Government

Hearing Scheduled to Repeal Yorktown's Affordable Housing Law

A public hearing to repeal Yorktown's affordable housing law has been set for Tuesday, May 3. Credits: Brian Marschhauser/Yorktown News
a66caff52716545c7504_7ef1b3e8348ec893614c_jj_and_grace.jpg
From left: James Johnson and Yorktown Supervisor Michael Grace
a66caff52716545c7504_7ef1b3e8348ec893614c_jj_and_grace.jpg

Editor's Note: The video, featuring Supervisor Grace's comments, has been edited for time and does not reflect the entirety of his comments. The full video of the April 5 Town Board meeting can be viewed on yorktownny.org. The exchange between Grace and the resident begins around 2:06:45.

YORKTOWN, N.Y. - In a move deemed by one county official as “rattling the bear’s cage,” the Yorktown Town Board will seek to repeal its local affordable housing law at its meeting this coming Tuesday.

The bear, in this case, is the federal government, which settled a 2009 lawsuit with Westchester County after the county was sued by the Anti-Discrimination Center in New York. The agreement with the U.S. Housing and Urban Development (HUD), signed by former Democratic County Executive Andy Spano, stipulates that the county approve funding for 750 affordable housing units in 31 municipalities by the end of 2016.

Sign Up for E-News

Yorktown is indeed one of those municipalities, but Supervisor Michael Grace, a Republican, said the town is under no obligation to encourage affordable housing, nonetheless require it from new developers. In fact, Grace said the 2011 local law enacted following the settlement, which requires all new developments of eight units or more to dedicate a portion as affordable housing, is an illegal “tax.”

“Zoning is concerned with area and bulk requirements, density, uses, etc.,” Grace said. “When I go over that line and I go to manage your property, I’ve overstepped the bounds of my jurisdiction as a town.”

Grace’s comments were made at a Town Board meeting earlier this month, after a resident warned the supervisor that his actions could result in a lawsuit by the federal government. The resident referred specifically to James Johnson, a court-appointed monitor overseeing compliance of the settlement.

“Is he gonna come and beat me up?” Grace asked resident Ed Ciffone. “Let him try.”

“He’s gonna beat the town up and taxpayers because you’ll be getting a suit,” Ciffone responded.

Johnson sent a letter to Grace on March 30, asking about the status of the public hearing. The same day, Johnson sent a letter to Robert Meehan, attorney for Westchester County, asking if county officials intend to “discourage or dissuade” Yorktown from repealing the 2011 law, as it would “undercut” the settlement agreement. He also inquired about how much county funding Yorktown receives.

Grace said he was not worried about Johnson’s letters.

“The bottom line is the federal government can go tell the county what to do, because the county is a party to their lawsuit. The town of Yorktown is not,” Grace said. “The federal government can’t tell me anything. There’s still municipal home rule in New York State.”

Mike Kaplowitz, Yorktown’s county legislator and chairman of the County Board, said Grace’s words and actions puzzled him. To date, he said Yorktown has been “exemplary in providing diversified housing.”

“I have no idea why anybody would purposely rattle a bear’s cage just for the sake of rattling a cage,” Kaplowitz said. “I just hope the supervisor knows what he’s doing.”

Kaplowitz, a Democrat, also said Grace is wrong in saying that Yorktown was not a party to the 2009 settlement, because the county settled “on behalf of all of the municipalities.”

“I don’t think that’s a terribly strong argument,” Kaplowitz said.

While supporting Grace’s right as town supervisor to make decisions in the best interest of his municipality, Kaplowitz said he does not understand why Grace would take such a public position against the federal government.

“I just wonder in the end if it’s going to cost taxpayers significant dollars and angst to defend that position,” Kaplowitz said.

In addition to overseeing compliance, Johnson was also tasked with publishing reports “analyzing impediments to fair housing” in Westchester, “including barriers imposed by local zoning regulations.” In those reports, Johnson noted that Yorktown “has an exemplary zoning code in terms of providing opportunities for affordable housing.” That description was “due in no small part” to the law the Town Board is now attempting to repeal, he wrote to Grace on March 30.

Grace sent a letter back to Johnson on April 15 further explaining his position. He said Yorktown has had an affordable housing law since 1988. That law, separate from the 2011 law, allows developers to request additional units of housing in consideration for creating affordable units. Grace said the 1988 law is a “bonus” for developers, while the 2011 law is a “tax.”

Both laws, while well-intentioned, are flawed, Grace wrote. Those that purchase affordable units are “trapped,” he wrote, because they are unable to sell it without a loss. As a result, “the town was obligated to subsidize sales or release units from the deed restrictions,” he wrote. Affordable units also don’t allow purchasers to “accumulate wealth in the long-term through recapturing market created equity,” Grace said.

There have been 26 affordable units created in Yorktown since 2009, with 10-12 more pending, Grace added. On top of that, Yorktown “has always sought to provide a wide-range of housing options,” he wrote.

He finished his letter telling Johnson: “If you would like to be heard, please attend our May 3, 2016, public hearing meeting.”

The May 3 meeting begins at 7:30 p.m. in Yorktown Town Hall, 363 Underhill Ave.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Yorktown

Catching up with Westchester County Executive George Latimer

George Latimer, our new county executive, has been in office now for a little over half a year. I thought it might be a good time to check in with my friend to see how things were going. You can see the interview in its entirety on Channel 74 (Optimum) at 9 p.m. Wednesday nights.

What happened last November?

The election last November brought change throughout Westchester County. In my ...

A (Burnt) Toast to Love and Marriage, on the Rocks

In its first few moments, sitcom-style comedy “Clever Little Lies” grabs audience attention right away, with one of the most revealing wardrobe changes you’ll ever see on stage. It is done modestly but just provocatively enough to elicit vocal appreciation from amused patrons.

The fast-paced play, starring Richard Kline of TV comedy classic “Three’s ...

Assemblyman Kevin Byrne Looks Back on 2018 Legislative Session

July 17, 2018

There’s an old saying, “Our liberty is never safe when the New York State Legislature is in session.” There’s definitely some truth to that. This past legislative session I successfully fought back against several initiatives that would have added to our state’s crushing tax burden, added excessive regulations on businesses that hurt job creation and chipped away at ...

The Adventures of Superdog

I was always very impressed that my dog could bark on command and come when I called his name, until I read in the newspaper about a dog that saved his owner’s life by calling 9-1-1. Apparently, when his owner had a seizure, the dog pushed a speed-dial button for 9-1-1, barked into the receiver for help, and then opened the door when the responders arrived.

Honestly, though, it’s ...

If You See Something, Say Something

July 11, 2018

I am writing this letter because I see something different with the new Yorktown Town Board. I see an open government instead of a dictatorship with rubber stamps. I see the new Town Board working together for the best interests of the residents in Yorktown.

The auditor suggests in his report to not start a capital project without having the money first. A bad example is the Granite Knolls ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_4e4c638eba7b9d057333_782289e382fb71551284_bocce_open_play_6-19-18

Thu, July 19, 7:00 PM

Yorktown Heights

Bocce Open Play

Sports

Thu, July 19, 7:15 PM

Jack DeVito Veterans Memorial Field, Yorktown

Outdoor Movie Night

Arts & Entertainment

Sat, July 21, 12:00 PM

Club Fit, Jefferson Valley

Yoga for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

Yorktown Residents Named Ambassadors of Support-a-Walk

July 12, 2018

Two Yorktown residents have been named Walk Ambassadors for the Annual Support-a-Walk organized by Support Connection, a non-profit organization that provides support and services to people battling breast or ovarian cancer. This year's walk will take place on Oct. 7 (rain or shine) at FDR State Park.

Mary Heagle, Mohegan Lake

Heagle’s experience with breast cancer began when her ...