Union County News

Hikers, Mountain Bikers, Neighbors of Watchung Reservation Continue Debate On Adding Bike Trails

Hikers and Bikers continue to debate Watchung Reservation Trail Master Plan to include 13 miles of new bike trails. Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer
Credits: Bobbie Peer

ELIZABETH, NJ - Conflict between supporters and opponents of mountain bike trails at the Watchung Reservation continued Thursday, at the regular meeting of the Union County Freeholders.

More than a dozen people spoke about the Watchung Reservation Trails Master Plan during the Public Comment portion of the meeting, which came just two days after about 300 people packed a room at a public meeting on the proposal to add 13.5 miles of new trails to the plan. 

The comments from opponents of adding bike trails were similar to those made at Tuesday night's meeting: lack of communication by the County of Union; impact on homeowners who live near the park, including concerns of property values and bikers traveling close to their property lines; erosion of trails and effects on wildlife and trees.    

Sign Up for E-News

Supporters presented themselves as a Union County user group that deserves access to the park and disputed the claims against mountain bikers made by opponents of the plan.

Chairman Bruce Bergen kicked off the discussion emphasizing that adding bike trails at Watchung Reservation "is just a proposal."

Contrary to the criticism regarding public notice to the process, Bergen said that the County has made proper efforts to get the word out. "We certainly want to hear public comments from both sides of the issue," said Bergen. "Tonight is not a question and answer session. We are taking comments from the public but will not have a back and forth."   

Mary Housel from New Providence, an "ultra runner" who knows the trails inside and out, is disturbed at the current state of the trails. "Park staff has not done a good job maintaining the parks," she said. She also said she believes there has been a lack of involvement of the walkers, runners other users of the park, including the employees of the reservations. "There’s a lack of respect for nature and the environment," said Housel, adding that with no environmental study and without contacting the EPA, implementation of the bike trail could be detrimental.  "It is a reservation not a park," she said.  

Charles Weltner of Plainfield came to the microphone and provided his summary of "how this has gone down," stating the Watchung Reservation Master Plan was approved February 2016, a special public meeting was held in October 2016 with the biking community which resulted in changes to the proposed trail paths in December 2016. He had previously said that when the Master Plan was first conceived by Consulting & Municipal Engineers (CME), mountain biking trails were only to be at one end of reservation, with the eastern end left untouched. In December, the plan was amended. The new trails are bike-only trails that will extend over 13 miles, including new trails in an unused portion along the perimeter of the 2,000-acre park. 

He provided the clerk with copies of a map he prepared from the Master Plan with a list of endangered habitats with an overlay to show how the trails will disturb the endangered habitats. 

"I am asking for you to go back to the beginning and start over," said Weltner. "Reach out to the community. It is your obligation as the stewards and [as] representatives of the people of Union County is to find out from the people what we want." 

Bill Toth said he had heard that trail construction has already begun, so he went over to the area that was referenced and saw it to be true. "Trails are being cleared and marked," said Toth. "There is a visible trail that has been started. I’m disturbed to hear that this is said to be a proposal and here it is being cut." He added, "As stewards we need to take this seriously to preserve for generations."

Bergen responded to Toft's comment  and said, "that is not the case. I have seen the pictures, and yes, there have been flags placed. There has been no clearing of the trails. --- Any clearing that was done had nothing to do with clearing trails." 

A man sitting in the back yelled "that is a lie." Bergen asked an officer to escort the man out for not following the meeting rules and lack of decorum.

More people spoke out against the plan, expressing their concern about bikers not observing the rules, signage and an influx of traffic, and impact to local authorities. 

Ann DeCamp of Mountainside would like to know "what recourse will we have as hikers?"  

Karen, an architect from Summit, wants to know when the public, besides the biking community, will have the opportunity for a back and forth collaborative session. 

Matt, a resident from Summit, said it is not just a hiker vs biker issue. "It is a county resident vs non-resident issue, an enforcement issue. Is there going to be a handful of gates?" He said, "[There has been] no plausible study that shows a realistic estimate of the surrounding region usage. It’s a reservation not a park. I find it to be a safety issue. 

"[The] misinformation going around -- it's very apparent that you all are finding it hard to manage your own process. There should not be any flags marking the prospective trails ... [The] most interesting important misinformation is about the setbacks ... Now what are the intentions," Matt asked.

A Mountainside resident asked the freeholders to take into consideration the homeowners that live directly adjacent to the Watchung Reservation. "We need to have an understanding of where the trails will be placed in conjunction to where the back of our homes are," said the resident. "There is not a lot of accurate information as to where the trails are going to be placed."

Andrew Stevenson of Summit commented on the proposed new trails north of 78. "This is very steep and densely wooded. It will be dangerous and will be close to the homeowners. This trail and the bikers will be right in our backyards and increase the traffic on our streets. To my knowledge there is not a single parking lot for the section north of 78." He urged the Freeholders not to allow the trails on this sliver of property. 

Marybeth Garry of Springfield displayed a photo board showing flags marking "two big last-standing trees," various areas that are not being maintained, infrastructure falling apart, and graffiti. She said she represents the animals and feels the reservation is under attack. Her concern is that "whoever marked this out doesn’t know anything about the laws of this state, wildlife, nature and where you put a trail." She strongly urged the Freeholders to "put the trails next to the other trails. Do not take virgin land." 

Bergen confirmed, "There is a process whereby once it [engineering report] is a finalized public document, it will be available to the public and I will presume that we will post on our website at that time."  

Thomas Dunn of Cranford and a supporter to the addition of bike trails said in a recent Letter to the Editor, "We are all stakeholders who care for and enjoy access to the outdoors. We value the environment and want our children and grandchildren to enjoy outdoor play. Through working together over the past year, listening to the input of opponents and proponents, the plan has moved from shared trail access to a separate trail system for children and families to ride their bicycles off-road. This plan is a fair plan."  

Jamie Meiselman, co-leader of the Union County Chapter of the Jersey Off Road Bicycle Association (JORBA.org) read a Letter to the Editor that he recently submitted to many TAPinto.net sites, "Bridging the Knowledge Gap on the Watchung Reservation Mountain Bike Plan."

Meiselman passed the microphone to fellow JORBA member Joe Weiss, of Westfield, who rebutted the claims made against mountain bikers. "None of the horrible things that you are hearing about ever happens. There were no injuries, no families getting run over, no parking issues.-- Everyone got to share the reservation. Please consider real facts when you make the plans for the reservation in the future."  

Andrew Stillufsen of Westfield, who has been in front of the freeholders in the past, commended the freeholders for their transparency and reminded people that the master trail plan had put forth a shared trail option but, in response to feedback from stakeholders about safety and usage concerns of misconceptions 20 years ago "the county revised the plan to put mountain bikers on their own trails," he said. It's about "Access. Now the opponents of mountain bikers are saying 'no mountain bikers in the reservation,'" because "mountain biking trails would ruin the reservation. This can’t be further from the truth. Mountain bikers are responsible trail users. This has been proven all over the state, and in fact all over the country. Shared trails with hikers and equestrians are successful. There is little to no user conflict. I understand the concerns -- you don’t want to get run over – To my knowledge, conflict is minimal if never happens."

Stillufsen called the reservation a "great resource for Union County. – The notion that myself or any other mountain bikers would want to go there to do something to harm the reservation or adversely affect it is untrue." He asked for equal access as a Union County user-group. "I want to continue to encourage the County and urge the Freeholders to approve the Master Trail Plan at Watchung to include mountain biking access."

Glen Johnson concluded, "Democracy is not a spectator sport – folks that are here tonight feel blindsided – frankly they haven’t been paying attention."

After listening to everyone speak, Freeholder Bette Jane Kowalski told the public that "we are going to think very carefully before proceeding any further on this and please stay in touch and don't be discouraged."

Freeholder Angel Estrada explained, "The process will take time. I can assure you that this decision is not made – we will study, we will look into it and service our residents’ needs. I appreciate you coming out. -- That is part of the exchange that needs to take place."

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Westfield

Union County Daughters of Ireland Raise More Than $3,500 with Cranford Bar Crawl

September 19, 2017

CRANFORD, NJ – Union County’s women of Irish descent are coming together to build relationships, network and raise money for young women of Irish heritage.

Two Clark women, Kate Mooney and Lori Connolly, teamed up last April to start the Union County Daughters of Ireland. They were inspired by the Friendly Sons of St. Patrick, a group of which Mooney’s father is a proud ...

It is Time for the Incumbent Mayor to Pass the Torch

September 19, 2017

Dear Editor:

There is a reason why the Westfield primary turn-out was historically high this year. Westfield residents are hungry for change. I, for one, give credit to the incumbent mayor for his accomplishments. After 12 years in office, some are to be expected. Length of service in politics is a double-edged sword; it can lead to complacency. The best thing about this ...

Brindle Asks: ‘Who’s Representing You in our Local Government?’

September 21, 2017

You have a right to know who is representing you in your town government. This information should be easy to find on the Town website; it’s not. If it was, you might be surprised by what you discover.

Our mayor’s nearly 100 political appointees to key positions in our local government are not representative of our community across Ward, political party, skill sets and experience.

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_e7794c05218c83df7623_oktflyer-nv

Fri, September 22, 5:00 PM

NosVino, Westfield

Free Oktoberfest Beer Tasting!

Food & Drink

Carousel_image_fc5b5626003c59ab0830_8e5f9e67f8bdfb8a9e43_img_9192

Fri, September 22, 6:30 PM

The James Ward Mansion , Westfield

5th Annual Rahway Film Festival the The James ...

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_09b8037a9192fd208201_car_wash

Sat, September 23, 10:00 AM

Allstate - Ron Bansky & Associates , Westfield

Free Car Wash Day at Allstate

Business & Finance

Video: Point View's Petrides Feels Market Has Room to Run as Fed Decision Looms

September 20, 2017

Point View Wealth Management's Managing Director and Portfolio Manager, John Petrides, appeared live on CNBC discussing the upcoming Fed meeting and its rate hike decision:

cnbc.com/video

For nearly 25 years, Point View Wealth Management, Inc. has been working with families in Summit and beyond, providing customized portfolio management services and ...

Westfield Police Blotter: Home Burglary Reported & More

September 20, 2017

September 14, 2017 8:50 a.m.

A resident of the 1000 block of Harding Street reports a theft to their motor vehicles while parked in the driveway of their residence. The vehicles were left unsecured during these incidents. Unknown actor(s) entered the one vehicle, a silver-colored Nissan Pathfinder, and removed approximately $5 in US coin currency. Actor(s) also entered a Nissan Maxima and ...

Dog Lost in Westfield

Juliet, a boxer, was last spotted at 10:30 a.m. Wednesday by the south side firehouse in Westfield on Central Avenue. 

If you see her, please call 908-380-3319.

Free Pass to School Events for Westfield Senior Citizens

The Westfield Public School District is once again providing a senior citizens’ “Golden Pass” to Westfield residents 65 years and older to attend many school-sponsored events for free.  The pass will provide free admission to events that normally collect entrance fees such as Westfield High School musicals, matinee performances of plays and certain concerts.  The pass ...

Westfield Area YMCA Celebrates International Dot Day in Early Learning Programs

The Westfield Area YMCA Early Learning programs recently celebrated International Dot Day.  During this day of creativity, courage and collaboration, all classes began by reading and discussing the book “The Dot.” The classes then participated in a variety of age-appropriate activities including creating art projects with dot paints, paper circles, and other round items.  ...

Op Ed: High Schools Should Teach Students CPR

September 18, 2017

You walked through the halls together. You sat together at lunch. You couldn’t wait to go to college together. But all of it was destroyed by one minute of that day. One minute she was smiling. The next she was on the floor, pale, and lifeless. I couldn’t save her. Everyone gathered around her as she choked, no one knew what to do. I lost my best friend that day because my education ...

Whether You’re Selling Your Home or Want More Peace

Realtors always advise home sellers to eliminate clutter when selling their homes because it makes a remarkable difference. A clutter-free home can look like a new one altogether, and you shouldn’t wait until you sell your home to make it look better. Furthermore, clutter can have adverse effects and cause mental and physical stress. You can take steps to conquer your clutter by breaking ...

Teens Complete Youth Facilitator Training at Imagine

On Saturday, Sept. 9, Imagine held its’ sixth youth facilitator training. Eighteen amazing young people, ages 14 to 18, attended the full day training which sensitizes teen participants to the issue of childhood grief, and prepares the youth to assist with the facilitation of peer-support groups for children who are coping with the death of a parent or a sibling.

Through the ...

Two Scams You Should Know About

Scam Alert 1: Fake Donations

It's a testament to the generosity of the people in our nation to want to pitch in and help those affected by a catastrophe. As we see all the destruction that Harvey and now Irma are imparting, our hearts go out to these folks, and we want to respond by opening our wallets.

Unfortunately, criminals and scam artists are counting on that generous spirit, too, ...

Saving for Higher Education

Saving for Higher Education

Part 1 – Six Options for Savings

 

Introduction

Your children’s education may be the most cost-intensive purchase you ever make. A family of three children that all attend private universities will likely pay close to $1 million for their degrees. No matter your personal financial objectives or your children’s choice of ...

Moving with Your Children Out of State After a Divorce

One of the most contentious issues faced by many divorced parents has always been whether the custodial parent has the right to relocate with the parties’ children out of state. In an increasingly mobile society this has become an issue for many parents. Often custodial parents decide that they cannot continue to reside in New Jersey. They need to explore job opportunities in other states ...

Sam Shepard's 'Simpatico' takes off

Sam Shepard’s “Simpatico” has a forceful workout at McCarter Theatre.

By Liz Keill

PRINCETON, NJ – If you’re at all familiar with the works of Sam Shepard, you know that he writes about gritty, unforgiving characters in what appear to be hopeless situations.

In “Simpatico,” we learn that Vinnie and Carter are former partners in a race horse ...

Obituaries

Oct 24, 1926 - Aug 14, 2017
Elizabeth H. List, 90, of Westfield and Cape May, NJ, died peacefully surrounded by her family ...
Read more

Boy Scouts’ Sabattis Adventure Camp to Remain Open for Now

September 20, 2017

CEDAR KNOLLS, NJ — The Patriots’ Paths Council Executive Board met on Monday, Sept. 18, in a special session to discuss the future operation of Sabattis Adventure Camp, which was threatened with closure. The board voted to continue Sabbatis camping activities through the end of the 2019 summer camping season. 

“Patriots’ Path Council’s ...