Guest Column

When Doing Nothing Costs Money


Yorktown is owed $3 million, and every year that town officials do nothing to collect this debt Yorktown taxpayers lose money.

As of Dec. 3, 2015, the owners of 158 parcels owed the taxpayers of Yorktown $3 million in unpaid taxes and interest, aka liens, from 2005 through 2013. Yes, 2005. That’s not a typo. Some of the money is owed by homeowners, some by corporations. Some property owners only owe a few hundred dollars but at least one property owner owes more than $200,000.

Some examples:

Sign Up for E-News

  • The owner/occupant of a house owes $169,386 in back taxes and interest dating back to 2005.
  • The corporate owner of a property that houses multiple dwelling units owes $120,702 in back taxes and interest for 2011-2013. 
  • A 9-plus-acre vacant parcel owes $67,421 in back taxes and interest for 2006-2013. When the parcel was sold in August, 2015—for $10—the title search did not disclose the existence of the liens. And the new owner is in the process of building a single-family house on the parcel.
  • Two elected officials owe a total of $22,032 in taxes and interest for 2013 on properties they own or have an ownership interest in.

When town officials do precious little to collect unpaid taxes, their inaction is costly. It’s wasteful. It’s inexcusable.

Inaction is costly in two ways: not only does the town not receive the taxes levied on the property which it relies on to balance the budget, there’s an additional cost because when property owners don’t pay their taxes, by law, the town has to pay the county and the school district the full amount of the taxes that are due those entities. So it’s a double whammy—not only does the town come up short in collecting, it has to actually make payouts on behalf of the delinquent homeowners.

While in most cases, the back taxes are eventually paid—with interest that becomes a welcome non-tax revenue for the town. However, when it becomes clear that the back taxes will never be paid, the taxes and the foregone interest have to be written off (wiped) from the town’s financial books. Like making a withdrawal from your savings account, the dollar value of the uncollectible liens is subtracted from the town’s reserves, aka fund balance.

Example: In 2010, after a concerted multi-department effort to clean up unpaid back taxes, some dating back to 1995, the town wiped out just under $1 million in uncollectible liens from the fund balance. Since then, an additional $907,000 has been wiped from the books for a grand total of almost $2 million in lost revenue to the town. And there are more liens waiting to be wiped from the fund balance.

Inaction is wasteful because each year the town does nothing to collect what it is owed, it ends up losing more and more money.

Examples: The Sultana Ridge Association, a quasi-homeowners association that owns a pool but exists only on paper, owes the town $56,505 in taxes for 2008-2013. The association has no regular source of income and the pool has been closed for several years. As long as the Town Board continues to do nothing to resolve the future ownership of the property, Yorktown taxpayers will continue to pay the annual county and school taxes on the property.  

A second defunct homeowners association currently owes $56,521 in taxes from 2005-2013. And, like the Sultana pool, taxpayers will continue to pay the annual school and county tax bills until the town decides what to do with the property.

Three vacant adjoining parcels with unpaid taxes as of 2009 were included in the 2011 foreclosure petition, the last foreclosure petition filed by the town. It then took the town 21 months to take title to the property—and another 24 months to try to sell the property at auction. By the time the parcels were sold in November 2015 for a total of $11,000, the three properties had cost the town $18,802 in taxes for 2009-2013, plus an estimated $5,000 in school taxes for 2014 and 2015. (Combined, the three parcels make a buildable lot. At the November auction, there were no bids at the initial $23,000 price set by the town.)

Inaction is inexcusable because the procedure for collecting delinquent liens is straightforward and mostly an automated clerical process. But it’s a procedure that Yorktown officials have been slow to implement—either by choice or neglect. The procedure can include two optional letters, an initial “reminder” letter followed by a stronger “warning” letter. But ultimately, if the optional letters haven’t resulted in the taxes being paid, the town files a formal foreclosure petition that gives the delinquent property owner a third chance to pay up before the court allows the town to take title to the property (aka an in-rem proceeding) for non-payment of taxes.

EXAMPLE: Yorktown waited until February 2015, to send “reminder“ letters to people who owed taxes dating back to 2010. To date, no warning letters have been sent. And, when asked when they would go out, the town official in charge of the process said she would skip that step and go right to the foreclosure petition. But that hasn’t been done yet.

All this leads one to ask: What very specific actions will the new Town Board take, and when, to collect the $3 million owed to the taxpayers of Yorktown? Yorktown taxpayers have already permanently lost almost $2 million. If we don’t want to see more money lost, it’s time for more action and less talk.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Guest Column.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


How Far Down the Rathole Will New York Go?

Boy oh boy, Governor Cuomo must be wetting his pants over being primaried on his left by Cynthia Nixon. In his continued lurch leftward to stave off this challenge, last week Cuomo issued an executive order to allow parolees the right to vote in New York. That is right. Now all 55,000 parolees, which include murderers and rapists, will be able vote. The Legislature wouldn’t pass this, so ...

World at a Crossroads

I was born three and a half years after Nazism and Fascism were defeated in Europe in April of 1945. Being victorious in World War II was no small feat and our country rejoiced during the 1950s by embedding the decade with unbridled optimism about the future. After all, the Allies had confronted and defeated what, until recently, would have been considered an unimaginable evil. Additionally, in ...

Time to Crank It Up!

It’s easy to get upset these days for any number of reasons. Still, hope springs eternal (even when we’ve given up hope of seeing spring). We live in a time of such grace and deference toward each other that a wimpy word like snowflake is the toughest insult that bullies can muster.  

We’ve all heard of the Bully Pulpit. That’s when somebody uses his leverage ...

Time to Take Action on Low Voter Turnout

April 26, 2018

Low voter turnout, particularly among young people, has reached crisis proportions—what will we do about it?

In terms of the percentage of people voting, the United States ranks near the bottom among developed countries in the world; New York ranks 44th among the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Only 41 out of approximately 500 18-year-olds in Yorktown voted in the 2017 election.

Closet Case

Not too long ago, if you said you had a room the size of a closet, it meant the space was probably pretty darn small. These days, however, it’s not uncommon to have a closet the size of a living room, with more sliding drawers, revolving racks and custom shoe trees than Barney’s or Bloomies or Kim Kardashian. So nowadays, if you tell someone you have a room the size of a closet, the ...

Where's Gilbert's Sense of Urgency

April 26, 2018

Supervisor Ilan Gilbert’s non-confrontational approach and slow methodic consideration of every issue is more suited for the courtroom than town hall. Supervisor Gilbert needs to take off his former judicial robe and put on a pair of political gloves and enter the rough and tumble arena of Yorktown politics.

Yorktown voters wanted change and not business as usual. Supervisor ...

Upcoming Events

Fri, April 27, 10:30 AM

Yorktown Community Cultural Center, YORKTOWN HEIGHTS

Tai Chi for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

Sat, April 28, 12:00 PM

Club Fit, Jefferson Valley

Yoga for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

Guiding Eyes for the Blind Launches Wag-a-Thon Fundraiser

April 18, 2018

On April 17, Guiding Eyes for the Blind, a non-profit organization dedicated to creating and supporting life-changing connections between people with vision loss and exceptional guide dogs, announced its first annual Wag-a-thon, a “virtual marathon in a month” fundraiser beginning on May 1.

The Wag-a-thon is a cumulative marathon that you and your dog can do anywhere, at your own ...