Food & Drink

Westfield's Own ‘Cake War?’ Locals Debate After Carlo’s Opens Near a Longtime Staple

Bovella's Pastry Shoppe, located at 101 E. Broad in Westfield, NJ Credits: Erin Scialabba
Carlo's Bakery, located at 21 E. Broad in Westfield, NJ Credits: Erin Scialabba

WESTFIELD, NJ — When Carlo’s Bakery opened in Westfield on Sept. 1, fans of “Cake Boss” Bartolo “Buddy” Valastro Jr. lined up for hours to catch a glimpse of the TLC reality show star and try some of the bakery’s famous treats.

But not everyone was so happy to see Carlo’s open shop down the block from Bovella’s Pastry Shoppe, a town staple since 1949 with a very similar menu, from their Italian pastries to their novelty cakes.

In person and on social media, many locals expressed outrage—even hostility—in response to the television personality claiming his latest location as Westfield’s new “hometown” bakery.

Sign Up for E-News

"Westfield doesn't need another bakery," said one Facebook user in a local group in response to a story posted there from The Alternative Press.

Many said they planned to show their support for Bovella’s by shopping there Sept. 1, instead of heading to Carlo’s. One Bovella’s supporter even told the group that he was “going to egg the opening,” though no such egging was reported.  

Carlo’s Chief Brand Officer Adam Bourcier told The Alternative Press that Carlo’s proximity to Bovella’s was unintentional.

“We looked at a few spaces in town and it just happened that 21 East Broad Street was the best fit for our needs,” Bourcier said. “We're not looking to take over the town. We both have our own specialties to offer the community.”

One difference between the two shops is Carlo’s open kitchen. Six-year Westfield resident Caroline Sutton said that her family enjoys the setup because it allows her daughters to watch the bakers make chocolate-covered strawberries. Sutton, a “Cake Boss” fan, also said that it was Carlo’s that opened her eyes to Italian pastries.

“I never ate cannolis, and I do now,” she said.

Jim Baker, interviewed at Westfield’s Rockn’ Joe Coffeehouse and Bistro nearby, said that he was impressed with Carlo’s assortment of baked goods and their presentation.

“This is economic Darwinism,” Baker said, “If [Bovella’s] can’t cut it, they’ll go under.”

Thirty seven-year Westfield resident Ed Cruikshank agreed with Baker, after recalling waiting on long lines at Bovella’s during holidays past.

“I like to see the old survive, but business is business,” Cruikshank said.

With lines for its fresh treats and breads still forming each day and the unmistakable sweet scent of Italian desserts still luring customers through its doors, many doubt Bovella’s will go under any time soon.

Meanwhile, Carlo’s may be helping to put Westfield on the world’s map—Bourcier said that though there are “no official plans yet” to film episodes of “Cake Boss” in Westfield, it’s certainly a possibility.

Additional reporting by Erin Scialabba.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


After 47 Years of Operation, Jade Isle Set to Close Its Doors in Scotch Plains

February 17, 2018

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ — The iconic Jade Isle Restaurant located at the corner of Terrill Road and Second Street in Scotch Plains will close its doors forever after its last day on  Feb. 18. A phone call to the restaurant on Saturday confirmed that the Jade Isle's long history would come to an end Sunday.

Jade Isle has served a menu of traditional Chinese and Polynesian dishes and ...

Mayor Brindle’s Update

February 15, 2018

The following are highlights from the update that Mayor Shelley Brindle gave at Tuesday night’s town council meeting.

I first want to congratulate Nick Calello and David Went for their promotions to patrol officers in the Westfield Police Department. I’d also like to welcome and congratulate new Patrol Officer Fortunato Riga, who joins the police department this week upon his ...

Upcoming Events


Sun, February 18, 3:00 PM

Lawton C. Johnson Middle School , Summit

New Jersey Intergenerational Orchestra Free ...

Arts & Entertainment


Mon, February 19, 11:00 AM

Westfield Area YMCA, Westfield

President's Day Jump

Giving Back Health & Wellness


Thu, February 22, 8:30 AM

Hilton Garden Inn, Hamilton , Hamilton

Defending Your Independent Contractor & Wage & ...

Business & Finance Education Law & Justice

Wardlaw+Hartridge Students Earn Scholarship Finalist Standing

February 17, 2018

The National Merit Scholarship Program has determined which of the 16,000 semifinalists named in September 2017 have met all requirements to advance to Finalist standing in the competition. All Finalists will be considered for National Merit Scholarships to be offered in 2018.

Wardlaw+Hartridge seniors Jennifer Guo and Suraj Chandran of Edison received their Finalist certificates from Susan ...

Westfield Police Blotter: DWI Arrest & More

February 15, 2018

February 7, 2018 10:25 p.m.

Officers Natale and Gill arrested Brian Mueller, age 55, of Westfield, NJ for driving while intoxicated pursuant to an accident investigation in the area of Mountain Avenue by Colonial Avenue. Subject was transported to headquarters, processed and released to a sober adult.


February 9, 2018 2:21 a.m.

Selena G. Palacios, age 22, of Westfield, NJ was ...

How Tax Reform Impacts You

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act brings a host of changes to tax returns for 2018. Highlighted are just a few of the new rules that may impact many of our clients. Please reach out to us to find out if and how your personal situation is impacted.

For Business:

·       A flat 21% corporate tax rate for C corporations replaces the 15% - 35% graduate rate ...

Sinai or Sanctuary?



And in the beginning, G‑d was homeless, and so G‑d asked His people to set Him up with some digs. Where does it say that? Well, nowhere, actually. But it does say that G‑d instructed Moses to tell the people, “They shall make for Me a Sanctuary, that I may dwell among them.”

Now the question is, was G‑d really homeless? ...

Westfield Public Schools Celebrate High School and Intermediate Music Honors

Westfield High School sophomore Brooke Walden auditioned and was selected to the New Jersey All-State Wind Ensemble and Orchestra for a second straight year.  Brooke was the top scoring piccolo player and ranked third on the flute.  She will perform in February with the Wind Ensemble and in November with the Orchestra.

Walden also was among 12 WHS musicians to perform in January with ...

How to Talk with Kids About the Florida Shooting

February 13, 2018

The tragedy of the Florida school shooting is devastating, leaving 17 killed and 15 injured. Our children can easily identify with what occurred yesterday. It will be the topic of conversation today in schools everywhere. School administrators are doing all they can to provide support and guidance. The shootings affect children, teachers, and school personnel. The school shooting ...

Love Craft Beer But Hate the Tour? State Assembly Moves to Make it Easier for You to Belly Up to the Bar

Good news is a brew for New Jersey craft beer advocates. In February 2018, the New Jersey Assembly’s Agriculture and Natural Resources Committee paved the way for the introduction of Bill A2196, which would remove a current licensing rule requiring breweries and distilleries to provide a tour of their facilities before serving alcoholic beverages to consumers. Currently, breweries holding a ...

'What Stays' exposes family secrets and lies

‘What Stays’ exposes family secrets, resentment and lies

By Liz Keill

SUMMIT, NJ – In an original play by Laura Ekstrand and Jason Szamreta, the Dreamcatcher Repertory Theatre has provided an enlightening, funny and heart-felt view of family foibles.

Ekstrand has said that the germ of the play came from conversations with the ensemble members of the troupe, based on ...

6 Homes Sold Last Week in Westfield, Scotch Plains, Fanwood, Cranford & Mountainside

Six homes sold last week, 2/4/2018-2/11/18, in Westfield, Scotch  Plains, Fanwood, Mountainside and Cranford.*

Sale Price   TOWN                  ADDRESS                  ...


AtlantiCast Medical Minute: Atlantic Orthopedic Institute’s Scoliosis and Spinal Deformity Center

On this episode of the AtlantiCast Medical Minute, we’ll take you inside the Atlantic Orthopedic Institute’s Scoliosis and Spinal Deformity Center, with the center’s director, Jason Lowenstein, MD.

Video Link:

Cat Found in Westfield

UPDATE: Reunited with family!

ORIGINAL POST: Cat found in Golf Edge area of Westfield. Call 908-913-0509.

Doing Well While Doing Good

The new tax law is predicted to reduce significantly the number of taxpayers who itemize deductions.  That has some concerned about charitable giving. There are ways for taxpayers who do not itemize deductions to give to charity and still receive some tax benefits.

Give from your IRA. Those aged 70-1/2 or older, who must take required minimum distributions from retirement accounts, can ...


Kathleen Marie Christian (nee Helmstetter), age 73 of Surf City, NJ, passed away peacefully at home ...
Read more

Nutley Schools Closed Friday Following Security Threat

February 16, 2018

NUTLEY, NJ — The Nutley Police Department is currently investigating a video posted to Instagram that suggested a possible threat to schools. Dr. Julie Glazer, Nutley Superintendent of Schools, made the decision late Thursday night to close Nutley schools on Friday as a safety precaution. 

The Nutley Police Department reports they have spoken to the individual ...