Law & Justice

Lawsuit Over Yorktown's ‘Illegal’ Drainage System Dismissed

Baptist Church Road Credits: File Photo

YORKTOWN, N.Y. – A neighbor’s lawsuit claiming the town of Yorktown installed an “illegal drainage system” on Baptist Church Road has been dismissed by a New York State Supreme Court justice.

Dr. Michael Salitan, who lives at 1225 Baptist Church Road, alleged that the drainage system caused water, silt and debris to discharge onto his 5-acre property every time it rained. The discharge, he claimed, caused erosion to his property, which includes a stream, a waterfall and a pond. Heavy rain events would also cause his pond’s level to rise, he claimed, sometimes flooding his home.

Supreme Court Justice Lewis Lubell dismissed all of Salitan’s claims, saying Yorktown, like other municipalities, is immune from “failure of design” of drainage systems. Yorktown can be held liable for “maintenance and repair,” but that is not what Salitan alleged, Lubell wrote in his decision.

Sign Up for E-News

“As argued by [Yorktown], nowhere does [Salitan] allege that the drainage system degraded over time or was not properly maintained by the town,” Lubell wrote. “The sole contention is that the installation and refusal to remove the drainage system caused damage by virtue of the discharged water passing over his land.”

Salitan told Yorktown News that Lubell’s decision was “rife with errors” and that his attorneys have filed an appeal to the Appellate Division, Second Department, in Brooklyn. He said the litigation is “not over, not by any stretch.”

“We are confident that Justice Lubell’s erroneous determination will be reversed,” Salitan said.

Town Attorney Michael J. McDermott remained confident the decision will be upheld.

“The town stands by Justice Lubell’s decision and order,” McDermott said. “If Dr. Salitan appeals, the town expects that the dismissal of the action will be upheld as the correct result.”

Salitan said local judges, like Lubell, “give a great deal of deference and latitude to municipalities and towns.” He said he hopes the appellate court corrects his “errors.”

“The court erroneously found that the town was entitled to a legal immunity for the design of the drainage system,” Salitan said. “This determination is simply ridiculous on its face.”

Salitan said the town did not even design the drainage system, which, he said, was installed by his neighbor. Because of this, he said, the town cannot be immune from its design.

He and the town have engaged in a long and complicated legal dispute dating back to 2013. At that time, the town was in the process of designing a new Baptist Church Road bridge, which required an easement onto Salitan’s neighboring property. Salitan resisted, with Yorktown prevailing in a months-long eminent domain proceeding. Despite receiving the easements in February 2014, the bridge repairs were never made and it collapsed in April 2015. With the bridge now closed, the town sought more easements onto Salitan’s property to rebuild it.

The two sides attempted to settle out of court, with Salitan desiring both an aesthetically pleasing stone wall and the dredging of silt from the pond on his property.

At its Sept. 1, 2015, meeting, the town board agreed to set aside money to repair the bridge, with a portion dedicated to constructing a stone wall of Salitan’s choosing. The town was also prepared to remove the sediment from Salitan’s property in hopes of ending the lawsuit.

A few weeks later, however, settlement talks broke down and the town built a new bridge without using Salitan’s land. To do so, the town had to build a taller, narrower bridge.

Salitan called the new bridge an “aesthetic nightmare” that is out of character with the neighborhood. The town, in a press release, said it was willing to address Salitan’s issues, but that he “rebuffed” all of the town’s offers. Salitan said this is not true.

“Putting aside the obvious question of why would the town offer to repair the damage to my property if the town was not responsible, what actually occurred is that the town pulled its offer to repair my property out of the blue and forced the litigation to continue,” Salitan said.

If repairing the bridge without using any of Salitan’s land was an option from the beginning, he said, the town should have done so instead of wasting his time and money in court.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


The Hatch Act and Immigration Updates

This is for information purposes only. So, when you see headlines like the recent “Kellyanne Conway cited for two violations of the Hatch Act,” you will have a working knowledge of what it means. First off, what is the Hatch Act? This has nothing to do with Orrin Hatch, senator from Utah. Simply put, it states one cannot advocate for or against candidates while serving in an official ...

Are We All Connected?

A question that has long plagued me is whether we, as a species, have evolved in our consciousness of our interconnectedness to one another.

Influential philosophers, writers, economists and politicians have debated whether that should be our focus in the first place. Writers such as Ayn Rand (“The Fountainhead”) and her followers have suggested that our center of attention should ...

To Harrison, L'Chaim!

At long last, the smile of spring approaches, as an angry winter recedes into good riddance. Our spirit is ready to be re-charged. Damn the power outages, full speed ahead!

For my wife, Elyse, daughter, Elissa, and me, this otherwise exuberant time of year brings a confusion of mixed emotions. In 2003, on the opening day of spring, March 20, which happens to be my birthday, our 15-year-old son ...

Whose Hypocrisy?

March 7, 2018

Councilman Ed Lachterman has an unbridled First Amendment right to critique actions of the new Town Board majority and administration (Feb. 22, “An ‘air of hypocrisy’ at town hall”). But in the court of public opinion, his comments will fare poorly before those who respect objective truth.

The councilman’s political self-interest in the manufacture of non-issues ...

When It's Not OK to Ask If Everything's OK

There is this thing that I do that annoys the heck out of my family. Well, to be honest, there are a lot of things I do that annoy the heck out of my family, but I am thinking of one thing in particular.

Whenever someone is in the bathroom for what I determine to be an abnormally long period of time, I stand outside the bathroom door and yell,


I ...

Reading Across America With Dr. Seuss

Dear Dr. Linda,

I’m a school librarian and I wanted to remind your readers that March 2 was “Read Across America Day.”  Teachers, librarians and others who read with children encourage schools, libraries and parents to celebrate this day with their children. This special date was chosen because it is the birthday of Dr. Seuss, the adored children’s author. That ...

Hold Con Edison Accountable

March 14, 2018

To the editor,

I am writing to suggest that my fellow residents assist in holding Con Edison responsible for its disastrous handling of these storms and, further, to support steps that would ensure these now common shortcomings are not repeated.

Like too many here, I, my wife and three children ages 5, 3, and 8 months have been without power for more than a week. That we could live within ...

Upcoming Events

Fri, March 23, 8:00 PM

OAC Steamer Co. Firehouse, Ossining

2018 Living Art Event

Arts & Entertainment

Sat, March 24, 10:00 AM

Jefferson Valley Mall , Yorktown Heights

Yorktown Indoor Farmers Market

Food & Drink Health & Wellness

Sat, March 24, 12:00 PM

Club Fit, Jefferson Valley

Yoga for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

Seton Holds First Social Fundraiser

March 14, 2018

St. Elizabeth Ann Seton school, 1375 East Main St., Shrub Oak will be hosting it's first ever Social Fundraiser on Friday, May 4th, 2018 in the Seton school gym.  Seton extends it's invitation to all to join in a night of food, fun, and dozens of raffles and silent auctions.  Entry tickets must be purchased in advance. Tickets purchased by April 6th will be $35 per person; ...