of Special Education Programs determination regarding the complaint, and went on to say:

"The district spent an excessive amount of time, money and manpower to prove what we were doing was correct all along.  The individuals who filed this complaint have professed to discover district wrong doing in other areas of our operation.   They not only owe an apology to the district but to the taxpayers who have underwritten the cost of the investigation. 
 
Some local publications found filing of the complaint to be front page news.   Perhaps this news will get the same attention."
 
 
 

 

 

 
 

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

West Orange

Our Lady of the Lake One of 50 Private Schools to be Nominated by the Council for American Private Education (CAPE) for the National Blue Ribbon Schools Program

February 13, 2017

Verona, NJ - Our Lady of the Lake School (OLL), a 2011 Blue Ribbon School, received its second-consecutive nomination for the National Blue Ribbon Schools Program by the Council for American Private Education (CAPE). 

OLL is one of 50 private schools throughout the nation to have its application submitted to the U.S. Department of Education for further review. The list of ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_f9921a06db9f183a7730_reel_film_series-winter_2017_17_flyer

Wed, February 22, 12:00 PM

JCC Leon & Toby Cooperman, West Orange

NJ Jewish Film Festival Reel Film Series

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_3989fd92d368f650301a_mini_magick20170115-8063-15yyhez

Thu, February 23, 6:30 PM

Township of West Orange, West Orange

Mayor Parisi's Open Office Hours

Community Calendar Government

Carousel_image_79548a876edeb5df282b_eb72b149b363cd11febd_a1b7f06aa53b6ab2ba46_shipwrecked_icon

Fri, February 24, 8:00 PM

Dreamcatcher Repertory Theatre, Summit

Shipwrecked! An Entertainment

Arts & Entertainment

Congressman Rodney Frelinghuysen

February 15, 2017

To the Editor:

There has been much discussion recently about representatives in our government who pretend to represent their constituents, but who have been corrupted by special interest groups or blind self-interest. Unfortunately, in the 11th District, we have one such politician who, by his actions, is a significant part of the problem that we have in the federal government.

Orange/West Orange UNICO to Host 43rd Annual Sports Breakfast

February 17, 2017

WEST ORANGE, NJ — The Orange/West Orange Chapter of UNICO National will be hosting its 43rd Annual Sports Breakfast on Sunday, Feb. 26 at 10 a.m. in the Tarnoff Cafeteria at West Orange High School (WOHS).

The event, which typically attracts more than 300 people, honors the “unsung heroes” from West Orange High School, Seton Hall Prep, Golda Och Academy and Orange ...

A Heartbreak Kid

It hurts.

 

She was sobbing pretty hard when she said it, so it came out more as a halting stutter.  It hu . . . hu . . . hu . . . rts. 

 

My arms were wrapped around her and her head was buried in my shoulder as she cried.  She was just a little girl the last time I comforted her like this.  Now she is a young woman.  

 

With a broken ...

‘Shipwrecked’ Rollicks Along at Dreamcatcher Theatre

SUMMIT, NJ – You may be in for a high seas adventure if you visit “Shipwrecked! An Entertainment, The Amazing Adventures of Louis de Rougemont (as Told by Himself).”

This 90-minute play by Donald Margulies has plenty to keep you entranced. Margulies has won just about every theatre award possible for such plays as “Time Stands Still” and “Dinner with ...