Guest Column

Are We Protecting Our Environment?

When a developer tells us that his or her plans will not cause any negative environmental impacts, should the town automatically accept their statement? Or, should the town review the developer’s statement to make sure that the town’s interests, and the interests of its residents, are protected?

If the answer to this question seems obvious, then Yorktown has a problem. A serious problem. The environmental impacts of development applications, even those involving critical wetlands, are no longer being reviewed by a town-funded environmental professional. No town employee with environmental credentials or an outside environmental consultant is representing the town’s interests and verifying the accuracy of a developer’s “no adverse environmental impact” submissions.

That means that if homeowners have concerns about the possible environmental impacts of a proposed development in their neighborhood, they’re on their own. It’s up to them to “pass the hat” and hire their own consultant to make sure their property will not be negatively impacted by the proposed new development.

Sign Up for E-News

Just to be clear, I’m not saying that we can’t trust developers. All I’m saying is that while a developer is looking out for his or her interests, the town should be looking out for its interests—and the interests of its residents.

Yorktown’s problem dates back to early 2017 when the previous Town Board decided not to renew the contract of an environmental consultant whose job included reviewing the wetlands and natural resources sections of all site plans and subdivision plans. No reason was given for dropping the consultant, who had worked for the town for many years.

The Town Board then waited until November to hire a new environmental consultant. But unlike the previous consultant, who automatically reviewed the environmental aspects of all development plans, the services of the new consultant were only to be used on an on-call basis. To the best of my knowledge, the new consultant has not been called in to consult on a single application.

Not even for a controversial application involving a 14-acre, heavily wooded, environmentally sensitive site in the Croton Watershed that contains two streams, steep slopes and a flood plain. Which meant that when the Planning Board held a public hearing on the application, there was no town environmental review of the applicant’s Environmental Assessment Form, habitat study, erosion and sediment control plan and plans for building a road across both streams. Nor was there any town verification of the developer’s conclusion that the subdivision would not have any adverse environmental impacts.

While the town was silent during the hearing (the town engineer informed the Planning Board that he needed an additional 30 days to complete his technical review of the application), area homeowners weren’t. They did their homework—and they passed the hat, for a second time, to hire a professional engineer to review the applicant’s latest submissions. One after the other, the homeowners came to the podium and called the Planning Board’s attention to a series of deficiencies, missing information and conflicting, confusing, dubious and inaccurate statements in the developer’s environmental submissions. It was a staggering list that included:

• No details of how the road crossing the two streams would be constructed or the impact the disturbance would have on the streams.

• No assessment of how the removal of trees, runoff, erosion and grading would affect the hydrology of the streams or how changes to the streams would impact downstream flows or the habitat for stream-dependent wildlife.

• The tree survey, which was done in 2009, was invalid because it counted trees that were already down as a result of hurricanes Irene and Sandy.

• The impracticality of relying on the new homeowners to maintain critical and sophisticated stormwater retention facilities that were supposed to prevent runoff from flooding nearby existing houses.

• The incomplete habitat study that failed to identify endangered species known to be present on the site. The bird survey counted eight species of birds while a survey on the abutting property identified more than 40 different species.

The homeowners did what they felt had to be done to protect their neighborhood and their property values. But that doesn’t excuse the town’s failure to do its job: The town should have had an environmental professional reviewing the developer’s submissions and providing input to the Planning Board.

If the new Town Board is serious about its commitment to the environment, then it needs to rethink what environmental services the town needs and how those services can best be provided. Money should not be an issue. If Yorktown can afford to spend in excess of $5 million to build a sports complex, it certainly should be able to find money to protect and preserve the town’s fragile environment.

Susan Siegel is a former town supervisor (2010-11) and councilwoman (2014-15).

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Guest Column.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


God Is Just! Schneiderman Is Out!

Whenever you doubt that God is just, remember last Monday. That is the day New York state Attorney General Eric Schneiderman resigned.

As you know, I have had him in my sights for a long time. He has squandered our tax dollars with more than 100 lawsuits against the Trump administration. Plus, his lawsuits against Big Oil and trying to nullify our double jeopardy laws. Most will go nowhere as ...

A Scientific Look at Decision-Making

Seven years ago, when I first began sharing my thoughts with you, I posed the question: What are the neurological mechanics of decision-making? I was referring not only to decisions about our actions, but also to the method by which we form our beliefs and preferences, political and otherwise. What inspired that inquiry, at that time, was my observation that our nation was increasingly polarized ...

Bias in Media, in Me, in You

While listening to an interview with a voter on my car radio, I thought I had excess ear wax that obstructed my hearing. The voter (whose name is Bruce) said this about one of the qualifications that a Senate or House candidate must have to earn his vote: “I don’t want anyone with ideas. We have enough of those already.”

I’m a journalist and have been one my entire ...

Cross My Legs and Hope to Die

One morning, I had a big cup of coffee as I usually do, and then I got in the car and drove 40 minutes to a clothing store I had been curious to check out. I don’t normally drive 40 minutes to go shopping, but since I am a stay-at-home mom and everyone knows we stay-at-home moms just spend our time shopping and eating bonbons, I figured, “What the hey.”

Having had the ...

Don’t Mix Politics with Business

May 17, 2018

When every year is an election year, it’s hard to avoid “talking” politics—but business leaders need to try.

The problem is that talking politics changes relationships. You quickly go from business owner or salesperson to Democrat, Republican, etc.

Putting a political sign in front of your business is a clear sign (literally) of your views. Not only do you tell your ...

Upcoming Events

Sun, May 20, 10:00 AM

FDR Park, Yorktown Heights

Northwell Health’s Second Annual Health Walk at ...

Health & Wellness

Sun, May 20, 6:30 PM

Mohansic Grill & Lounge, Yorktown

Comedians for a Cure

Food & Drink Giving Back

Sun, May 20, 7:00 PM

Paramount Hudson Valley Theater, Peekskill

Yorktown Relay for Life Comedy Night

Arts & Entertainment Giving Back

Yorktown Youth Soccer Club Roundup

May 18, 2018

YORKTOWN, N.Y. – Yorktown’s Girls U9 Team, the Hurricanes, defeated the Poughkeepsie Fireflies with a 1-0 win at Hunterbrook Field in Yorktown.

Hurricane’s goalies Cameron Parise and Avery Pugliese shut out the Poughkeepsie offense with several key saves. Yorktown controlled the ball throughout the game with outstanding performances by midfielders Samantha Nastasi, Macey ...