Letters to the Editor

Neighbor Objects to Townhouse Project


On Wednesday Jan. 25, 2017, at 7:30 in the Council Chambers of the Municipal building, the Board of Adjustment is hearing a controversial appeal which involves tearing down a two and a half century old single family home at 1481 East Broad Street, and building two town houses with three units each.  Many of my neighbors as well as myself object to the proposed usage, and we are asking you to consider our position, as well as the fact that the precedent this could set, and how that could affect you neighborhood.  We are requesting that you attend the meeting and hear the case for yourself.  We believe most of you will support our position.

This is not a minor matter, one that seemingly fits a board named the Board of “Adjustment.”  It is, essentially, a zoning question. The land, approximately .98 acres, is classified as Zone RS-12, which is a single family home zone allowing no more than 3.07 building units per acre.  The land is perfectly suited for this purpose, and it is relatively easy to envision three single family homes being built on the land.  The builder is proposing to construct 6.09 units per acre.  This is contra to the Master Plan of Westfield, which was last redone in 2009 and amended in 2013.

If you are not familiar with the concept of the Master Plan, it is a legally mandated process for the Town Government to undertake.  It involves many expensive hours of professional work, the input from town officials, Public Hearings and Council votes.  It is an imperfect process, but it reflects the best attempt of the town to control its destiny.  You can learn more about the Master Plan process at: http://www.trenton250.org/learn/planning-101/what-is-a-master-plan/

Sign Up for E-News

The party requesting these variances, “Country Classics at Montgomery” of Hillsborough, NJ, is proposing to build six multifamily homes on a property zoned for single family homes.  With the exception of a church on one side of the property, there is no multifamily housing on that side of East Broad Street until you get to the downtown area.

To build contra to the master plan would now set two markers on that side of East Broad Street, this property and the multifamily apartment’s downtown. It would support future arguments about precedent, and what the town actually allows. All the large properties on East Broad Street would become vulnerable to possible multifamily discussions.  In fact, this could open any large property in town, or the combination of two adjacent properties, to a similar discussion. The risk is a loss of control set by at the Master Plan.

To understand the impact of this, consider the economics of this to the town. A higher population density increases costs to the town, most notably the cost of education. This units are being proposed for 3.5 stories each, these are not “downsizing” homes for empty nesters, who generally don’t want to have to climb stairs. Instead, these are opportunities to buy a new home in the Westfield School district for less than it would normally cost. 

I welcome all who want to buy in Westfield and put their kids in the school system. But increasing density with a lower tax per unit only increases the financial burden on the rest of us.

The “purpose” is not the only variance requested; there are significant size requests that again belittle the phrase Board of “Adjustment.” Again, the builder is proposing to build 3.5 stories, while the current zoning permits 2.5 stories.  Since the property sits at an angle across the street from my home, and is elevated to my property, the height effect will be exaggerated. Further, the current height limit is 32.75 feet, they are requesting 35.75 feet.

It’s not just a height issue. Current zoning permits coverage of 10 percent of the property.  At 19.6 percent, it nearly doubles the norm.

It doesn’t stop there. The effect of building more home and building higher results in more square footage to sell on the property. The Maximum Floor Area Ratio, also called “Total Habitable Floor Space” request is for 36.1 percent of the property size, while the current regulation is 20 percent.  It’s a request of 180 percent of what is allowed. Let’s be clear here; this is a much more profitable way to build.

Again, it doesn’t stop there. Because the number of people living on the property can be twice what would be in three single family homes, the builder needs to build a parking area on the property. If you are familiar with East Broad Street (think three lanes of traffic there, backed up a quarter mile at rush hour) you understand that you can’t park on street.  So this results in a request for a “Maximum All Improvement Coverage Ratio” of 45 percent.1, versus the permitted 20 percent. This is especially important on a property that sits higher than many in the area.  It reduces the amount of water that property can absorb, and increases the amount of water than runs off into the waste water drainage system. 

While the engineering will be presented to show that no adjacent properties are flooded, and no basements are flooded, there are no guarantees that works out that way. Minimizing the Coverage Ratio to what is allowed is an important feature to the neighbors. This can be achieved by developing the property to the RS-12 standards of three single family homes, which would not require additional parking to be built on the property.

In summary, I believe what is being requested so far exceeds what is allowed that I have asked myself if it is really a negotiation tactic, hoping that the Board of Variance will grant the D-1 permitted usage with a smaller building and parking lot profile. I can’t answer that, but let me be clear:  I object to the request for the permitted usage and I object to the oversized building conditions that are being requested.  Since it is my problem today and could be your problem tomorrow, I request that you give serious consideration to attending the meeting and voicing you opinion. Thank you for your time and attention.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Plainfield Convicted Felon, Sister Charged in Indictment Stemming from Violent Encounter with Law Enforcement

March 20, 2018

NEWARK, NJ – A brother and sister from Plainfield were indicted on Monday on drug distribution, felony possession of a firearm, obstruction of justice and other charges resulting from a violent encounter with law enforcement officers in October 2017, U.S. Attorney Craig Carpenito has announced.

Arthur Forman, 35, is charged with possession of cocaine, marijuana, and oxycodone ...

Mayor Brindle’s Update, Feb. 13

March 14, 2018

The following are highlights from the update that Mayor Shelley Brindle gave at Tuesday night’s town council meeting.

Last week’s back to back nor’easters left a wave of destruction that Westfield hasn’t experienced since Hurricane Sandy in 2012. Three thousand homes lost power. Over 40 roads were closed due to downed wires and/or trees. Our police responded to ...

Upcoming Events


Fri, March 23, 12:00 PM

Resolve, Scotch Plains

Free Teen Anxiety Group (Ages 14-17) at Resolve

Sat, March 24, 10:00 AM

Burent Middle School , Union

Union County Wide - March for Our Lives

Government Law & Justice


Sun, March 25, 11:00 AM

Shackamaxon Country Club, Scotch Plains

Hear Our Voices: MemoryCare Plays

Health & Wellness

Westfield Police Blotter: DWI, Reported Fraud & More

March 14, 2018

March 7, 2018 2:06 a.m.

Carlos C. Mendoza, age 33, of Garwood, NJ, was arrested on the strength of three Westfield Municipal Court warrants ($750) pursuant to a traffic stop in the area of South Avenue in Scotch Plains. Subject was transported to Westfield Police HQ where he was processed and refused after posting bail.


March 9, 2018 2:09 p.m.

A resident of Sandra Circle ...

UC Tech Student Volunteers Put Fun and Games to Work for Special Needs Learners

March 20, 2018

Earlier this month, a group of 51 students in grades 9 to 11 from the Teacher Education Academy at UC TECH staged an indoor carnival for special needs learners. More than 140 participants from the community attended the event and enjoyed plinko, corn hole, dance revolution, hula hoop activities, a DJ, prizes and more.

UC TECH is part of the Union County Vocational-Technical School District. It ...

'Trying' explores age, youth and points of history in poignant production

‘Trying’ explores youth, age and points of history in poignant production

By Liz Keill

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – The George Street Playhouse presents an engrossing, two-character play based on the real life of Francis Biddle, former Attorney General.

Biddle, a Harvard educated lawyer, served under Franklin Roosevelt and later Harry Truman during the Nuremberg Tribunal. His ...

Gratitude Goes to the Girls! Mindful Monday Series - # 1

March 19, 2018

I am thrilled to launch our first edition of "Mindful Mondays" today!  Why Mindful Mondays? After several years of working with individuals in a variety of settings, many have asked me: "What's all this mindfulness about anyway?"  I often respond with, "It's different for everyone," but in general I begin with this definition ...

16 Homes Sold Last Week in Westfield, Scotch Plains, Fanwood, Mountainside & Cranford

Sixteen homes sold last week, March 11 to March 18, 2018, in Westfield, Scotch Plains, Fanwood, Mountainside and Cranford:*


TOWN        ADDRESS                  STYLE           RMS    ...

Charitable Spirit Alive and Well in Westfield Public Schools

Students, staff and parents in Westfield Public Schools continue the district’s long tradition of helping others both in and outside of the community, with a number of students recently recognized for their efforts.

Fifteen Westfield High School juniors and sophomores were honored by the Community Food Bank of New Jersey for collecting more than 5,000 pounds of food items for families in ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 13

On this episode of AtlantiCast, new clinical studies in the fields of cardiology and immunotherapy, national and statewide recognitions for Atlantic Health System medical centers and the inaugural AtlantiCast Collab Challenge!


The Day After

Some years ago, the United Nations held the International Summit on Sustainable Development, here in Johannesburg. The Summit was a great success. One wonders, though, whether all the wonderful decisions and resolutions that were adopted were ever implemented. In other words, were they themselves sustainable?

Good ideas and worthwhile projects are suggested regularly. The question is, do they ...


Kathleen Marie Christian (nee Helmstetter), age 73 of Surf City, NJ, passed away peacefully at home ...
Read more

Suspended Hillsborough HS Athletic Director Charged with Theft

March 19, 2018

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ — Suspended Hillsborough High School Athletic Director Michael Fanizzi has been arrested and charged with the theft of $10,704 in athletic event receipts over a four-year period from 2013-2017, according to Somerset County Prosecutor Michael H. Robertson.

Fanizzi, 53, a resident of Conover Way in Hillsborough who had been athletics director for 14 years, had been ...