Law & Justice

Court Clears Yorktown of Wrongdoing Over Tree Law

Yorktown Town Hall Credits: File Photo

Editor's Note: This article has been updated from its print version to more accurately reflect the judge's decision.

YORKTOWN, N.Y. – The town board did not violate any laws regarding the creation and approval of a new tree law, a State Supreme Court justice has determined.

Resident Susan Siegel, a former town supervisor and councilwoman, had alleged the board erred by closing last year’s Sept. 20 public hearing, then altering the law and voting on it, denying the public a chance to comment on the amended version of the law.

Sign Up for E-News

Justice Barbara Zambelli, however, said the changes the board made before approving the law were not substantial and did not require a new public hearing, as Siegel alleged.

Siegel also alleged that the town board held a public hearing on the wrong version of the draft tree law. Zambelli also dismissed that accusation, saying it was based on speculation and not substantiated by facts.

Despite the dismissal, Zambelli noted that a transcript of the meeting contradicts the town board’s minutes from Sept. 20, 2016. The transcript states that the board closed the hearing then amended the law. The minutes, however, said the law was amended prior to the hearing being closed.

Though the transcript "conclusively establishes" the timeline of events, according to Zambelli, she ultimately determined a new public hearing was not required.

This is the second time in 18 months that a Siegel-initiated lawsuit against the town board has been dismissed. In January 2016, Siegel accused the board of making staffing decisions behind closed doors.

“This latest court dismissal of Siegel’s challenge to a town board action is yet another example that Siegel is intent on wasting taxpayers’ money with frivolous behavior and conduct,” said Town Attorney Michael J. McDermott.

Siegel filed her latest lawsuit in December 2016 and, three months later, the court dismissed five of the eight causes of action. The remaining three causes were dismissed on June 22.

Zambelli, in her decision, said the amendments made to the tree law were not substantial and resulted from comments made by the public.

“The three amendments were a small part of a large, complicated legislation that underwent extensive public review,” Zambelli wrote.

Siegel, in her response, said, “It’s not frivolous when the town board doesn’t follow the law.” Though she disagrees that the changes were not “substantial,” she said, she will not appeal the judge’s decision.

“My claim was that the town board proposed and adopted amendments to the law after it closed the hearing in violation of the law,” Siegel said. “The judge agreed but disagreed over whether the amendments were substantial enough to invalidate the law. The amendments were substantial because they infringed on a homeowner’s property rights and homeowners didn’t get a chance to comment on the proposed amendments which is the purpose of a public hearing.”

The amendments were: the introduction of 18-month time restrictions on two of the activities that require a permit for the removal of 10 or more protected trees, and the addition of the words “as a part of an agricultural activity” to a list of items exempt from the law.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Cuomo’s Frivolous Lawsuits Cost Us Money

Since Donald Trump became president, New York State has filed more than 100 lawsuits against the federal government. This includes those filed by both Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman and Gov. Andrew Cuomo. It does not include lawsuits filed by the City of New York. Most of them are political in nature, filed to please the plaintiffs’ voting base. In the real world, if we had filed ...

Live and Learn

When I was a senior at Fordham University (1970), the school initiated an experimental program allowing a small number of seniors to teach a professor-assisted accredited pass/fail course. I applied and to my amazement was one of three students selected. The course I taught was titled Philosophy of Education.

The underlying theory of my course was that every educational system has an ...

A Trip to the 'Liberry'

Raise your hand if you didn’t—did not—call the library the “liberry” when you were little. I’m guessing not a lot of hands just went up.

Didn’t just about all of us say “liberry” when we were learning to read? (Well, whaddya expect when a place is named something way too easy for little kids to mispronounce?)

OK. Now, raise your hand if ...

I'm Mrs. Heat Miser

To be perfectly honest, I did not need a large rodent with insomnia to convince me that we had six more weeks of winter. It’s been so cold outside lately that when I go out, my nostrils stick together. The dog is so hesitant to go out that he does his business right on the deck, less than five feet from the door, and then gives me a look of contemptuous indignation when he comes back in the ...

Should Valentine's Day Be Celebrated at School?

Dear Dr. Linda,

I’ve been a third-grade teacher for over 20 years and have never allowed my students to celebrate Valentine’s Day in my class. I know my colleagues think I’m mean, but I’m refusing to celebrate it for many reasons.

1) Children hand out cards to each other and there’s always some child left out or who gets very few; 2) Children are always asked ...

What Next for Sober Houses?

February 7, 2018

To the editor,

As Yogi Berra famously said: “It’s déjà vu all over again.”

As reported in the Jan. 25 edition of Yorktown News, 482 Underhill Ave. is back in the sober house business, this time operating as a “family,” not a convalescent, home. And because it’s operating as a family home, there are no town regulations, standards, guidelines ...

Upcoming Events

Thu, February 22, 7:00 PM

NY Presbyterian Hudson Valley Hospital, Cortlandt Manor

Book Club for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

Sat, February 24, 10:00 AM

Jefferson Valley Mall , Yorktown Heights

Yorktown Indoor Farmers Market

Food & Drink Health & Wellness

Sat, February 24, 12:00 PM

Club Fit, Jefferson Valley

Yoga for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown Receives GreenFaith Certification

February 16, 2018

The First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown has completed the requirements for GreenFaith certification ( GreenFaith is an organization which helps religious communities grow in environmental leadership. GreenFaith certification was a two year process that required a number of accomplishments in the areas of stewardship, education, worship, environmental justice advocacy, and ...