Government

Patel to Grace: ‘Make My Day’; Sparks Fly During Depot Square Debate

Supervisor Michael Grace and Councilman Vishnu Patel, right, argue over "protocol" at board meetings. Credits: yorktownny.org/townboard/meeting-videos

YORKTOWN, N.Y. - At last week’s town board meeting, two resolutions concerning the future of the long-debated Depot Square project angered Councilman Vishnu Patel, the board’s lone Democrat, who targeted town board Republicans in a heated exchange.

At one point in the dust up, Supervisor Michael Grace told Patel that if he did not stop speaking over his fellow councilmembers, that he would institute new rules about speaking at board meetings.

“Go ahead and do it,” Patel told Grace. “Make my day.”

Sign Up for E-News

The town’s plan calls for the construction of new highway and parks offices on Greenwood Street. The highway garage, located on the corner of Underhill Avenue and Front Street, would then be demolished and the town-owned property would be sold to a private developer. Conceptual plans for the property indicates it will have a three-story mixed-use building with other amenities, such as a gazebo and plaza seating.

Sparks began to fly when Patel said he was voting against two resolutions authorizing Grace to spend $36,450 on outside engineering services for the Underhill Avenue/Front Street property. The resolutions, dealing mostly with stormwater runoff, were approved 4 to 1.

“This is really, to me, it’s a fake project,” Patel said. “I want the town to keep that land, because you will not be able to purchase that land back ever again.”

Patel accused his fellow councilmembers of spending money to clean up the property, which would then be given to a “friend” for free.

“My vote is N-O. No,” Patel said. “One, two, three times.”

Grace asked Patel if he could refrain from talking over fellow councilmembers, and Patel replied that he would not.

“No,” Patel said. “I learned from Trump. He talks over [people] worse than anybody else. That’s another problem I have. You can do whatever you want and other people cannot.”

Councilman Ed Lachterman asked Patel if he could keep the conversation on topic. He then told Patel he was “being rude.”

“Why are you taking over me?” said Patel, who is in his eighth year as a councilman. “I have been sitting longer than you. I have experience.”

Lachterman, elected in 2015, responded, “But I’m still a councilman, Vishnu.”

Patel, a retired IBM scientist, said: “Oh yeah? You’re a councilman? You have your vote, I understand. You have 4 to 1, but let me tell you: $10 billion IBM trusted in me, OK? You want me to show you my award? Twice. So don’t tell me I have no clue how the budget works.”

Deputy Supervisor Gregory Bernard said he was upset by the accusation that the town board would give the highway garage property to a friend.

“Every time this discussion comes up there’s an innuendo by Councilman Patel…” Bernard started before Patel cut him off.

“Not innuendo; the facts and the science,” Patel said. “You know, I can pay my own taxes, I can manage my checkbook, and $10 billion project award (referring again to IBM). I have worldwide recognition. Want me to show you? Did you pay your taxes? I’m asking everybody else. Give me a break.”

Grace said that there is “protocol” on the board that Patel needs to follow. Patel responded, “give me a break,” and accused Bernard of saying “F (expletive) Y-O-U” while meeting in a closed session.

“If I could finish my statement, it would be that every time this discussion comes up there’s an innuendo by Councilman Patel that we are giving away land to a friend,” Bernard said. “That is absolutely inappropriate for a councilperson to say about anyone else on this board that we are giving away land to a friend. It will be sold to a developer, it will be put out to bid, it will be public knowledge, there’s nothing behind the scenes here.”

Lachterman agreed with Bernard and said the property will be competitively bid; not given to a friend.

“I do not understand how a sitting councilman for seven years does not understand this,” Lachterman said of the process.

Lachterman said Patel’s comments were “totally uncalled for” and to insinuate that board members are stealing, lying and giving away land is insulting to the board and the town.

“It is the perception of the people; not me,” Patel said. “I did not create it.”

Patel said he has 5,000 signatures from residents who do not want Depot Square to be built. He has not submitted the signatures to the town clerk’s office, he said.

Resident Tony Grasso, a former town councilman, was critical of the board and Grace for the circus-like atmosphere, saying the supervisor must keep order at board meetings. He asked the board members to be respectful of each other and “act like gentlemen; not children.”

“When I see people, educated people, come to meetings like this and act like children, I cannot accept that,” Grasso said. “And you, Michael, have a big responsibility to run a meeting properly. If your board does not respect you, then something has to be done about that. Something has to be done about that. Either learn the rules, or get out. It’s that simple.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Yorktown

Is Yorktown’s Zoning Being Undermined?

September 13, 2017

Are Yorktown’s residential neighborhoods in danger? Is the town board undermining our existing zoning by an excessive—and inappropriate—use of an obscure provision of the zoning code that allows a parcel to be rezoned to an open-ended, anything is permissible, 100 percent negotiated “transitional zone”?

It’s time to take a closer look at this emerging ...

The Art of the Deal

I have written repeatedly that the media cannot separate Trump from his supporters.  They did not create him, so they, no matter how hard they have tried, cannot take him down. Only Trump can separate himself from his supporters.

Last Thursday I woke up to headlines saying Trump, Schumer and Pelosi have brokered a deal that will enshrine amnesty on the “Dreamers,” promise more ...

My Birthday Question

When I was 20, I was confronted with the following allegory: imagine that the wisest person who ever lived is dying. As a parting gift to the planet, the wisest one has agreed to travel the world and answer people’s questions. Luckily, after waiting in line for hours, you are able to ask your one question. What is your question?

Actually, this allegory is from a whole family of questions ...

Man of Letters

Author’s Note: Mom + Pop Culture are a couple of real characters. They could be you and me. Or not. Every so often, I eavesdrop on their conversations. Let’s listen in on what they’re saying right now about Pop’s penchant for writing Letters to the Editor…

MOM: Whatcha doin’ there, Pop?

POP: Writin’, Mom.

MOM: Writin’ what?

POP: A ...

A Shampoo by Any Other Name

“What’s in the bag?” I asked my mother as she got into the car. She had just come out of the hair salon and apparently had been talked into buying some high-end hair products.

“New shampoo,” she said with some excitement. “My old shampoo was terrible. It really dried out my hair.”

“What brand were you using?” I asked. She thought for a ...

To Home School or Not to Home School

Dear Dr. Linda,

We’re only into the second week of school and our fifth-grade son, Joey, doesn’t want to go to school again. He’s never liked school. For years we blamed his teachers. Then we put him in private school and it didn’t get better.

He’s a bright kid and self-driven. When he’s home, he’s never bored. He’s not playing video games or ...

Upcoming Events

Tue, September 26, 7:00 PM

Support Connection, Yorktown Heights

Breast and Ovarian Cancer Support Group

Health & Wellness

Sun, October 1, 9:00 AM

FDR State Park, Yorktown Heights

Annual Support-A-Walk for Breast and Ovarian ...

Other

Sun, October 1, 9:00 AM

Yorktown Jewish Center, Yorktown Heights

Open Air Flee Market

Community Calendar

Tips to Offer Children with Poor Executive Function Skill

Dana Stahl, a learning specialist and educational consultant, will address educational questions and concerns that parents may have regarding their children’s academic development and progress in school. Topics can center on how to handle homework dilemmas to what questions to ask at a CSE meeting. Questions can range from “How best do parents advocate for their children?” to ...