Real Estate

Westfield Historic Preservation Commission Votes to Deny Subdivision of 667 4th Ave.

361010f5699c1af7ddab_ef84fce4538145d32bde_IMG_0153.jpg
Members of the Westfield Historic Preservation Commission discuss an application to subdivide the historically designated property at 667 4th Ave. Credits: Kate Brochu
9723147a006402900a23_2d34496fabc37cb8e27d_IMG_0152.jpg
Home owners Heather and Andrew Stillufsen listen to the Westfield Historic Preservation Commission as they discuss the application for subdivision at their historically designated property. Credits: Kate Brochu
cecf7aa038f10bf4ef3a_89c64278cee584606f74_ff4e3c3d5808e2021e20_IMG_0162.jpg
667 4th Ave Credits: Kate Brochu
6c7ded2f311580efc777_IMG_0164.jpg
Brief history of 667 4th Ave provided by Neal Acito and Robert Wendel of the Westfield Historic Preservation Commission. Credits: Neal Acito
91953302785631b20180_9be41034e729273a7f2b_IMG_0156.jpg
Home owner Andrew Stillufsen says that he is passionate about his house as he addresses the commission at Monday's meeting. Credits: Kate Brochu
60f6664696596b71aa32_Screen_Shot_2018-01-30_at_5.11.26_PM.jpg
Artist rendering of what the property at 667 4th Ave may have looked like in the 1760s when it served as a farmhouse on 55 acres. Credits: Neal Acito
361010f5699c1af7ddab_ef84fce4538145d32bde_IMG_0153.jpg

WESTFIELD, NJ — The Historic Preservation Commission voted to recommend that the Planning Board deny the application for a subdivision of the historically designated property at 667 4th Ave at Monday night’s HPC meeting.

After nearly three hours of discussion, public contributions and comments from the property owners, Andrew and Heather Stillufsen, and their attorney, Steve Hehl, the commission reached a majority agreement on the following motion:

At this time, the Westfield Historic Preservation Commission recommends that the application for subdivision of the historic site at 667 Fourth Ave, Block 3303, Lot 6, as presented, be denied for the reasons set forth through the discussions of the HPC and the testimony of the applicant and the public and further in accordance with Historic Preservation Ordinance Subsection 6A (Actions requiring a certificate of appropriateness) and Subsection 8D (Subdivisions, Site Plans, Variances).

Sign Up for E-News

Commission members James Corcoran and Michael Fisher (who voted as an alternate in the absence of two commission members) voted against the motion, preferring further clarification as to their reasons for denying the existing application.

After a lengthy discussion and extensive rewording the commission agreed to vote on two motions, with the first motion (shared above) gaining the majority vote and therefore eliminating the need to vote on a second motion with additional details on the recommendation.

“The planning board referred this to us for our recommendation and they want our recommendation of how it will affect a historic site,” said HPC chair Kelly Kessler, who acknowledged that some of the discussed conditions were not items that could be considered at the time of the meeting. “I’m not sure that they want us to start talking about the economic implications or alternative ways of subdividing the property.”

Commission member Joe Biren attempted to streamline consideration of the application.

“From what I’ve heard from most of the members is that, yes, this site will be affected by this subdivision. Secondly, with consideration that was offered as to why this should be permitted is outside our mandate, ie whether or not there is sufficient funds to maintain the existing property,” he said. “The way I understand it, this matter of cost and financial involvement is going to be left to the planning board for their decision, it’s not our decision.”

Homeowner Andrew Stillufsen spoke during the public comment part of the meeting.

“I am passionate about this house. I’m passionate about history,” said Sillufsen. He went on to explain that the house was in need of repair work that he hopes to complete with the funds made available after selling the subdivision to a developer. 

Commission member Neal Acito questioned Stillufsen’s plans for the funds, suggesting that they may be used to pay off a mortgage before paying for repairs needed for the home.

“Sorry, I’m not going to talk about my mortgage,” Stillufsen said.

While many members of the commission expressed a level of discomfort at prying into the property owner’s mortgage, Town Attorney Tom Jardim said that it could be relevant to the commission’s decision.

“Let me just stress this again. The applicant has come forward and is attempting to make a case of economic hardship. So to be perfectly candid, it is a relevant question,” Jardim said. “If the applicant has an undo economic hardship, the applicant has to make that case. Period.”

The final recommendation will be presented to the Planning Board on Feb. 5.

When asked about her reaction to the outcome of the meeting, Heather Stillufsen said they were disappointed.

“We believe in our house,” added Andrew Stillufsen.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Westfield

Scotch Plains Man Arrested for Exposing Himself to Girl at Farley Park

April 19, 2018

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ — A 26-year-old Scotch Plains man was arrested and charged with lewdness after he allegedly exposed himself in front of a girl at Farley Park, police said.

The girl's family members contacted the Scotch Plains police, who arrested Melvin A. Hanciles, who lives near the park on Farley Avenue.

Sergeant David Lavery and Patrolman Chris ...

2018 Municipal Budget is on Collision Course with Principles of Financial Soundness & Stability

April 18, 2018

Having chaired the town council’s finance committee in the recent past, I appreciate the hard work that goes into developing a municipal budget for a town as large and dynamic as Westfield. But as I have expressed publicly and also to the mayor and my council colleagues, I do not support the adoption of Westfield’s 2018 municipal budget. Although the budget contains much that I ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_847ee9151bdce789833a_y

Sat, April 21, 9:30 AM

Westfield Area YMCA, Westfield

Westfield Area YMCA Camp Open House

Sat, April 21, 10:00 AM

Tamaques Park, Brightwood Park & Mindowaskin Park, Westfield

Westfield 2018 Spring Clean-Up

Giving Back Government Green

Carousel_image_28ada9d80beb9d6466b0_picture2_simpler

Sat, April 21, 1:30 PM

Westfield Area YMCA, Westfield

Free Aquatics Healthy Kids Day

Health & Wellness Sports

Westfield Police Blotter: Residence Burglarized & More

April 18, 2018

April 11, 2018 10:23 a.m.

Raymond Rodgers, 56, of Westfield, NJ was arrested in the area of E. Broad Street. Rodgers was arrested pursuant to an unrelated traffic investigation. Rogers was transported to Westfield Police HQ without incident. At WPD HQ, Rodgers was processed and released after posting the full bail amount ($250). Rodgers was arrested on the strength of an outstanding Westfield ...

Craft Brew Fest Pours Into Westfield April 28; TAPinto Readers Get $20 Off

April 19, 2018

Westfield Hops – A Craft Beer Experience will be taking place on at the Westfield Armory April 28 with one session from 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. Enter code TAPINTO when you order your tickets and get $20 off! Tickets are available online at  http://www.westfieldhops.com. All tickets include unlimited tastings and a souvenir tasting glass. 

Westfield Hops – A Craft Beer ...

McKinley School Kicks Off its Annual Fundraising Effort for Pediatric Cancer Research

It was an enthusiastic start as students and staff kicked off the 7th Annual McKinley School Mini-THON, a schoolwide, energetic effort to raise money for leukemia and pediatric cancer research.

“As you know, McKinley School does a lot to give back [to the community],” said McKinley principal Marc Biunno as he addressed students and staff gathered in the gymnasium on April 11.

Get Your Home Ready for Summer Before its TOO HOT

Finally, the weather is getting warmer and you are shedding those down coats. Now is a great time to start thinking about summer and getting your home prepared. Paying attention to a few maintenance items can alleviate painful repairs later on if you wait too long. The line ahead of you will build as the summer rush starts. So, let’s not wait.

Check your roof   (hire the expert ...

Why We Keep Kosher

Why We Keep Kosher

This week's parshah, Shemini, introduces the Torah's dietary laws. Animals must chew their cud and have split hooves to be kosher, fish need fins and scales, and a list of forbidden fowl is enumerated.

To those of us in Jewish education, it is a continuing source of disappointment that so many Jews still believe the kosher laws to be outdated.

Fear of Rising Rates? Remember The Reason You Own Bonds

If the current interest environment has you concerned about your bond portfolio, remember why you are investing in bonds.  The role bonds, or fixed income, play in a portfolio is not solely based on performance.  Bonds are used to offer stability, particularly when stock market volatility is rising. Rate hikes can dampen bond performance, but keep perspective on how rising rates impact ...

Hellenic Therapy Center

April 13, 2018

Dropping Off Our Kids At College – Learning How To Adjust

Hellenic Therapy Center

 

Whether your kid is a freshman entering college for the first time or returning back to college, there are so many emotions we experience as parents.  There are differences in a parent’s reaction to the departure of a first child, an only child or even the last child.  Feelings ...

AtlantiCast

AtlantiCast: Episode 14

On this week’s AtlantiCast, an internationally recognized orthopedic oncologist takes a leadership role at Atlantic Health System, see the newest weapon in the fight against HPV-related cancers, Atlantic Health System leads the Castle Connolly / Inside Jersey Rankings, and much more!

 

Obituaries

Oct 21, 1944 - Apr 14, 2018
Kathleen A. Hertell passed away peacefully with family at her bedside on April 14, 2018. Loving ...
Read more

Edison Cop Arrested, Charged With Computer Theft and Stalking

April 18, 2018

EDISON, NJ - An Edison police officer has been arrested and charged with computer theft and stalking.

Middlesex County Prosecutor Andrew C. Carey and Chief Thomas Bryan of the Edison Police Department on Tuesday announced the arrest of Paul Pappas. The 43-year-old officer, an Edison resident, has been charged with computer theft/criminal activity in the second degree and stalking in the fourth ...