Yorktown Library Workers Grieve Pay Scale, Claim Gender Discrimination

The John C. Hart Memorial Library

SHRUB OAK, N.Y. – Thirteen library workers at the John C. Hart Memorial Library have filed a grievance against the town of Yorktown regarding their placement on the town’s pay scale.

Civil Service Employees Association (CSEA) workers in the town of Yorktown are separated into two classes: A and A-1. A library worker who spoke to Yorktown News on the condition of anonymity said the Class A positions include mostly “blue-collar” workers (cleaners, cooks, laborers, maintenance workers and mechanics), while Class A-1 positions are considered “white-collar” (clerks, typists, stenographers, building and environmental inspectors, and the code enforcement officer). To her, it’s clear where the library workers should be grouped.

“We don’t look down on the blue-collar workers,” the library worker said. “We just want to be grouped with our counterparts.”

Sign Up for E-News

The library worker said they have been unsuccessfully lobbying their union to negotiate a jump to the higher pay scale for years and can only think of one reason as to why the town has “dug its heels in” so vociferously against it.

“Within our town, we are being discriminated against,” the library worker said.

There are 14 library positions under Class A; one is currently vacant. The entirely female library staff features four “librarian II” positions (all have master’s degrees); three “librarian I” positions (all have master’s degrees); three senior clerks (all have associate’s or bachelor’s degrees); two clerks (all have associate’s or bachelor’s degrees); and one staff assistant (has an associate’s degree). The library’s only male worker, a caretaker, is also on the Class A list.

The previous CSEA contract expired in 2015 and the town and union are currently negotiating a new one. The change in classification could come with a pay raise, but the library worker said that is not why she and her female co-workers are fighting so hard.

“The town will say we’re looking for a raise,” she said. “No, we’re just looking for equality.”

Supervisor Michael Grace told Yorktown News that this is a matter for collective bargaining and could not comment about specifics.

“The issue simply is their grievance, so to speak, really has to be brought to the negotiation table with their union,” he said. “They don’t understand. They’re part of a collective bargaining unit.”

He also dismissed the allegation of gender discrimination.

“It’s got nothing to do with it,” he said.

The library workers have become skeptical that their union is even raising the issue during negotiations. Last year, the library workers filed a grievance through their union against the town. An arbitrator was set to hear the case, but the necessary paperwork had not been submitted on time by their union, the library workers claim. The hearing was dismissed on a technicality and the arbitrator heard no arguments.

The library workers have re-filed their grievance, but they believe their union neither believes they can win nor wants them to.

Keith Kuttruf, Yorktown CSEA representative, declined comment and referred Yorktown News to Fred Smit, a CSEA labor relations specialist assigned to Yorktown. Smit said the improper filing was his mistake, though he didn’t think it was an “offendable grievance” and the hearing should have been heard.

“We withdrew the last arbitration and we said we would file again and we have,” Smit said.

Smit said the grievance is only about the library workers’ placement and there is no guarantee an A-1 classification would come with a raise. He called the contract “vague.”

“We filed a grievance on behalf of the library to put them to the A-1 salary schedule, which is more a white-collar salary schedule than a blue-collar salary schedule,” Smit said. “That’s really the gist of the grievance.”

If the higher classification did not come with a raise, the library worker said, that would be even “further discrimination.”

“It’s not just about being lumped in with labor,” she said. “It’s about equal pay.”

Smit dismissed the notion that CSEA is not acting on behalf of the library workers and, like Grace, said gender has not played a role in contract negotiations. He said unions are “generally blind to gender.”

“The town has 140 to 150 people there and we’ve got a lot of clericals and a lot of blue-collar people and no one’s treated any differently based on gender,” Smit said. “We’re blind to all of those things. You do the job and you get paid based on the salary schedule.”

The library worker says a pay raise could come at no additional cost to the town. Instead of filling the currently vacant 14th library position, that money could be spread out to other employees, the library worker said.

Smit said a date has not yet been set for the next arbitration hearing.

“It is now in the hands of the town’s attorney and our attorney,” he said.

Brian Marschhauser can be reached at

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Cuomo’s Frivolous Lawsuits Cost Us Money

Since Donald Trump became president, New York State has filed more than 100 lawsuits against the federal government. This includes those filed by both Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman and Gov. Andrew Cuomo. It does not include lawsuits filed by the City of New York. Most of them are political in nature, filed to please the plaintiffs’ voting base. In the real world, if we had filed ...

Live and Learn

When I was a senior at Fordham University (1970), the school initiated an experimental program allowing a small number of seniors to teach a professor-assisted accredited pass/fail course. I applied and to my amazement was one of three students selected. The course I taught was titled Philosophy of Education.

The underlying theory of my course was that every educational system has an ...

A Trip to the 'Liberry'

Raise your hand if you didn’t—did not—call the library the “liberry” when you were little. I’m guessing not a lot of hands just went up.

Didn’t just about all of us say “liberry” when we were learning to read? (Well, whaddya expect when a place is named something way too easy for little kids to mispronounce?)

OK. Now, raise your hand if ...

I'm Mrs. Heat Miser

To be perfectly honest, I did not need a large rodent with insomnia to convince me that we had six more weeks of winter. It’s been so cold outside lately that when I go out, my nostrils stick together. The dog is so hesitant to go out that he does his business right on the deck, less than five feet from the door, and then gives me a look of contemptuous indignation when he comes back in the ...

Should Valentine's Day Be Celebrated at School?

Dear Dr. Linda,

I’ve been a third-grade teacher for over 20 years and have never allowed my students to celebrate Valentine’s Day in my class. I know my colleagues think I’m mean, but I’m refusing to celebrate it for many reasons.

1) Children hand out cards to each other and there’s always some child left out or who gets very few; 2) Children are always asked ...

What Next for Sober Houses?

February 7, 2018

To the editor,

As Yogi Berra famously said: “It’s déjà vu all over again.”

As reported in the Jan. 25 edition of Yorktown News, 482 Underhill Ave. is back in the sober house business, this time operating as a “family,” not a convalescent, home. And because it’s operating as a family home, there are no town regulations, standards, guidelines ...

Upcoming Events

Thu, February 22, 7:00 PM

NY Presbyterian Hudson Valley Hospital, Cortlandt Manor

Book Club for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

Sat, February 24, 10:00 AM

Jefferson Valley Mall , Yorktown Heights

Yorktown Indoor Farmers Market

Food & Drink Health & Wellness

Sat, February 24, 12:00 PM

Club Fit, Jefferson Valley

Yoga for Women with Cancer

Health & Wellness

First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown Receives GreenFaith Certification

February 16, 2018

The First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown has completed the requirements for GreenFaith certification ( GreenFaith is an organization which helps religious communities grow in environmental leadership. GreenFaith certification was a two year process that required a number of accomplishments in the areas of stewardship, education, worship, environmental justice advocacy, and ...