Letters to the Editor

FieldTurf Objects to Westfield's Choice for Sid Fay and Houlihan Fields


Editor’ note: The following letter was sent to Westfield Town Administrator Jim Gildea before the town council meeting Tuesday. To read about that meeting, click here.

Re: Synthetic Turf Replacement at Sid Fay & Houlihan Fields

Mr. Gildea,

Sign Up for E-News

FieldTurf has recently obtained the recommendation letters by Mr. John Belle with respect to the above mentioned turf fields, copies of which are attached for your review and reference. In his letters, Mr. Belle recommends the Desso iDNA‐60 and ranks our product (FieldTurf / Tarkett XM6‐6049H) 2nd – even when considering that our offer was $75,000 cheaper than that of Desso.

I wanted to personally reach out to you because of my concern with the recommendation made by Mr. Belle. It is clear by the arguments made by Mr. Belle that he does not have a clear understanding of the technical issues involved in either product and, as a result, may be misleading the client in to believing that they are receiving a higher quality product from Desso.

Several of Mr. Belle’s technical recommendations are made without merit:

‐ Mr. Belle makes a statement about the artificial turf polymers. We proudly use a C6 metallocene fiber – the most durable combination that we’ve seen.

We also know that fiber durability is a lot more than just Polymer. It’s about PPG – Polymer, Process, and Geometry. The combination of these three attributes is what makes a fiber durable and resilient.

‐ Mr. Belle continues with his flippant technical points in his letter dated January 6th, 2014 by commenting about UV inhibitors. FieldTurf’s XM6 fibers are packed with 10,000 HALS of UV protection – the most we’ve seen by any turf manufacturer.

- Ironically, despite the fact that Mr. Belle relies heavily on the Lisport data, he has ignored the fact that Lisport is done in a laboratory without the presence of sunlight or UV.

‐ Mr. Belle makes an absurd comment that “a heavier face weight will last longer”, when there is actually no proof to support that claim. It’s quite shocking that a consultant would make such a comment when there is absolutely no scientific evidence.

- In fact, as proof to the contrary, Penn State University’s Sports Surface Research Center conducted their own independent testing on 13 different monofilament fibers and found the 40 ounce FieldTurf product to be the most durable of all tested. The 60 ounce systems from Astroturf and 45 ounce system from Mondo were significantly less durable.

The entire report is available here: http://plantscience.psu.edu/research/centers/ssrc/documents/lisport‐report.pdf

- What is interesting is that Mr. Belle keenly refers to the wear scale implemented by Penn State (Good, Hair‐Splitting, Fractured, Complete Splitting), but fails to recognize the actual test report and superior results of the FieldTurf Revolution system.

- What is of equal concern is the source of the referenced Lisport testing in the January 6th, 2014 report. Mr. Belle makes reference to the results of XM6‐6049H, but truthfully no such test results exist – specifically because we have never produced such a sample for testing.

‐ Mr. Belle goes on to discuss monofilament versus slit‐film and chooses to ignore the slit‐film product results. We believe that it is common knowledge in the industry that slit‐film turf systems are far more durable than monofilament turf systems. If it was a durable system that Mr. Belle sought, then he should have opted for a slit‐film option at Sid Fay and Houlihan Fields. That would be our recommendation.

Considering the following:

‐ Both of Desso’s “high profile” fields in North America were recently replaced. The University of Wyoming was replaced with FieldTurf and Oklahoma State University was replaced with Astroturf. The turf field at the University of Wyoming was installed in 2005 and removed in 2012 – a year before the termination of the field warranty. Again, while Mr. Belle has relied on Lisport test data, he has chosen to ignore real life examples.

‐ Desso’s annual market share in North America is approximately 1%. FieldTurf’s, on the other hand, is greater than 45%. In fact, the only architect to routinely recommend Desso in the region is John Belle.

‐ The Desso product comes with an 8 year warranty. The same as FieldTurf. FieldTurf, on the other hand, has over 250 fields in the US that are at least 10 years old. Desso has zero. Has Desso published an anticipated life service that exceeds this warranty period? Are they willing to extend their warranty?

‐ Mr. Belle claims that the “service life of at least 12 years can reasonably be expected from the least of these” is negligent. I don’t believe that any of the turf proponents would agree with this. If they did, I would challenge them to step forward and provide a 12 year guarantee.

‐ Last, but not least, Desso is a European based company, announced last year that they have retrenched and changed their overall business strategy after a failed attempt to sell their business. Will Desso be around to service this field? Read more here: http://www.dessosports.com/news/new‐strategy‐desso‐sportssystems


Darren Gill

Vice‐President, Global Marketing

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


NJ Flags to Fly at Half-Staff for Jerry Green May 7

April 24, 2018

TRENTON, NJ — Governor Phil Murphy issued an executive order on Monday for New Jersey flags to be flown at half-staff at all state buildings and facilities on the day of the upcoming General Assembly session, scheduled for May 7, in memory of Assemblyman Jerry Green, former chair of the Union County Democratic Committee, who died last week.

On Thursday, Governor Murphy had said, ...

2018 Municipal Budget is on Collision Course with Principles of Financial Soundness & Stability

April 18, 2018

Having chaired the town council’s finance committee in the recent past, I appreciate the hard work that goes into developing a municipal budget for a town as large and dynamic as Westfield. But as I have expressed publicly and also to the mayor and my council colleagues, I do not support the adoption of Westfield’s 2018 municipal budget. Although the budget contains much that I ...

Upcoming Events

Tue, April 24, 4:00 PM

Westfield Memorial Library, Westfield

Westfield Memorial Library Spring Book Sale

Arts & Entertainment


Tue, April 24, 7:00 PM

Westfield Municipal Building, Westfield

Westfield Town Council Meeting


Tue, April 24, 7:30 PM


Westfield Board of Education Meeting


Westfield Police Blotter: Residence Burglarized & More

April 18, 2018

April 11, 2018 10:23 a.m.

Raymond Rodgers, 56, of Westfield, NJ was arrested in the area of E. Broad Street. Rodgers was arrested pursuant to an unrelated traffic investigation. Rogers was transported to Westfield Police HQ without incident. At WPD HQ, Rodgers was processed and released after posting the full bail amount ($250). Rodgers was arrested on the strength of an outstanding Westfield ...

Learning to Fly Drones at Lamberts Mill Academy

April 24, 2018

Thanks to a very generous donation from the Columbia Bank Foundation the students at Lamberts Mill Academy are learning how to build, program and fly drones. This innovative program will ensure that students gain skills needed for 21st Century employment. 


Lamberts Mill Academy, located in Westfield, New Jersey, is part of the Union County Educational Services Commission.

Ways to Increase Your Home's Equity

Sometimes you forget and don’t realize your home provides so much to your life. It brings along with it your dreams of the future, shelter to you and your family, a way to provide a better lifestyle, a better commute, a neighborhood, schools, community involvement and recreational facilities. But it also provides a way to save for the future. It does this by allowing you to build your ...

Westfield Public Schools Welcomes Community to Auditorium Open Houses

Two years ago, voters in Westfield approved a bond referendum to renovate the aging auditoriums in Edison and Roosevelt Intermediate Schools. Major aspects of the renovations include new seating and flooring, electrical and lighting upgrades, state-of-the-art sound systems, acoustical treatments and air conditioning.

On April 11 and 12, students, staff, families and other members of the ...

'The Sting' shimmers and shakes at Paper Mill

‘The Sting ‘slithers and shakes at Paper Mill Playhouse


MILLBURN, NJ – In a premiere production of “The Sting,” Harry Connick Jr. commands the Paper Mill Playhouse stage in Millburn.

Based on the sensational Paul Newman/Robert Redford film in 1973, the 1930s plot centers on a con game and gambling, sometimes on a train between New York and ...

Why We Keep Kosher

Why We Keep Kosher

This week's parshah, Shemini, introduces the Torah's dietary laws. Animals must chew their cud and have split hooves to be kosher, fish need fins and scales, and a list of forbidden fowl is enumerated.

To those of us in Jewish education, it is a continuing source of disappointment that so many Jews still believe the kosher laws to be outdated.

Hellenic Therapy Center

April 13, 2018

Dropping Off Our Kids At College – Learning How To Adjust

Hellenic Therapy Center


Whether your kid is a freshman entering college for the first time or returning back to college, there are so many emotions we experience as parents.  There are differences in a parent’s reaction to the departure of a first child, an only child or even the last child.  Feelings ...


Oct 21, 1944 - Apr 14, 2018
Kathleen A. Hertell passed away peacefully with family at her bedside on April 14, 2018. Loving ...
Read more

‘A Sad Day for Paterson’ as Police Officer Loses Life in Car Crash

April 23, 2018

PATERSON, NJ — On what Paterson Superior Officers Association President Mason Maher called “a sad day for Paterson,” a city police officer lost his life on Sunday after he was involved in a motor vehicle collision while on duty.

Several sources familiar with Sunday’s tragic accident have identified the fallen officer as Tamby Yagan, a 13-year veteran of the ...