Guest Column

Protecting Yorktown’s Woodlands and Trees

Yorktown has a lot of trees. We’re lucky that way, because trees perform many important functions that provide us, as a community and as individual homeowners, with a rich array of aesthetic, environmental and financial benefits—for free.

In recognition of those functions and benefits, in 2010 the Town Board enacted an environmentally-grounded, progressive Tree Law. The law’s overriding goal is to preserve Yorktown’s woodlands, as well as protect individual trees, while at the same time recognizing the inherent rights of homeowners to manage their own property and also to accommodate reasonable development.

Now Yorktown’s woods and trees are in danger, because the Town Board is considering repealing the 2010 law and replacing it with a new law; a law that is significantly weaker. And for no apparent reason as no data or analysis has been provided pointing out problems with the current law.

Sign Up for E-News

In numerous ways, the current law achieves a well thought-out balance of protecting individual property rights while preserving the town’s woodlands and trees.

Instead of being a copy, cut and paste of other municipal tree laws that typically protect individual trees, the innovative 2010 law is geared toward protecting the critical functions of woodland communities, as well as individual trees. For example, trees functioning as a buffer between residential properties are regulated differently from trees holding soil in place on a slope. Trees in a woodland are regulated differently from the stately historical trees in front of the John C. Hart Library. In other words, the 2010 law recognizes that the regulation should be tailored to the function of the tree or woodland and that one regulation doesn’t fit all situations.

While some property owners and elected officials have criticized the 2010 law as overly complicated, these critics fail to realize that it’s the law’s careful attention to detail that actually protects the rights of property owners.

A draft of the new Tree Law is currently being circulated to advisory boards for feedback. Because the draft includes many internal contradictions, inconsistencies, undefined terms and omissions, one assumes (and hopes) that the draft will undergo major revisions before a version is advertised for a public hearing. One wonders, however, why the Town Board didn’t take the time to identify problems with the current law, real as well as perceived, and then suggest changes. Why throw the baby out with the bath water?

Here are just a few of the provisions and omissions in the proposed Tree Law revision, which actually make the new law less protective and more difficult for the individual homeowner, while, at the same time, doing nothing towards the overall goal of preserving Yorktown’s woodlands and important individual trees.

• There is no overriding goal to preserve Yorktown’s critically important wooded areas. Indeed, the proposed law has no stated goal at all. This is a shortsighted approach to protecting a natural resource that can take decades to replenish itself.

• The draft law treats all property owners the same, regardless of lot size. The regulated buffer zone in which a tree cutting permit is required is the same for quarter-acre lot as for a 4-acre lot, which means on small lots potentially almost the entire property is a regulated zone. An example where one regulation definitely does not fit all.

• The draft law does not differentiate between permits a homeowner might need for limited tree removal and a permit required by a developer who will likely clear cut a large area of trees.

• The draft law eliminates the special protections for large property owners who already have professionally written plans for the sustainable management of their trees and wooded areas.

• The draft law regulates trees only on private property and completely leaves out woodlands that are the home of thousands of trees in town-owned open space and parks as well as individual trees along our streets and roads. Should the town be allowed to exempt itself from regulations that all other property owners must abide by?

When I taught college-level environmental science courses, on the first day of class I asked incoming students if they cared about the environment and to name something they did which signified this care. Often students cited not littering as a testament to their environmental stewardship. This is a perfectly acceptable answer. However, it focuses on how things look and reveals a lack of understanding about how the environment works.

Similarly the new draft Tree Law focuses on individual trees with little understanding of how large wooded areas function and why, as a community, we need to balance preservation with human activities. Will the Town Board move beyond the first day of class?

Linda Miller is a former environmental consultant to municipalities and helped write the 2010 Tree Law.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Guest Column.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


What Is Cambridge Analytica?

Cambridge Analytica is a research organization. Apparently, it is funded by the Mercer family, second only to the Koch brothers on the liberal hit list. Both, through their philanthropy, spend millions on various needy organizations like hospitals. What makes them liberal targets is their funding of various conservative think tanks and candidates. I digress.

Cambridge Analytica used Facebook ...

The Best of the Best: Albert Capellini

In the spring of 1991, after answering an ad for a judicial race placed in the local Yorktown paper, I was talked into the unenviable position of running for Yorktown councilman as a Democrat in our then solidly Republican town.

Having been a practicing lawyer since 1974, I felt confident about my qualifications for the position of town judge, but being elected to the Town Board was quite ...

‘Sister Act’: A Musical Like Nun Other

Of all the Broadway musicals I’ve seen over the years at Westchester Broadway Theatre, only a handful have elicited the noisily enthusiastic audience response I observed at the recent opening night of “Sister Act.”

There were outbursts of applause in the middle of some numbers, and several clever turns of phrase sprinkled in the dialogue landed squarely, to the delight of big ...

An Open Letter to the Yorktown Town Board

April 11, 2018

The Yorktown Chamber of Commerce proudly serves as the voice of Yorktown’s vibrant business community. A vital part of our mission is to help improve the quality of life for all Yorktowners.

The chamber’s Board of Directors is more ambitious than ever, as we work hard to find new ways to enhance our great community through marketing opportunities and smartly placed commercial and ...

Cleaning the Empty Nest

Part of the shock of being a part-time empty nester is when the kids come back to visit and I have to watch my house transform overnight from a pristine haven of OCD goodness to a place that looks like an explosion happened at Forever 21.

After my kids moved mostly out, I put away whatever tchotchkes they chose to leave behind and then I put on a hazmat suit and cleaned their rooms until they ...

Why Do Kids Hate Math?

Dear Dr. Linda,

I am in second grade and have a problem about math. My teacher just keeps giving me homework and it’s driving me crazy. Because she keeps giving it to me on weekends and spring and summer breaks. And it’s only one level and it’s too hard. But the other people who have special needs get to be moved into a higher or lower group and they learn even more because ...

Upcoming Events

Fri, April 20, 10:30 AM

Yorktown Community Cultural Center, YORKTOWN HEIGHTS

Tai Chi for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

Fri, April 20, 1:00 PM

Yorktown Town Hall, Yorktown Heights

Yorktown Senior Advisory Committee

Community Calendar

Fri, April 20, 7:00 PM

Villa Barone Hilltop Manor, Mahopac

Support Connection’s 2018 Spring Benefit

Giving Back

Guiding Eyes for the Blind Launches Wag-a-Thon Fundraiser

April 18, 2018

On April 17, Guiding Eyes for the Blind, a non-profit organization dedicated to creating and supporting life-changing connections between people with vision loss and exceptional guide dogs, announced its first annual Wag-a-thon, a “virtual marathon in a month” fundraiser beginning on May 1.

The Wag-a-thon is a cumulative marathon that you and your dog can do anywhere, at your own ...