Union County News

Hikers, Mountain Bikers, Neighbors of Watchung Reservation Continue Debate On Adding Bike Trails

5065b3531ad2a40a401f_IMG_1773.JPG
Hikers and Bikers continue to debate Watchung Reservation Trail Master Plan to include 13 miles of new bike trails. Credits: Bobbie Peer
34bc9067757e2954baf1_IMG_1769__1_.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
bc6b4c3d54dc32d13392_IMG_1768.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
bd30fa2bfe9454ddc955_IMG_1771.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
6db93a3b2192754dd909_IMG_1793.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
1bb9448f48c3fbcc996b_IMG_1790.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
7852a7ce94efe659f6e0_IMG_1782.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
a0ac46f251a07762f725_IMG_1778.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
1aa3ddb0f8f7082a2b2d_IMG_1774.JPG
Credits: Bobbie Peer
244ee926a844998fc713_watchungflag.jpg
Credits: Bobbie Peer
5065b3531ad2a40a401f_IMG_1773.JPG

ELIZABETH, NJ - Conflict between supporters and opponents of mountain bike trails at the Watchung Reservation continued Thursday, at the regular meeting of the Union County Freeholders.

More than a dozen people spoke about the Watchung Reservation Trails Master Plan during the Public Comment portion of the meeting, which came just two days after about 300 people packed a room at a public meeting on the proposal to add 13.5 miles of new trails to the plan. 

The comments from opponents of adding bike trails were similar to those made at Tuesday night's meeting: lack of communication by the County of Union; impact on homeowners who live near the park, including concerns of property values and bikers traveling close to their property lines; erosion of trails and effects on wildlife and trees.    

Sign Up for E-News

Supporters presented themselves as a Union County user group that deserves access to the park and disputed the claims against mountain bikers made by opponents of the plan.

Chairman Bruce Bergen kicked off the discussion emphasizing that adding bike trails at Watchung Reservation "is just a proposal."

Contrary to the criticism regarding public notice to the process, Bergen said that the County has made proper efforts to get the word out. "We certainly want to hear public comments from both sides of the issue," said Bergen. "Tonight is not a question and answer session. We are taking comments from the public but will not have a back and forth."   

Mary Housel from New Providence, an "ultra runner" who knows the trails inside and out, is disturbed at the current state of the trails. "Park staff has not done a good job maintaining the parks," she said. She also said she believes there has been a lack of involvement of the walkers, runners other users of the park, including the employees of the reservations. "There’s a lack of respect for nature and the environment," said Housel, adding that with no environmental study and without contacting the EPA, implementation of the bike trail could be detrimental.  "It is a reservation not a park," she said.  

Charles Weltner of Plainfield came to the microphone and provided his summary of "how this has gone down," stating the Watchung Reservation Master Plan was approved February 2016, a special public meeting was held in October 2016 with the biking community which resulted in changes to the proposed trail paths in December 2016. He had previously said that when the Master Plan was first conceived by Consulting & Municipal Engineers (CME), mountain biking trails were only to be at one end of reservation, with the eastern end left untouched. In December, the plan was amended. The new trails are bike-only trails that will extend over 13 miles, including new trails in an unused portion along the perimeter of the 2,000-acre park. 

He provided the clerk with copies of a map he prepared from the Master Plan with a list of endangered habitats with an overlay to show how the trails will disturb the endangered habitats. 

"I am asking for you to go back to the beginning and start over," said Weltner. "Reach out to the community. It is your obligation as the stewards and [as] representatives of the people of Union County is to find out from the people what we want." 

Bill Toth said he had heard that trail construction has already begun, so he went over to the area that was referenced and saw it to be true. "Trails are being cleared and marked," said Toth. "There is a visible trail that has been started. I’m disturbed to hear that this is said to be a proposal and here it is being cut." He added, "As stewards we need to take this seriously to preserve for generations."

Bergen responded to Toft's comment  and said, "that is not the case. I have seen the pictures, and yes, there have been flags placed. There has been no clearing of the trails. --- Any clearing that was done had nothing to do with clearing trails." 

A man sitting in the back yelled "that is a lie." Bergen asked an officer to escort the man out for not following the meeting rules and lack of decorum.

More people spoke out against the plan, expressing their concern about bikers not observing the rules, signage and an influx of traffic, and impact to local authorities. 

Ann DeCamp of Mountainside would like to know "what recourse will we have as hikers?"  

Karen, an architect from Summit, wants to know when the public, besides the biking community, will have the opportunity for a back and forth collaborative session. 

Matt, a resident from Summit, said it is not just a hiker vs biker issue. "It is a county resident vs non-resident issue, an enforcement issue. Is there going to be a handful of gates?" He said, "[There has been] no plausible study that shows a realistic estimate of the surrounding region usage. It’s a reservation not a park. I find it to be a safety issue. 

"[The] misinformation going around -- it's very apparent that you all are finding it hard to manage your own process. There should not be any flags marking the prospective trails ... [The] most interesting important misinformation is about the setbacks ... Now what are the intentions," Matt asked.

A Mountainside resident asked the freeholders to take into consideration the homeowners that live directly adjacent to the Watchung Reservation. "We need to have an understanding of where the trails will be placed in conjunction to where the back of our homes are," said the resident. "There is not a lot of accurate information as to where the trails are going to be placed."

Andrew Stevenson of Summit commented on the proposed new trails north of 78. "This is very steep and densely wooded. It will be dangerous and will be close to the homeowners. This trail and the bikers will be right in our backyards and increase the traffic on our streets. To my knowledge there is not a single parking lot for the section north of 78." He urged the Freeholders not to allow the trails on this sliver of property. 

Marybeth Garry of Springfield displayed a photo board showing flags marking "two big last-standing trees," various areas that are not being maintained, infrastructure falling apart, and graffiti. She said she represents the animals and feels the reservation is under attack. Her concern is that "whoever marked this out doesn’t know anything about the laws of this state, wildlife, nature and where you put a trail." She strongly urged the Freeholders to "put the trails next to the other trails. Do not take virgin land." 

Bergen confirmed, "There is a process whereby once it [engineering report] is a finalized public document, it will be available to the public and I will presume that we will post on our website at that time."  

Thomas Dunn of Cranford and a supporter to the addition of bike trails said in a recent Letter to the Editor, "We are all stakeholders who care for and enjoy access to the outdoors. We value the environment and want our children and grandchildren to enjoy outdoor play. Through working together over the past year, listening to the input of opponents and proponents, the plan has moved from shared trail access to a separate trail system for children and families to ride their bicycles off-road. This plan is a fair plan."  

Jamie Meiselman, co-leader of the Union County Chapter of the Jersey Off Road Bicycle Association (JORBA.org) read a Letter to the Editor that he recently submitted to many TAPinto.net sites, "Bridging the Knowledge Gap on the Watchung Reservation Mountain Bike Plan."

Meiselman passed the microphone to fellow JORBA member Joe Weiss, of Westfield, who rebutted the claims made against mountain bikers. "None of the horrible things that you are hearing about ever happens. There were no injuries, no families getting run over, no parking issues.-- Everyone got to share the reservation. Please consider real facts when you make the plans for the reservation in the future."  

Andrew Stillufsen of Westfield, who has been in front of the freeholders in the past, commended the freeholders for their transparency and reminded people that the master trail plan had put forth a shared trail option but, in response to feedback from stakeholders about safety and usage concerns of misconceptions 20 years ago "the county revised the plan to put mountain bikers on their own trails," he said. It's about "Access. Now the opponents of mountain bikers are saying 'no mountain bikers in the reservation,'" because "mountain biking trails would ruin the reservation. This can’t be further from the truth. Mountain bikers are responsible trail users. This has been proven all over the state, and in fact all over the country. Shared trails with hikers and equestrians are successful. There is little to no user conflict. I understand the concerns -- you don’t want to get run over – To my knowledge, conflict is minimal if never happens."

Stillufsen called the reservation a "great resource for Union County. – The notion that myself or any other mountain bikers would want to go there to do something to harm the reservation or adversely affect it is untrue." He asked for equal access as a Union County user-group. "I want to continue to encourage the County and urge the Freeholders to approve the Master Trail Plan at Watchung to include mountain biking access."

Glen Johnson concluded, "Democracy is not a spectator sport – folks that are here tonight feel blindsided – frankly they haven’t been paying attention."

After listening to everyone speak, Freeholder Bette Jane Kowalski told the public that "we are going to think very carefully before proceeding any further on this and please stay in touch and don't be discouraged."

Freeholder Angel Estrada explained, "The process will take time. I can assure you that this decision is not made – we will study, we will look into it and service our residents’ needs. I appreciate you coming out. -- That is part of the exchange that needs to take place."

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Westfield

Another Car Smashes into CVS on Morris Avenue in Union

April 21, 2018

UNION, NJ – For the third time in the past year, a car hit the CVS building at 2287 Morris Avenue at the corner of Commerce Avenue.

Union firefighters responded to a call at the CVS at about 12:50 p.m. Thursday.  According to Fire Chief Mike Scanio, a car had struck the building. The Union Fire Department Special Operations Team along with a township construction official ...

2018 Municipal Budget is on Collision Course with Principles of Financial Soundness & Stability

April 18, 2018

Having chaired the town council’s finance committee in the recent past, I appreciate the hard work that goes into developing a municipal budget for a town as large and dynamic as Westfield. But as I have expressed publicly and also to the mayor and my council colleagues, I do not support the adoption of Westfield’s 2018 municipal budget. Although the budget contains much that I ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_891e5cb2bf40dbaff85b_untitled_design

Sun, April 22, 11:00 AM

Roosevelt Intermediate School , Westfield

Greta's Run

Giving Back Sports

Carousel_image_651ca21754f0dc5bb945_sandwich

Sun, April 22, 12:00 PM

James Ward Mansion, Westfield

Westfield Sandwich Fest

Food & Drink

Carousel_image_92bd37d6a82288e9e7a3_mini_magick20180417-8964-lws1d9

Sun, April 22, 12:00 PM

Westfield

Westfield 2018 Earth Day Celebration

Green

Westfield Police Blotter: Residence Burglarized & More

April 18, 2018

April 11, 2018 10:23 a.m.

Raymond Rodgers, 56, of Westfield, NJ was arrested in the area of E. Broad Street. Rodgers was arrested pursuant to an unrelated traffic investigation. Rogers was transported to Westfield Police HQ without incident. At WPD HQ, Rodgers was processed and released after posting the full bail amount ($250). Rodgers was arrested on the strength of an outstanding Westfield ...

The Secret to Managing Insulin for Weight Loss

April 21, 2018

Not too long ago I was sitting with my good friend, Charlie, and I asked him, "Hey Charlie, what's the easiest way to get rid of belly fat?"

"C'mon, Tony, you know the answer to that question." I was pretty sure I did, but I wanted to see if he knew something I didn't. Charlie continued, "The secret to losing belly fat and keeping it off is simply a matter ...

'The Sting' shimmers and shakes at Paper Mill

‘The Sting ‘slithers and shakes at Paper Mill Playhouse

By LIZ KEILL

MILLBURN, NJ – In a premiere production of “The Sting,” Harry Connick Jr. commands the Paper Mill Playhouse stage in Millburn.

Based on the sensational Paul Newman/Robert Redford film in 1973, the 1930s plot centers on a con game and gambling, sometimes on a train between New York and ...

Edison Students Participate in Beta Test of Google Augmented Reality App

Students and teachers at Edison Intermediate School participated in a recent beta test of a Google application that uses augmented reality technology to explore the inner workings of plant cells, the functions and framework of the human skeletal system, and other educational subjects.

Edison Media Specialist Andrew Cusumano arranged for a Google representative to visit the school on April 9 to ...

Get Your Home Ready for Summer Before its TOO HOT

Finally, the weather is getting warmer and you are shedding those down coats. Now is a great time to start thinking about summer and getting your home prepared. Paying attention to a few maintenance items can alleviate painful repairs later on if you wait too long. The line ahead of you will build as the summer rush starts. So, let’s not wait.

Check your roof   (hire the expert ...

Why We Keep Kosher

Why We Keep Kosher

This week's parshah, Shemini, introduces the Torah's dietary laws. Animals must chew their cud and have split hooves to be kosher, fish need fins and scales, and a list of forbidden fowl is enumerated.

To those of us in Jewish education, it is a continuing source of disappointment that so many Jews still believe the kosher laws to be outdated.

Hellenic Therapy Center

April 13, 2018

Dropping Off Our Kids At College – Learning How To Adjust

Hellenic Therapy Center

 

Whether your kid is a freshman entering college for the first time or returning back to college, there are so many emotions we experience as parents.  There are differences in a parent’s reaction to the departure of a first child, an only child or even the last child.  Feelings ...

Obituaries

Oct 21, 1944 - Apr 14, 2018
Kathleen A. Hertell passed away peacefully with family at her bedside on April 14, 2018. Loving ...
Read more

Mets Sign Patriots Pitcher Before He Can Unpack His Gear

April 20, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — The Somerset Patriots have announced that right-hand pitcher Scott Copeland’s contract has been purchased by the New York Mets.

So, instead of stretching out and getting in shape at TD Bank Ballpark, he's been sent to extended spring training at the Mets' complex in Port St. Lucie, Fla.

The 6’3” righty broke into the big leagues in ...